• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Possible reform to the law concerning the Causing or Allowing the Death of a Child

Extracts from this document...


Submissions on the possible reform to the law concerning the Causing or Allowing the Death of a Child (the "new offence") Comments on the potential injustice and unsesirable social impact caused by the improper scope of potential defendants of the new offence Introduction 1. In response to the "Discussion Paper"1 dated September 2006, the writer has considered the relevant law reform in England and Wales detailed therein and the possible impact of introducing the same "new offence" of Causing or Allowing the Death of a Child or Vulnerable Adult2 as in England. Augmented duty of care 2. The new offence can be triggered where an "unlawful act"3 had resulted in the death4 of a child or a vulnerable adult in a domestic environment. 3. This new offence mandates a duty to protect or prevent harm on others that is wider than the charges of statutory protection of ill-treating or neglecting the child5 and common law protection under, inter alia, Pittwood6, Gibbons and Proctor7 and Miller8, because it doesn't require, the defendant to have, respectively, "custody, charge or care" of the victim, pre-existing contractual duty, undertaking (express or implied) to care for the victim or created a danger for the victim. ...read more.


The lack of statutory defence would widen the door of injustice. This is especially so where the charge is being laid against an abused young parent who is under the age of 16. Social Implications - distorting present interpersonal social relationship 25. The new offence has a significant potential of distorting he present interpersonal social relationship in the following ways. 26. On one hand, people will be discouraged from bearing, rising or offering help take care of children or the vulnerable in order to avoid the risk of being caught under such a wide and uncertain offence. 27. This difficulty is particularly relevant to Hong Kong where there are an increasing number of single parents who has relied on relatives or child care workers to look after the children so that he/she can return to work.17 28. On the other hand, for obvious reason, people in the society will be encouraged to stay away from, instead of helping, ones showing a certain tendency to violence, where such tendency may originally be ratified through mutual support between people, relatives, couples and friends. Conclusions 29. The writer understands that the new offence is made with a view to deter members of the society from their abusive acts, and impose an legal duty on persons close to children or the vulnerable to engage into positive steps to protect the children and the vulnerable. ...read more.


14 In order to ascertain when the risk is one of which the defendant ought to have been aware under s5(1)(d)(i) of DVCVA 15 Sally Broadbridge, The Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Bill: [HL] Criminal procedure and victims (9 June 2004), Pp 56-57 16 The Women's Commission, The Women's Commission report : women's safety in Hong Kong : eliminating domestic violence (Hong Kong : Women's Commission, [2006] ) P 31 17 Law Reform Commission of Hong Kong, Child custody and access : report Law Reform Commission of Hong Kong (Hong Kong : The Commission, 2005) P 12 18 Namely the difficulty in ascribing the responsibility of the death of children to their members of the household who caused the death of the child. Discussion Paper pp 1-2 19 R v Macaskill No. SCCRM-00-257 [2003] SASC 61 was a good example where the South Australia court faced the difficulty in ascribing the responsibility of the death of children to either of the parent who caused the death of the child due to the lack of evidence. 20 PRC became the 105th member nation states of the Convention on the Rights of the Child as of 29th August, 1990 21 Art2: Minors as used in this Law refer to citizens under the age of eighteen. 22 The Chinese Communist Party (the "Party") ?? ?? ?? ?? Criminal Law Research Paper Topic 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Child Development section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Child Development essays

  1. Study of a child.

    She asks lots of questions. She can also sort out simple objects and recognises long and short objects. She knows some shapes and logos of sport were. E.g. Nike, Adidas, etc. She know lots of colours but mostly the simple ones like red, blue, green, yellow, etc.

  2. Health, Social Care and Early years provisions.

    Perhaps introducing a leaflet drop from those who receive services from meals on wheels. This would be a direct way for information to be brought to those who cannot access it. * Obviously the health of elderly decline with age, so factors like poor eyesight could become an issue when trying to read a leaflet or information.

  1. Health and Social care

    particularly if they have a problem specific to communicative trouble for example paranoid schizophrenia. However, clients do not feel they will be losing independence by using this service. This may be because they feel that the care workers at the surgery are helpful and will not pressure them, but instead

  2. Children and the Law.

    Advise as to both the short term and long term options. (You are not required to consider adoption) In answering this question, the relevant statute that applies is the Children Act 1989 which deals with the local authorities and their powers of intervention.

  1. The main aim of this paper is to compare and contrast parental rights and ...

    Hence, the child is any person under sixteen years. Further, the legitimate child is a child born in a lawful and valid wedlock while an illegitimate child is a child born outside lawful wedlock. Under Malawian circumstances, a parent is the natural father or mother, or an adoptive father or mother, or a putative blood father of an illegitimate child.

  2. Protecting children-A Good Practice Guide. Child Protection ...

    The purpose of such an enquiry is to decide what action if any is necessary to safeguard the child's welfare. It is usual to make an initial assessment, which involves inter agency enquiries regarding the child's education, health, general welfare and any particular matters which may have acted as a

  1. Occupier's Liability

    However, able body visitors will not require such as to ensure their subjective duty of care. Thus, the duty of care is not one set of standards that can be applied to all visitors but must accommodate the different needs of different invitees.

  2. Private International Law

    Of more importance is the fact that the domicile of origin can be revived if a domicile of choice is lost and a new one not gained.5 This rule may create potential problems but as of 1976 this was still good law.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work