• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11

Was the refusal of the McDonalds planning site fair and justified?

Extracts from this document...


Was the refusal of the McDonalds planning site fair and justified? Aim I aim to investigate the reasons behind the refusal of the McDonalds, and then judge whether these were fair and justified. I also aim to find out why the didn't pursue there aim when there original plan got thrown out and to see if it was likely to succeed if placed somewhere in Abergavenny, and if so, then why. Background Information In 2001, Campaigners defeated the McDonalds fast food giant by forcing planning permission for a proposed McDonalds restaurant on the outskirts of the small welsh town Abergavenny to be refused. McDonalds felt this was an excellent place for an 82-seater restaurant for a number of reasons. These were because of its positioning next to a town, which means that it offers a wide customer base, and a good area to advertise to. The area is also placed next to the 'heads of the valleys' road, which runs parallel to the coastline along the top of all the valleys that lead down to the coastline. This road is regularly full of traffic running through to the west of Wales, which means that there are plenty of potential customers which can be advertised to on their way along the main road (Fig 1), and may also go into the restaurant because they simply feel like something to eat, and as the restaurant is placed on a junction, it provides easy access to. They also felt it would be an excellent place as there is a very nearby estate, in fact on the other side of the road (Fig 2), hence even more customers. Planning inspectors turned down the proposal for safety reasons, citing that the restaurant was inaccessible to residents of Abergavenny except by crossing the A465 heads of the valleys road. The refusal was hailed by anti globalisation protesters as a victory against the American giant by small town protesters. ...read more.


The response was that: * 80% were local residents * 5% tourists * 15% from remaining areas He said that the indoor market was probably the main source for people visiting the town. I also realised that the seasons and days would affect the number of people shopping in Abergavenny. And as I went on a cold November Wednesday morning, I predicted that the turnout would not be very good and that instead if I would have come in a summer weekend I would have been likely to find a lot more people from surrounding areas and tourists. Traffic Survey Upon conducting my traffic survey at the 'Heads of the Valley Road' I found that it was a very busy a well-used road. I found out that 25 vehicles pass this point in one minute. That is a vehicle every 2.4 seconds. I also found out that on average every one in five of these vehicles was an articulated lorry. I also made and educational guess that the average speed they passed this point at was about 50-55 mph. I feel the reason for this is due to it being such a popular road, it can get you quickly and easily across the country (fig 8 and 9), and being an A road it is hardly surprising they go at such quick speeds. Councils Views To look whether the refusal was justified I was required to give the reasons why the council refused planning permission to this site. The reasons are as followed: o They felt the site was unsafe to access and so had to be scrapped. One Planning Inspector said that many drivers would be to concern about what was happening on the road to notice anybody crossing this busy 'Heads of the Valley' Road. o They felt many were against the idea of a McDonalds coming to Abergavenny. o They also felt a litter problem would come about if McDonalds was built here, and so chose against the idea. ...read more.


I stuck to it and it seems to have paid off as I have got the results I wanted, and also answered the questions in full detail, using my results to back up m reasoning and logic. I do not feel there are many improvements I could make, apart from maybe try to get more results, and also try to get the results at a time when school children will be around in order to find out what they think on the matter. I feel my questions have been answered well and so there is very little improvement that can be made there, and also I feel that my data is easily adequate enough to supply my needs, in order to answer the question. The only other improvement I can think of is that it would have been better if I would have done an investigation closer to the time of this debate going on, as I have no doubt many people have forgot about the debate and also many people have probably changed their views on the matter. This would have also gave me much more accurate results to base my conclusion on, and so therefore would have been much more likely to be true, however I feel I have completed my investigation thoroughly and to the best of my ability with the results and information I could acquire. The only thing I feel is left to do is for McDonalds to apply for planning permission again, whether it be at the same spot or a different one, as I feel they should have not give up last time, as they found a very suitable spot with an excellent case to support it, I just feel the council were very harsh on them, however with the right persistence of the matter and the right frame of mind and views, I feel they could overcome any problems the council give to them, and succeed in getting planning permission for the site, and succeed in business in the Abergavenny area. By Thomas Melia ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Human Geography section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Human Geography essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Mock Field Work - Malham

    3 star(s)

    This made are data slightly unreliable but we collected a good number to even this out. Lastly I did a land survey of Malham. For each building I located its position accurately and wrote down other relevant information: * Function e.g.

  2. Malham field work.

    Site Time of Day Children Teens Young Adults Old Adults OAP's Total 1 10.40am 3 9 2 9 2 25 1.30pm 0 0 2 10 4 16 2.10pm 13 3 2 5 4 27 Total 16 12 6 24 10 68 2 10.40am 0 0 1 21 20 42 1.30pm

  1. Windsor Investigation

    Some of the tourists required a bit more time as they did not fully understand the nature of the questions asked, this was mainly the foreign tourists who struggled with English. Doing the relevant work to construct this investigation seemed more difficult at home as I was not in a

  2. To create three different hypotheses related to tourism and tourists in Dubai that can ...

    How long are you staying in Dubai? * 1-3 days * 4-7 days * More than 1 week * More than 2 weeks * More than 3 weeks On the next page is my final questionnaire that I will use for my investigation Table showing the problems and solutions

  1. The aim of my coursework, investigating shopping patterns in Brent, is based on answering ...

    milk, bread, butter > Comparison goods - Goods which people are prepared to travel far distances to compare e.g. furniture > Convenience goods - Goods which are needed on a daily bases and are readily available e.g. milk, bread, butter > Threshold population - the minimum number of people needed

  2. Geography Project GCSE

    once per month though according to the survey, the shopper enjoys shopping in Bromley shopping centre because of its positive environment and therefore the shopper is prepared to travel the considerable distance to Bromley shopping centre on Public Transport. However I do believe this particular shopper has given me false

  1. Nottingham Lace Market

    it easier to compare the differences in the two different periods of time form before and after the changes that took place. After I completed the maps I used the data from them and converted the land use into percentages to record them in a pie chart.

  2. It was a selfish idea to build the long groyne at hengistbury head

    Seven: What coastal protection methods are already in place at HH? As we already know, there are groynes at HH, as this is the main subject of this investigation, but there are also other things in place.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work