• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluation of my survey methods comparing Buxton and Chorley

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Evaluation In this section I am going to describe how the enquiry process can be improved by questioning how the reliability of the methods used to collect the data have affected the accuracy of the results and validity of the conclusion. Land use survey In this section I recorded the ground floor functions only of each shop and service in my specified street. One limitation is that the functions could have changed since I have last visited the shopping centre considering how bad today's economic climate is. Another limitation is the fact that I individually, classified shops and services and therefore could have got it wrong and classified a shop as comparative where it was actually convenience. Also the map where I recorded my data on could have been different to the actual shopping centre itself, as it has changed over years. I could have improved on this part of my coursework by going back to each centre and double checking to see if the data I have collected is correct. By doing the land use survey it helped to prove that Buxton has more comparison shops and services than Chorlton, but my data may not be 100% correct so therefore the results may not be accurate or reliable. ...read more.

Middle

Questionnaire This method of data collection was central to my study as many questionnaires led me to decide the position of my shopping centre on the shopping hierarchy. The main limitation for this was the fact that sample size differed between each centre. In Buxton the class grouped all of the data they collected that day which adds up to a total of 219 people, but in Chorlton there was only me and I was only able to ask 35 people, so therefore as more people was asked in Buxton the results are more reliable compared to Chorlton. Sampling technique is another limitation, as mentioned in the methodology section. One person could have been asked the same questionnaire more than once, so you have the same response twice. Another limitation is the timing of the day or the day of the week, I visited both Buxton and Chorlton on a Wednesday so it would have been fair but I did visit Chorlton in the Easter term so more people might have been out in Chorlton than expected. Also in Buxton I did my questionnaire in the morning but in Chorlton I did my questionnaire around dinner time, so more people who might ...read more.

Conclusion

Car tax disc survey I collected 50 tax disc origins form both centres car parks. I made sure that the tax disc records were collected from a range of car parks. In Buxton I collected my data form various car parks which included, the train station, the supermarket car park and the car park outside pavilion gardens. In Chorlton I collected my data from the only one car park which was the supermarket car park and then there were car parking spaces on the side of the road. I was careful to collect information at the same time of the day which I did as I collected my data in the afternoon. I had some trouble doing this as people enquired me why I was looking at their car, also many of the cars said DVLA which means they have been registered online. Another reason which might affect my outcome is that many people might have moved after they got there car taxed, so my answer might no be accurate for many reasons. By doing this study it helped me prove hypothesis two which is Buxton has a larger sphere of influence than Chorlton, as it shown that people did travel further to get to Buxton rather than Chorlton. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Human Geography section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Human Geography essays

  1. Method, Data Interpretation and Evaluation for 'How Tourism Has Changed Hawkshead'

    This technique is a primary data collection. The main advantage of this technique is it is really clear to see what the functions of each buildings are. The disadvantage is it doesn't give much information other than what the functions are. It would be better if we had an old land use survey from say 50 years

  2. Geography Pedestrian Survey

    The time of day could affect numbers of people if it was half day for example. Also the closing and opening times of shops must be taken into consideration. * In Halifax's Central Business District there are changes being made, and new buildings being built which occasionally meant that all pedestrians had to walk on one side of the road.

  1. Traffic Flow survey

    As the person did this, they recorded the data on the sheet in the spaces provided. This makes the data primary data. Other data collection techniques could have been used, but these were impractical, time consuming and unreliable methods.

  2. Is there a Shopping heirarchy in Brent

    suggesting that there are many high order shops which are quite expensive like Next, Dfs, GAME and Carphone warehouse. This also explains why people come here sometimes (as shown in graph B1), as they would not come here regularly just to spend over a �100.

  1. Retail Coursework

    15 600 433 725 750 627 16 230 270 457 477 359 17 630 710 850 1060 813 18 370 440 540 360 428 19 200 390 450 450 373 20 550 460 880 560 613 21 300 290 460 440 373 22 1027 1019 1084 1376 1124 23 200

  2. Critical Evaluation - Assisi by Norman McCaig

    He uses alliteration to say things like, "sat slumped" and "tiny twisted", these two pieces of text give a good view of the dwarfs way of sitting and his little weak legs. The simile used is, "Slumped like a half-filled sack."

  1. Does the Bentalls Shopping Centre in Kingston Upon Thames meet the needs of the ...

    or less people in a certain area would have to travel to get to the Bentalls Shopping Centre. This has a big effect on the sphere of influence because people would most probably want to travel a short distance to get to a shopping centre.

  2. ASSISI - CRITICAL EVALUATION

    By using these lines and the technique of alliteration of the letter C, MacCaig is alluding to the parable of the sower when the seed fell on the path and the birds came to eat it up. Here MacCaig is comparing the tourists that are at the church to being the birds in the parable of the sower.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work