• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The representation of Islands in Peter Pan and Return of the Soldier

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The representation of Islands in Peter Pan and Return of the Soldier Peter Pan and Return of the Soldier can easily be seen as very different novels but there can be many important comparisons made. Although they were written closely together, Peter Pan in 1911 and Return of the Soldier in 1918, they have very different subject matters and seem to be intended for audiences of a different age. The style and narration of Peter Pan shows it to be a children's novel, with humorous quotes and exciting adventures while Return of the Solider has a much darker tone, typical to war literature at the time. Islands are used in both novels to represent themes of death and innocence as well as placing their narrators on the outside of events. In Peter Pan this idea is used to present the character of Peter as avoiding the responsibilities and feelings of adulthood through his escape to a separated world of childhood. Similarly, in Return of the Soldier, it is used to show the sadness and despair felt by Chris, and so supporting his replacement of the lost child through a return to innocence in himself. ...read more.

Middle

However what he has returned to is a world that he no longer belongs to and this creates inconsistencies and doubts in his mind, much like Peter 'he had trusted that I at least would have been no party to this conspiracy to deny that he was young'. In this way Chris in his child-like state, as Peter is connected to Neverland, is connected to Monkey Island 'why, Monkey Island's real' and the only way to restore himself completely is to take himself back to that place. However, the memories that he carries from the island can not be relied on as they are the memories of childhood 'it was strange that both Chris and she spoke of it though it were not a place, but a magic state which largely explained the actions performed in it' and as he left the island and became an adult, the memories were also corrupted by the war 'lights in our house were worse than darkness, affection worse than hate elsewhere'. Throughout Return of the Soldier the reader is placed in the position of an outsider looking into the action, largely due to the novel being narrated by a character in the story, Jenny. ...read more.

Conclusion

This idea is introduced right from the first moment they meet, as a kiss is not shown for what it is 'I don't mean a kiss, I mean a thimble' and the theme of love as pretence grows on Peter's side as they become closer while it breaks down as Wendy grows up 'what are your exact feelings for me?' This is mirrored in the part of Return of the Soldier where Kitty dresses in her wedding dress as this shows the total lack of sexuality within their relationship, making her appear beautiful but in a completely desexualised way 'she looked cold as moonlight, as virginity, but precious; the falling candlelight struck her hair to bright, pure gold'. This removes the aspect of desire and highlights her grief experienced from being removed from her husband's life. Also in Return of the Soldier, sexuality becomes something that can only be experienced in the separated world of the island. Unlike in Peter Pan, the relationship between Chris and Margaret is something that is free and without the restraints of society, becoming something pure and without corruption away from the war 'seemed to him a guarantee that theirs was a changeless love which would persist if she were old or maimed or disfigured'. 2,050 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Child Development section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Child Development essays

  1. Why family structures are changing.

    Jakes social needs are mainly met by Kane as Kane like to play football he encourages his dad to get out and meet new people in the park, his dad use to meet these when he was younger and more able, but thanks to his encouragement he has taken up

  2. Compare the use of fantasy in 'The Poor Relation's Story' and 'Superman and Paula ...

    By knowing that her fantasy adventures were not true enabled her to accept the truth when she needed to and not use her fantasy to escape into the sky and beyond with Superman. The narrator describes in much detail how she felt towards this newly exposed part of the world;

  1. Essay on Poetry - childhood

    Metaphorically speaking, when the father was taking off his clothes it was like he was taking of his personality and attitude towards the children that he has on a Sunday morning. The children in this poem have unfortunately experienced a harsh childhood, due to their father's intolerance towards them and their mother.

  2. English Literature Exam Essays

    Police records from that time describe some circles as having quite a confused atmosphere, where the "entire conversation turn[ed] on revolutionary themes" interrupted often with "revolutionary songs". . . [and] toasts to "the French republic, the success of the red flag, and revolution in general," which were "triumphantly received" by the participants (Brower 196).

  1. "The use of innocence in literature is never innocent" How far do you agree ...

    In "Clear light of day", it is fascinating to observe through the eyes of the children the somewhat cold and ambiguous relationship which their parents have ; to sense, as the children do, the arrogance which all adults feel towards Aunt Mira, and to grasp the mixture of feelings and

  2. Unit 1, Drama exploration of childhood

    6 months. We chose to do one year down the line because after this long period of time everything the parents think and know about the baby would be confirmed. Any shorter and the baby might just be acting up a bit and the parents might miss-assume his real character so they would have a different response.

  1. THE TRUTH ON AUTHORITATIVE PARENTING STLYE

    While defining, I am also attempted to compare the effectiveness of reasoning and punishment with each other and with other disciplinary responses. Another advantage of a reasoning-punishment combination is that it enhances the subsequent effectiveness of reasoning when used by itself.

  2. Childhood and Innocence

    I acknowledge the fact that I had a difficult time throughout my childhood, but that didn't stop me from growing stronger. Through my sufferings I persevered and because of this, I am proud to be myself. I am proud of my childhood.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work