• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Civil Rights Coursework Question 3

Extracts from this document...


How useful are sources 'D' & 'E' in helping us to understand why some black Americans rejected Martin Luther King? The author of Source 'E' is useful to us as Malcolm X is a Black American against Martin Luther King. This source is also useful as it is Malcolm X's autobiography so that means that it could be a primary source however, the date on which the source was published makes it a secondary source because it was written seven years after M.L.K.'s high, the march on Birmingham in 1963. The fact that the source has been written seven years after the height of M.L.K.'s career also affects the usefulness of the source because in these seven years Martin Luther King's methods could have changed. There could be a number of different purposes for this source. As it is Malcolm X's autobiography, it could be to entertain so that he will earn many monies. ...read more.


In contrast, the source does not tell us about doing these things the illegal way or with violence. These factors make this source not totally reliable as it only talks about not integrating with the white society and not forgiving them. The tone of the source is mainly exaggerated, as Malcolm X was a political opponent of Martin Luther King. This therefore makes the source unreliable, as it is only to do with down grading M.L.K.'s way of integration between both societies. Overall, this source is only partially useful, as it does not really help us understand why some Black Americans rejected the methods of Martin Luther King. This is mainly because the source only talks about one of the factors in M.L.K.'s method, integration, and why Malcolm X rejected it. The origin of source 'D' is partly useful as the source was written by Martin Luther King and he himself may have actually understood why some Black Americans rejected him. ...read more.


What Martin Luther King is trying to get across here is that some Black Americans were using violence and they should stop, as it will get them nowhere. We also learn that from the quote that people are using violence and rejecting his methods but we still do not know why they did this, as it does not mention anything about their reasons against M.L.K. The tone of this source is emotional as well as being factual. It is emotional as he talks in a way that people will start to get people to think about how his methods work and what they will gain if they support him. The tone is also quite factual as it is also trying to say in a sly way that people should stop the violence, as that is what is happening de facto. Overall, I would say that this source is only partly useful as it only tells us that there was violence but not the reasons for it and doing things the legal way. ?? ?? ?? ?? zaima ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1941-80 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1941-80 essays

  1. I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings is an autobiography by Mya Angelou.

    She realizes that she is different from the other children in appearance, giving her the sense that she does not belong in the world. Angelou also feels the need to prove her physical appearance at one point in the book, by choosing to have sex with a boy up the street.

  2. Free essay

    Civil Rights essay Assignment 1 Question 1

    at the front on public transport while black people sat at the back. One particularly humiliating rule was that if a bus was crowded blacks had to give up their seats for whites. On December 1st 1955 a black lady called Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat and

  1. History Coursework - Intolerance kkk

    This ban was implemented in January, 1920. In America 18 states had alcohol band by 1917 then the nationwide wide ban was put in place. The ban was supported in the rural areas of America. The group that were intolerant were the 'Anti-Saloon League', they saw alcohol as evil.

  2. Martin Luther King Jr.

    black, strong, and proud and that they are no longer the slaves and the subculture of a nation. Religion played a huge part in King's life, he always spread the word of The Lord to all his followers during speeches and in his books, he inspired the black American citizens

  1. Bloody Sunday - Source based Coursework

    However, there are also weaknesses such as because its written by the British government it maybe biased because they don't want to loose Northern Ireland. What evidence did they use? 7) Source B is a photograph of a civil rights march, which appears to be very peaceful, but marches they are provocative without the banners about religion and politics.

  2. Civil Rights Sources Questions

    The senator is expressing his views on segregation, so we can get an insight on what he thinks. It is useful as he is trying to justify segregation, saying it is not discrimination, and segregation is supported by both races.

  1. Segregation Sources Question

    He defends segregation as moral and something that is not only accepted by both races but benefits them also. The first thing a historian must note when evaluating this source is that it is an exert from a speech. At first glance we notice that Eastland seems to contradict himself

  2. Discrimination Sources Question

    In sources four and five judicial discrimination is shown. Both of these sources relate to fear and lack of justice. Source four shows a girl in fear for her life, just because she is black. Source five shows that even in court black people couldn't get justice. It clearly shows legal discrimination against black people.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work