• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"By the beginning of 1929, the survival prospects of the Weimar Republic looked good." Discuss the extent to which this statement can be agreed with.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"By the beginning of 1929, the survival prospects of the Weimar Republic looked good." Discuss the extent to which this statement can be agreed with. The statement that by the beginning of 1929 the survival prospects of the Weimar republic looked good brings many different political, economic and social views of the events and attitudes of that year and the 4 years (from 1924) leading up to it to a head. This essay will argue that while the statement can be evidenced by several improvements in different sectors, these improvements were only on the surface. If the fundamental flaws of the republic (exhibited in destabilizing factors to be discussed) are looked at accurately, its failures were inevitable. The great depression merely accelerated this inevitability. One argument that that supports the idea that survival prospects of Weimar looked good by 1929 is economic. The terror that the German people felt when faced with reparations was to be allayed by foreign minister Gustav Stressemans orchestration of the introduction of the Dawes plan in1924 (tailored to his policy of fulfillment of the Versailles treaty). The newly establish Rentenmark currency was stabilized by this influx of almost 25.5 billion marks worth of foreign capital. ...read more.

Middle

Another argument that supports the idea that the survival prospects of the Weimar Republic is political. In the early years of the republic leading up to 1923 there were no less than seven coups, and the challenges faced by the republic from the right (in Bavaria, where the army swore allegiance to the general and not the republic) as well as from the left (the spartacist uprising). The years after this (1924-29) were comparatively stable, with no major coups to speak of. In addition to this, Democratic Party majority in parliament had increased from 52% in May 1924 to 735 in May 1928. The election of Hindenburg as president in 1925 can also be seen as a positive step towards eventual cohesion of political systems, as the perception of him as a traditionalist was an assurance to conservatives that the Republic would protect their interests. Thus it can be seen why it can be argued that apparent political stability by 1929 contributed to the impression that the prospects of the Weimar Republics survival were good, and that had the depression of 1931 not occurred these political positives would have continued. However, with every positive comes a negative, and there are many historians with the belief that such arguments are superficial and ignorant of the very real (and evidenced) ...read more.

Conclusion

Workers were alienated economically also, with financial minister Bruning's harsh tax laws continued implementation (a move put into action with the noble goal of improving the economy following the hyperinflation of 1923).Agricultural production was hindered greatly by falling food prices, and the tough times faced by farmers and rural people were ripe for other solutions (which they found, as shown in the jump in the communist KPDs' rural membership by 10% in 1928). It can be seen that by 1929, all was definitely not positive economically and that this would not mean well for the prospects of Weimar's' survival, even with out The Great depression of 1931. In conclusion, it can be seen that while there were some positive economic, political and foreign policy developments from 1924 to 1929, these were merely on the surface and covered innumerable flaws in the Weimar system. The lack of understanding of democracy in German society, the negative perceptions and revisionist ideals leftover from the Versailles Treaty and the structurally induced economic weaknesses were all evident throughout the time period, and would have caused the republic eventual downfall. The great depression of 1931, while it sped up this process, was merely a catalyst. ?? ?? ?? ?? 5/8/2007 Isabel Marden ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. How great were the problems that the Weimar Republic faced from its beginning?

    This made the people feel that the Weimar Republic had sold out Germany by agreeing to the peace treaty and began to accept Lundendorff's theory. Many politicians against the Weimar Republic had the opportunity to blame social and economic problems such as inflation and depression on the treaty of Versailles and blame Weimar for accepting it.

  2. Was the Schlieffen plan the cause of Germany's defeat?

    Another cause of the USA entering the war was that the USA didn't want to cut themselves from Europe because they were making a lot of money from supplying weapons to the allies, also the American government were lending war loans which in 1917 had amounted to 2 billion dollars

  1. 'By The Beginning of 1929, the prospects for the survival of the Weimar Republic ...

    Some governments only lasted three or four months. With all this change people are going to start to become irritated by the inability of the elite to hold government. This left the door open in 1929 for a dictatorship or a strong coalition to come into power however this door

  2. By the beginning of 1929 the prospects for the survival of the Weimar Republic ...

    Now the reputation of the Weimar Republic had always been very low, their first action being the signing of the hated Treaty of Versailles in 1919, an action resented by Germans all the way up to 1929; 10 years later.

  1. To what extent had the Weimar Republic achieved political, economic and social stability by ...

    The Weimar republic's greatest weakness was its failure to establish lasting political stability. I. Kershaw once said that, ?a stable coalition is an oxymoron?. Germany's prosperity after 1924 was financed for the most part by borrowed money. The basic weakness was that the government was using short term loans to fund long term projects.

  2. Nazi Germany Revision 1918-45

    But Hitler was not prepared to do this and worked to establish a Nazi dictatorship. New Reichstag elections called for 5 March (Hitler hoped to win a majority) * Reichstag Fire, Emergency Powers, March 1933 Election, Enabling Law. Emergency powers used to control political meetings.

  1. WWII History Revision Notes. How far did the Weimar Republic Recover between 1924-1928.

    Edelweiss Pirates: Groups of teenagers who accepted Jews and BEAT UP HITLER YOUTH. But they were executed. Nazi Racial Policy[r]: The problems: 1. Aryan races were mixing with other races 2. There may have been Aryan Jews but the Nazi Party could not tell if they were Jewish or not The Answer: 1.

  2. Germany 1916-1945 revision notes.

    4. There are many factors that caused hyperinflation. It was initially caused by the Treaty of Versailles, I.e. Britain, USA and France. We took away the land of Germany which was heavily industrialised, these industrialised areas made valuable goods which would help pay of the reparations which the Treaty of Versailles made them pay.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work