• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analsysis of two sources on the Reichstag Fire.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History Assignment B Answers 1) Sources A and B support each other to an extent. Source A suggests van der Lubbe and a few other communists were responsible for starting the Reichstag fire and starting several other smaller fires elsewhere in Berlin. However in source B van der Lubbe admits that only he was responsible for planning to set the Reichstag on fire; Van der Lubbe said 'I can only repeat that I set fire to the Reichstag all by myself.' This shows that source B does support some points portrayed in source A. However, when Rudolf Diels interviewed van der Lubbe in source A, Lubbe made Diels believe that he could have acted on his own, 'The voluntary confessions of van der Lubbe made me believe he had acted alone.' Also Diels thought that starting a fire was an easy job, he said that 'he could have easily set fire to the old furniture, the heavy curtains, and the bone dry, wooden panels.' ...read more.

Middle

Van der Lubbe may have been tortured into saying what the Nazi Party wanted because by saying that a communist/s started the fire, Hitler would have an excuse to arrest many of his political opponents (using the decree for the protection of people and state.) Both sources are very convenient towards the Nazis and are suited to what the audience want to hear- Source A was to be suited to the judges at the Nuremberg Trials of 1945-47 and Source B was to fulfil what the Nazis wanted to hear and do. Therefore, both sources may be inaccurate and therefore not very reliable. 2. When Diels wrote his account, it was well after World War II- This may mean that the source is inaccurate. Straight after the war had ended another one started; this one was called the Cold War or 'the War of Words'. USA, Britain and France were fighting against the communist (USSR). ...read more.

Conclusion

In addition, there are some major concerns when using this account as a primary source. These concerns are due to the content and motive for writing the account. One of the major problems with the account is when it was written- a full 12 years after the events occurred. Although the burning of the Reichstag may be hard to forget, there is no way that Diels could remember everything that happened in the source, especially in such detail. Diels gives hugely complicated quotations, such as G�ring shouting; 'There will be no mercy now. Anyone who stands in our way will be cut down. Every communist will be shot or hanged. Everybody supporting the communists must be arrested.' This quote could not have so accurately remembered from such a long time ago, it is probably made up, making the account even more unreliable and inaccurate. As a result, the point of view of the account Diels put himself into may not represent of what he truly believes. Clearly, Source A is not a very reliable source due to the circumstances Rudolf Diels was in. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. The Reichstag Fire-Coursework B

    Out of the 24, which were put on trial, 12 were sentenced to death by hanging and 7 received prison sentences from 10years to life. Goring committed suicide a few hours before he was due to be executed. Diels might have been trying to take away the attention from the Nazis and putting it on the communists.

  2. GCSE History Coursework: Reichstag Fire 1) ...

    This decree that Hindenburg is handing to Hitler in the cartoon is the 'Decree for the Protection of the People and the State' issued on February 28th that allowed Hitler amongst other things to arrest leading Communists. In that respect, the Reichstag fire was of great advantage to Hitler in his run for power.

  1. Reichstag fire coursework assignments

    Some of the generals disliked Hitler and the Nazis. Hitler's arch rival Rohm was a A tough soldier who had thought both in the German army in first world war and in the freikrops after it, he was one of Hitler's earliest supporters, he had helped create the SA as

  2. History Coursework – the Reichstag Fire

    Source D supports source C as it was released shortly after the fire and suggests the control of the Communists for the advantage of the people, this would have gained votes in election as it produced fear and security. Source C suggests that Hitler gain votes using the Reichstag fire to eventually lead to his dictatorship.

  1. Modern World History Coursework - Reichstag Sourcework

    In doing this, Diels may have gained the extra amount of trust that permitted his continued employment in the post-war German government as an undersecretary. In conclusion, the points previously stated mainly show that the account of Rudolf Diels is very unreliable and cannot possibly be used as conclusive proof.

  2. IGCSE History Coursework Assignment B - Source Analysis of the Reichstag Fire

    This is one of the reasons why his account might be altered, making it unreliable, in order to keep himself alive. Another reason the judges could use to get him into jail is that he was one of the top Nazis to be prosecuted.

  1. Source based work about Van der Lubbe's involvement in the Reichstag fire of February ...

    In conclusion, Source A cannot be seen as a very reliable source as it is written several years after the event (at least 12 years since the war ended in 1945), is biased towards the Nazis, and its tone was most probably influenced by the political atmosphere of the time.

  2. Why did the Nazis set fire to the Reichstag

    Through gaining power, Nazis now had the excuse they need to tighten the screw on their oppositions. Nazis could execute and arrest their political enemies without considering any other factors. They can intimidate their votes and control the voters' decision by watching over them as they crossed their ballot papers.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work