• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14
  15. 15

Compare and contrast the soldiers experiences of the Great War 1914-18

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the soldiers experiences of the Great War 1914-18 with the official newspaper reports from the German and British sources; which is the most reliable account of the war? Source 1A portrays the ugliness of conditions of the war at the Western Front. The soldier has committed suicide in his trench to escape the horrible conditions. Rather than continue to fight, the soldier preferred to kill himself which shows how far some men would go to escape the horrors of the war. He has shot himself probably with his own rifle; he has got the gun pointed to his skeleton face which reveals he wanted his death over with quickly so he would not suffer a slow painful death. Furthermore, he has hidden himself in a corner so he cannot be seen. Source 3E illustrates why someone might want to commit suicide and it backs up this source here. Source 1B is more abstract than 1A. It is a picture of British casualties who had suffered gas attacks. There is a line of blind men with their arms on each other's shoulders showing that men were all in it together. We know that they are blind because they have bandages over their eyes. It seems that the men were blinded for life by the gas showing how savage the war became. This source is linked to source 3A "Dulce Et Decorum Est" as they both represent revulsion. Source 1C is a picture of repelling German counter attack. The picture is very graphic and portrays a typical depressing battlefield. ...read more.


This reveals the annihilating environment that throttles the surroundings. The rain distracting the troops is more pain and torture for them. Paul Nash describes it as "Unspeakable, godless, hopeless" This is because the soldiers have done so much that they feel speechless. This description is backed up by source 3E which also creates a choking atmosphere. Source G shows a gruesome, ghastly, sickening side of trench warfare. The violence that occurred was not forgetful but scarred the troops for life. They are described as ruthless animals attacking each other. "The fighters snarled and worried and scuffled and clutched and tore at each other more like savage brutes than men". The fear of death was enormous as most soldiers knew that there was a low chance for survival. The war was bloody and vicious and millions of people died each day facing the same situations which can also be supported in source 3J. Source H shows what equipment soldiers had to carry in warfare. He would be carrying a total of 30 kilograms of equipment This included a rifle, two mills grenades, 220 rounds of ammunition, a steel helmet, wire cutters, field dressing, entrenching tool, greatcoat, two sandbags, rolled ground sheet, water bottle, haversack, mess tin, towel, shaving kit, extra socks, message book and preserved food rations. The weight of the equipment made it difficult to move very fast across No Man's Land. The bayonet in his right hand would be a dangerous weapon which could stab someone in the back or though the heart causing blood and anguished death. ...read more.


This source can be backed up by source 5 as it gives a similar example. Source 7 was written on June 5th 1915 by Lord Derby. This last source shows a contrast to what the conditions were like. In all the newspapers reporters explained how successful they have done and Lord Derby clarifies by saying, "the Government are doing the best they can for their country" He appreciates this but also knows something is missing as they have not mentioned what is going on. He speaks out by saying, "I think we ought to be given little more news of what our troops are doing in field". The reporters have to be careful on what they write, but they are now being questioned by the people at home. Finding out about the horrible conditions would cause a lot of anger which is one big reason why it was not mentioned. This source can be backed up by source I as it conveys the conditions troops faced. Overall the soldier's experiences and the official accounts are very different from each other. The soldier's experiences illustrate the suffering of soldiers who faced terror throughout the Great War, were as the official accounts tell a different side of the Great War reporting how well the war was going. The troops experienced such awful conditions that they would describe it as "unspeakable, godless, hopeless" On the other hand the official accounts explained that "further important successes have been gained by troops" This gives evidence on how they contrast. However I think the most reliable sources are the soldier's diary accounts as they are personal, telling the reader their personal experiences and how they felt. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. WW1 - technology and trench warfare.

    If these conditions went untreated, they would destroy the tissue in the foot which would result in amputation. Another major concern for soldiers in the trenches was dysentery. Dysentery is a disease involving the swelling of the large intestine. The swelling caused stomach pains, diarrhoea, and usually vomiting or fever.

  2. Life in the trenches

    What made shell shock worse was, any man caught trying to escape from the battle because they had got this disease would automatically be executed on the spot by firing squad. One of the major dangers though was obviously being shot.

  1. Knightly Warfare. The knights primary and considered most well known weapon was the ...

    For the calf and ankle areas, knights wore plate armor known as greaves (Parts 2). Protection for the kneecap and thigh came from plate armor as well (Parts 2). These plates were called poleyns on the kneecap, and cuisses on the thigh (Parts 2).

  2. Gallic war

    Generals such as Pompey, Caesar, Antony and Octavian showed that political power came from control of successful armies. * Successful generals used threat of their armies to achieve greater political power. * Veterans became important (e.g. in terms of their loyalty)

  1. Battle of the Somme

    this shows that Coppards comrades may have been killed due to Haig's tactics. We know today about the casualties at the battle of the Somme. I believe the purpose of Haig's extract from source b was to reassure the public that everything was going to plan and that there were no signs of trouble.

  2. Comparison and contrast between Night by Elie Wiesel and Life is beautiful by Robert ...

    As you can see, the survival of Joshua is quite unrealistic because he hid in the compartments of the adult prisoners. However, in the Night, it was very different everybody only cared for himself and tried to snatch food from the weaker ones.

  1. What was life like in the trenches?

    Some trenches were dug quite deep, and then equipped with unwanted objects to make things a little drier and more homelike. But in general, these were developed to cover short distances and be a temporary defensive position for troops before moving on to a new battlefield, so there was little in the way of mortal comforts.

  2. Life In The Trenches - research and evaluation of the sources

    After they were dug, they were lined with sandbags and barbed wire, for protection, but that was only if there were enough supplies. It apparently took 6 hours for 450 men to construct 250 miles of trench (according to http://trenches.jynx.ca/?page=trenches)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work