• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Christopher Columbus - Our Nations Noble Founder... Or Is He?

Extracts from this document...


Geoffrey Platt 10/8/01 USEM 55A Roxanne Davila Christopher Columbus: Our Nations Noble Founder...Or Is He? People today try very carefully to be politically correct in order to ensure the equality of all races and creeds. When examining and studying historical events, it is unavoidable but to look at the 15th century through the lenses of a 21st century thinker. Accordingly, many modern historians have begun to view Columbus more critically than historians of the past. These modern day historical analysts tend to judge Columbus, his work and behavior in terms of modern day society (in which he would be considered politically uncorrect) and neglect to appreciate the good that he did. Professional historians always keep in mind that Columbus created history over four hundred years ago, when societies had different standards and morals. One must take into consideration the time period and environment in which he lived, and his reasons and justifications for his actions. The 15th century was an era of change. Many events that occurred during this time profoundly effected European society and culture and, in fact, created a template for a totally new environment that would eventually change the course of history forever. ...read more.


(P.224) Columbus' writings, for the most part, were undoubtedly addressed to please Ferdinand and Isabella; however, upon analyzing his descriptions, it is clear that he had other motives, as well. He was an adventurer and explorer at heart and was not purely motivated by selfish means, as many believe, to earn quick riches and fame and to spread the word of Christianity. Columbus wrote in his log, "Both the Indians and Spaniards were much grieved that they did not understand one another, since they wanted to ask about our country and we wanted to learn about theirs."(P. 214) These voyages to find an alternative route to India, instead, led to the very first encounters with another people that had been unknown to the rest of the world. Columbus and his crewmen were curious to learn more about who they had 'discovered' and exactly where they had landed. I feel it is wrong for people to depict Columbus as a greedy individual whose sole purpose in his voyages was to retrieve as much gold and convert as many people to Christianity as he could. ...read more.


But in order to leave them happy, the Admiral ordered that everything should be paid for and gave them glass beads, hawk's bells, little brass bells and suchlike."(p. 171) How Columbus is portrayed in the texts thus far is mostly one-sided and therefore one can not form an educated opinion on Columbus' personality. However, I believe, Columbus acted in a manner in which he was accustomed. In accordance with accepted normalcies and behaviors of his time, people believed that the conqueror should reap the benefits of those he conquered. I often feel that people judge Columbus' figure without fully understanding the situation in which he lived. In my opinion, Columbus is a man that brought forth a great number of changes, which bettered the way of life for the people of his time, and of today. For, if it was not for his voyages and his discovery of the this New World, then great nations such as the United States, Canada, Mexico, Brazil, and many others may not have been founded. I wouldn't consider Columbus the sole discoverer of America but I would definitely not deny him the glory that he truly deserves. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Christopher Columbus. Gold and fame were Christopher Columbuss main purposes for trying to ...

    He would have gained the Church's respect and trust if he converted Asians. However, although nobody supported him when he first expressed his wishes to travel West, he was adamant that he was the 'Chosen One'. When the Church refused to fund his expedition, he didn't dare speak against him

  2. On balance the league of nations proved to be a failure in the 1920(TM)s. ...

    illness, leprosy, as well as starting a global campaign to exterminate mosquitoes. The League's actions greatly reduced cases of malaria and yellow fever in later decades. Even the USSR, which opposed the League, took its Health Committee's advice on preventing plague in Siberia.

  1. The league of Nations

    The Germans felt picked on so resented the league. The League's members acted in their own interests, and not necessarily in the interests of the League. France and Britain wanted to ensure security from Germany, so they acted in a way that would be best for its empire. For example, in Vilna, 1920, Poland invaded Vilna, and though the

  2. Explain how the changing reputation of Columbus illuminates the nature of historical study.

    This is true of many historical myths spreading across many nations. In Britain we have the Spirit of the Blitz as our national psyche, yet its is never mentioned by families who may have had deaths caused by the Blitz.

  1. The California Gold Rush.

    of his village disappeared when the first proof of the gold strike reached them in June, leaving little more than woman and soldiers at the army post. A crew of carpenters who were at work on a schoolhouse "threw down their saws and planes, shouldered their picks, and are off for the Yuba.

  2. Speech on Christopher Columbus

    This idea was carried back to Europe, setting the tone for the relationship between the natives and the European explorers. On one a later journey Columbus?s later voyages he ordered his men to complete certain tasks to ensure their survival as a colony.

  1. St.David's effect on Christianity in Wales

    first at Brefi around 560 and the second at Caerleon (the "Synod of Victory") around 569. His best-known miracle is said to have taken place when he was preaching in the middle of a large crowd at the Synod of Brefi: the village of Llanddewi Brefi stands on the spot

  2. The Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus

    25/12/1492 Flagship Santa Maria sinks off Hispaniola. Columbus founds La Navidad. 06/01/1493 Pinz�n rejoins Columbus. 16/01/1493 Columbus departs Hispaniola for Spain in the Ni�a. 14/02/1493 Ni�a and Pinta are separated again in a fierce storm. 15/02/1493 Sights Santa Maria Island in the Azores. 04/03/1493 Arrives at Lisbon, Portugal. 15/03/1493 Ni�a and Pinta return separately to Palos, Spain.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work