Depth Study the United States of Amreica, 1919-41 - Sources Questions

Authors Avatar

DEPTH STUDY THE UNITED STATES OF AMREICA, 1919-41

  1. i) Source A tells about Hoover´s understanding about the cuases of the depression that USA is not the only country that should de blamed of cuasing it, because there are other countries which contributed to make the depression worse, like Asia or the revolutions in South America, and also financial crises or the over production of certain goods. But he is only saying all these becasue he was the responsible of cuasing the depression and he needs not to be blamed.

ii) Source B tells that the real cause of the depression was the Wall Street Crash, the Americans as a whole, were spending too little and saving too much, which encouraged speculation on the stock exchanges, and as the USSA was the world´s leading industrial nation the collapse spread. And the depression began. These source doesn´t agree with source A at all, because source A is about blaming every country but the USA of causing the depression and source B is blamgin actually the USA and Predisent Hoover of causing the depression.

Join now!

iii) Source B is more useful than source A as evidence of the causes of the Depression because source A is written from a speech given by President Hoover on December 2nd in 1930, when the Depression was happening, and as is given by the President of the USA he is obviously blaming the other countries, so people wont make him the only risponsible, when he actually is. And source B is more useful because was written in 1984, when the Depression was over, by a person who is not related at all with the causes of the Depression, so is ...

This is a preview of the whole essay