• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the significance of the Treaty of Versailles in the reasons for the eventual collapse of Democracy in Germany between 1

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Assess the significance of the Treaty of Versailles in the reasons for the eventual collapse of Democracy in Germany between 1918-1934. Despite that 'the idea of democracy had finally succeeded in shaping the constitution and institutions of Germany, the Treaty and other significant factors were evident in the inevitable collapse of Democracy in Germany. The real position of the Weimar Republic was determined by the unequivocal military defeat of the German empire and its severe restriction of power in the Versailles peace treaty.'1 Emphasis upon the ideological establishment of pluralistic democracy within Weimar Republic, 'was resisted and continually undermined both by powerful and influential forces in the central government administration and by local business interests.'2 Bessel suggests 'the collapse of Weimar democracy was due to a peculiar combination of long-term and short-term pressures. These pressures, many of which are found in other industrial societies, came together with particular force in Weimar Germany.'3 Despite the significant influence of the Treaty and its reparations evoking a sense of hatred and anger amongst the German populace, there were numerous factors contributing to the eventual collapse of Democracy. 'Economic constraints in particular, both domestic and international, greatly limited the possibilities for positive political actions.'4 Democracy was weakened severely after the onset of the economic depressions in 1922-23 and 1929-1930. ...read more.

Middle

crash had peculiarly serious implications, given the dependence of the German economy on short-term loans from abroad which were rapidly withdrawn.'13 Some of the staggering results included the rise of unemployment to over 6 million, by the beginning of 1933. 'No compromise could be reached between alternative schemes, with unions, employers, and members of the different parties all having very different positions on the matter, characterised by varying degrees of intransigence.'14 The presence of extensive hyperinflation was also prominent in stirring the disillusioned middle class. Thus, fiscal and monetary problems caused the first presidential cabinet to be appointed to rule without serious regard to democracy in March 1930, amounting to the collapse of the inherently unstable and ill-fated Weimar Republic. Salmon indeed comments that 'Germany had undergone traumatic economic crises, which had undermined the integrity of the Weimar Republic.'15 The presence of underlying political structural problems were evident and prominent in the eventual collapse of a democratic Germany. These contentions lay 'deeper than the criticisms of the (Weimar) constitutional framework.'16 Despite the success encountered by the republic during the Reichstag elections of January 1919, difficulties were manifested in the very nature of the Weimar political establishment. 'The republic was confronted by political opposition from the extreme left and right, whilst its democratic supporters were faced with the ongoing problem of creating and maintaining government coalitions.'17 The 'final political crisis' of 1932 was instrumental in the demise of the Weimar Republic and the triumph of Nazism. ...read more.

Conclusion

1319 2 McElligott, A., The Collapse of Weimar, History Today, from the compendium, Book III 3 Bessel, R., Why Did the Weimar Republic Collapse?, from the compendium, Book III. pp. 148 4 ibid, pp. 121 5 ibid, pp. 133 6 Bracher, K.D., The Nazi Takeover, , from the compendium Book IV, pp. 1319 7 Layton, G., From Bismarck to Hitler: Germany 1890-1933, pp. 89 8 ibid, pp. 90 9 ibid 10 ibid, pp. 91 11 Bessel, R., Why Did the Weimar Republic Collapse?, from the compendium, Book III. pp. 124 12 ibid 13 Fulbrooke, M., A Concise History of Germany, pp. 172 14 ibid, pp. 173 15 Salmon, P., Weimar Republic: Could it have survived?, Modern History Review, from the compendium Book III, pp. 10 16 Layton, G., From Bismarck to Hitler: Germany 1890-1933, pp. 98 17 ibid 18 Salmon, P., Weimar Republic: Could it have survived?, (1992) Modern History Review, from the compendium Book III, pp. 9 19 Bessel, R., Why Did the Weimar Republic Collapse?, from the compendium, Book III. pp. 141 20 ibid 21 ibid, pp. 132 22 James, H., Economic Reasons for the Collapse of the Weimar Republic, from the compendium Book III. pp. 30 23 ibid, pp. 133 24 Bracher, K.D., The Nazi Takeover, , from the compendium Book IV, pp. 1319 25 Salmon, P., Weimar Republic: Could it have survived?, (1992) Modern History Review, from the compendium Book III, pp. 10 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Treaty Of versailles

    5 star(s)

    This further angered the German nation and made the treaty unfair. This was a major concern of all powers especially France. Conscription was banned which meant that all recruits had to be on a voluntary basis. Furthermore Germany was allowed to build armoured vehicles, submarines or aircraft.

  2. Explain how the Treaty of Versailles created many problems for Germany in the period ...

    He also wanted to put an end to 'passive resistance' and people disheartened the government. Hitler was called out to sort out a disturbance so he left but Kahr managed to escape. Kahr informed the army and police of Hitler's attempts for this putsch.

  1. What factors best describe the collapse of Weimar and the rise of Hitler?

    The Treaty of Versailles in 1919, lumbered Germany with a war debt she was unlikely/able to repay. When the Germans failed to keep up repayments to the French, they responded by invading the Ruhr, an industrial region of Germany. The resulting economic crisis caused by the general strike in the

  2. Account for the failure of democracy in Germany in the period 1928 to 1934.

    Ideologically, structurally and politically the Nazi party was superior to the Weimar Democracy especially in the period 1928-1934. Ideologically, historian Hans Mommson claims the Nazi Party was a "catch all party" in that the party's nationalistic, socialist and racist policies were attractive to large sections of German society.

  1. The collapse of the Weimar republic.

    Another blunder made by Bruning, elucidating his fault in the breakdown of the government, was his failure to persuade the Nazis and the DNVP to allow an extension of Hindenburg's term as President, causing Hindenburg's credence in Bruning to cascade, inducing a shift within Weimar towards the right, creating better relations between Hitler and the government.

  2. Was the collapse of the Weimar Republic inevitable?

    The workers in the Ruhr were instructed no to co-operate with the occupiers and in effect, strike. A massive increase in public spending was met by a reduction in taxation due to the Ruhr being paralysed. This led to the collapse of Germany's currency, and also hyperinflation in Germany.

  1. In what way, and for what reasons, did the Treaty of Versailles cause political ...

    Hyperinflation resulted since Germany was not producing anything; its industrial heartland had been destroyed and yet the number of notes in its economy was increasing. The German currency soon became worthless and prices were constantly rising. Discontent with the political system and Weimar government continued to grow as the situation worsened.

  2. Free essay

    Why did the Weimar Republic collapse in 1933?

    Germany had no money to invest in industry. They were bankrupt and had to pay reparations. Poverty was rife in Germany as there was no social welfare system and no money. In a bid to stop the desperate poverty, they used soup kitchens in the street.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work