• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'The welfare principle is unhelpful. It is indeterminate. What parents, children and family law practitioners need are clear rules in order to predict the outcomes of problems and conflicts'

Extracts from this document...


'The welfare principle is unhelpful. It is indeterminate. What parents, children and family law practitioners need are clear rules in order to predict the outcomes of problems and conflicts' It is argued by many academics that the welfare principle is the fundamental aspect of family law regarding the protection of children. The primary reason for having such a system in place is to ensure that the rights and feeling of a child are never over looked, before and during litigation. In order to decide whether this principle is 'indeterminate' it is essential to evaluate the manner in which it is practically applied. The recognition of children's rights was increased after the enactment of the Children Act 1989. The central reason behind the new act was to modernise the law relating to children in order to improve the judicial system when cases regarding children were being heard. The act does not give a clear definition of what the term 'welfare' actually means. This can be seen as an advantage as by interpreting the act as whole, the judge will be able to infer the central meaning of welfare. The central principle is clearly stated under s.1(1) ...read more.


1(3). The checklist is mandatory; it is not a list of 'checks' as such but a list of things to be regarded. There are also problems with the checklist, such as overlapping and conflict between elements. The first point takes into consideration the feelings and wishes of the child. The courts however are not limited to listening to the 'Gillick competent' child. In M v M (Transfer of Custody), the Court of Appeal said that the trial judge was wrong to ignore the strong views of a 12 year old girl. However in Re P (Minors: Wardship) Lady Butler-Sloss stated, the wishes of a child would be taken into account but they did not bind the courts. The next condition takes into account the child's physical, emotional and educational needs. In the New Zealand case of Walker v Walker and Hanson it was said that this included material welfare and the provision of a pleasant home. The next provision is the likely effect on the child of any change in circumstances. In D v M (custody Appeal) the Court of Appeal held that continuity of care was important to a child's security, particularly in the early years. ...read more.


It is possible to argue that it is perfectly helpful to parents, children and family law practitioners because without this system in place a number of cases may not have been correctly decided. It is clear from Mnookin' article 'Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law' that family law cases are persons orientated, in that the adults and children must be evaluated and not the events. It is possible to say to have strict principals in place will cause a flaw in the system. This is because family law is based on the feelings and rights of individuals. If these factors are not adhered to then it will lead to rigidity within the system. The current system allows judges to use their discretion when passing judgement. However, this discretion is not unlimited as shown in the case of Re W. When judges depart from the evidence of welfare officers then they must give good reasons for doing so. This helps in creating transparency in the decision and the system. It is possible to argue the welfare system is not indeterminate, it allows judges to follow a clear and precise structure of the law by means of the Children Act in order to establish an isolated decision based directly on the case. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Child Development section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Child Development essays

  1. Why family structures are changing.

    until later on in life this has a number of implications of the effects on families for example, if couples are leaving it later on in life to have children then they wont find out if they are impotent, this leads to more families becoming childless however it will lead to an increase in families adopting.

  2. Explain How the Principles of Natural Law might be applied to Decisions About Fertility ...

    Essentially, the principles of Natural Law would refuse the decision of fertility treatment, however, it is possible to argue the principles so that they become more lenient. The problem with the argument is that it is based on if God exists and if there is a final cause for everything,

  1. Health, Social Care and Early years provisions.

    This could not only cause a lot of upset to that resident from the stress of moving, but also it could possibly mean that they are further away from their families. In some cases it might be a necessity of the resident's family having to move nearer to the residential home.

  2. Health and Social care

    Staff work hard as a team and feel it is important that parents can build up a good relationship with all staff members. It is important for children to bond closely with the care workers as they will spend a lot of time with them during the day.

  1. Identifying Data of Family.

    The ability of MB and FB to meet each other's affective needs is a sign of a functional family because "through fulfillment of the affective function, the family enhances the qualities of humanness, the stabilization of personality and behavior, relatability, and self esteem of family members" (Friedman et al., 2003).

  2. Children and the Law.

    In order for the child to be placed into the care of the local authority the child has to be considered as being 'in need' which section 17(10) of the act defines as being a child who requires local authority services to maintain or achieve a reasonable standard of health

  1. The main aim of this paper is to compare and contrast parental rights and ...

    THE RELEVANCE OF CUSTODY OF CHILDREN The word custody has two, meanings.8 In the wide sense it means the 'bundle of powers' exercisable over the child. This is synonymous with the expression 'parental rights.' Thus a person who has custody of a child, does not only keep the child

  2. Child development study - I will compare my visits and look at Aroushs development ...

    Aroush mum told me that Aroush has a few friends around her age, who live on her street, and she likes to see them often, but she doesn?t like sharing her toys with them. She sits beside them while she is playing with her toys, or she watches as another toddler plays with their toys.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work