• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

There is plenty to suggest that women never got away from their traditional role. Neil DeMarco, The Second World War, Hodder & Stoughton, 2004. In your opinion are the views expressed by Neil DeMarco justified?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The Second World War begun on the 3rd September 1939 and affected women massively. Not only did they have to go out to work in places like factories but they also had to do their traditional roles of cooking, cleaning and looking after the children. The women had to adopt new roles because the men were no longer there to do their jobs. In this piece of coursework I shall focus on how reliable the quote by Neil DeMarco is ("There is plenty to suggest that women never got away from their traditional role."). In my opinion I think that this suggests that the women were in the home all the time. And I shall look at evidence supporting and disputing DeMarco's interpretation throughout this coursework. In some ways it could be reliable because women still had their traditional roles because the jobs they had were giving out tea or being a librarian but this quote may not be reliable because women were more free and many worked in either the factories, being part of the land girls or WRNS. I shall look at a variety of sources to support or dispute this interpretation , primary sources, like diary accounts and pictures or ,secondary sources, from historians like Carol Harris or Juliet Gardiner. I shall also look at films such as Land Girls, Hope and Glory and Charlotte Grey. I think that Neil DeMarco's interpretation will be quite reliable because many women did have traditional roles but others didn't. In this first section I shall explore the ways by which Neil DeMarco's interpretation is correct and the reliability of it. There is plenty to suggest that Neil DeMarco was correct and women didn't get away from their traditional roles in the home. For example, all women had to struggle with the introduction of rationing and also feeding their children on limited food. They had to used ration booklets with daily coupons as there was only one other way to feed their children. ...read more.

Middle

But the role of nursing was very important in the armed forces because they helped injured soldiers which is like the caring people that women are. If nurses weren't there then the men wouldn't have as much a reason to fight as it would bring six people out of the war effort instead of just one nurse to one injured man. One form of nursing was from the 'Army Nursing Corps', it was voluntary but was fully part of the army's nursing sector. A poster(2) shows a women looking very glamorous and showing that women should volunteer so this shows that Neil DeMarco's interpretation is correct in that they need to care for injured men. This source is reliable because the woman looks glamorous and womanly even in the army and shows DeMarco is correct but this was made by the government so it could have been censored. This could be useful because it was made at the time and encourages women to join into a very traditional role and therefore the attitude had not changed towards women however it was made by the government so it is biased and probably censored. However, there are other sources that suggest that Neil DeMarco was incorrect and in this next section I shall be looking at the ways that Neil DeMarco is incorrect in his interpretation. There is plenty of evidence to suggest that Neil DeMarco was incorrect and that women got away from their traditional roles in the workforce. Women who went into the workforce were in the factories as they needed to go into them because there were no men anymore to do their jobs. Source F3 shows that women needed to come into the war effort to bring out planes and encourages women to go into work. However, it is a poster to boost morale which could have been censored and also we don't know whether the women actually were going into the factories. ...read more.

Conclusion

This could be useful because it shows women away from their traditional roles and providing for the country however this is a film so it is not as useful to me. This is moderately useful. At home the sexual morals changed and 1 in 3 babies were born illegitimate. The divorce rate rose because of these new sexual morals. The mothers went into work because they needed to help the war effort even though women who had children weren't supposed to work. There was also a lot of dying in the war and more women had died at home than the soldiers in action. So, this shows that women were more respected, they were the defenders of the family and they had more rights to do what they wanted. To conclude, I think that in some ways Neil DeMarco is correct because some women had to go into the factories and were paid less than men, some women still agreed with the old sexual morals. Many women still had important roles at home, cooking, cleaning and providing a good home for children. However, I think that in other ways DeMarco is incorrect because women had non-traditional roles being part of the SOE, the Land Girls and other parts of the armed forces. I think that the roles of the SOE are shown well in the film Charlotte Gray and shows how life affected young women and also it is backed up because it actually happened to Violette Szabo (F10). So, I think that really Juliet Gardiner's interpretation is more reliable to Neil DeMarco's interpretation and the interpretations that were shown at the time because it shows the full picture of all of the women's roles in the Second World War and is a good conclusion because she wrote a whole book about women in the Second World War and is an academic book with a lot of references involved and that as a historian in this era she has more sources and has a benefit. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Effect of Civilians in WW2

    Therefore it is difficult to find out about the Blitz because lots of sources are propaganda and one-sided. To become more reliable, they would need to be cross-referenced more. Life changed for men considerably during World War Two. If men were fit enough, they were conscripted into the army.

  2. The Changing Role and Status of Women Since 1945

    Source D, from a successful working mother, tells us how one woman felt that she had to be at home with her children. It is likely that the reason for this woman's decision was that she felt pressurised by society and media, and that other women felt similarly pressurised.

  1. It was the lack of buffalo that killed off the Plains Indian culture in ...

    The liquor used in the Indian trade was in most cases transported to the Indian country in the form of alcohol. Once there the traders could cut the alcohol two or three times with water and still produce the desired effect, which was to get the Indians hooked.

  2. The object of this coursework is to gather information and data, on how woman ...

    have chosen this article as a source as it clearly shows how the general public reacted and felt towards the violence that the suffragettes committed. It seems many people feared them, and felt that they were in danger. The newspaper clearly gives the view that the suffragettes won't be helping

  1. Free essay

    History medcine overview

    They provided transport taking risks as ambulance drivers and despatch drivers. Soon after that attitudes towards women in the 'Public Sphere' also changed. The male population realised that women are capable, suitable, and diligent and that they would do an incredible job in politics.

  2. Gallic war

    * Important pieces of legislation passed during joint consulship (known as Licino/Pompeian laws): * Restoration of tribunate to legislative powers and right of veto. * Revival of censorship. Censors immediately revised senatorial list, removed 64 senators and enrolled new senators.

  1. How and why writers have explored different views of the First World War. ...

    This poster also reinforces the idea that going to war will make your family proud of you. Jessie Pope was an English poet, writer and journalist best known for her patriotic, motivational poems published in The Daily Mail during World War I to encourage Army recruitment.

  2. Book Review. Treasury of Royal Scandals is a national bestseller book written by ...

    Rasputin influenced and dominated the royal family through Alexandra, the wife of the tsar, who was blind to his inner intentions. Although Alexandra refused to see this, the people saw perfectly. The people knew that Rasputin was a fraud whose influence on society was becoming more and more widespread as

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work