• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the effectiveness of US tactics such as 'defoliation' and 'search and destroy'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

´╗┐During the Vietnam War, the tactics most commonly used and with the most notoriety today are, ?search and destroy? and ?defoliation?. With the realization that bombing would not be enough to triumph over a guerrilla army, the US commander General Westmoreland created a strategy of ?search and destroy?. From heavily defended US bases in the south of the country, US and South Vietnamese forces would locate enemy forces and destroy both them and occasionally their base areas in raids from helicopters. Defoliation on the other hand was a way to prevent the enemy any cover or subsistence in the jungle terrain. American forces used an array of chemical herbicides: fast-acting Agent Blue was the chosen herbicide for crops, while Agent Orange was the favoured herbicide for forested areas. So with all the effort put into these tactics just how effective were they? To determine the effectiveness of these US tactics I have created two success criteria: did the tactic cause change that helped the war effort? ...read more.

Middle

The most well-known example for this was the My Lai massacre of March 16th 1968. US troops who were part of Task Force Barker (the codename for a search and destroy mission), murdered over 350 unarmed women and children. Actions like this ?encouraged even greater peasant support for the Vietcong in the countryside? [5] this being of more detriment to the allied forces. Additionally, with the Vietnam War being the first televised war, the public quickly became aware of such tragedies as the My Lai massacre. This meant the search and destroy tactic had a negating impact on the Vietnam War as the American public were outraged by the actions of the US troops and joined the protest movement, which is one of the main reasons the US left Vietnam. This displays how the US tactic of search and destroy was ineffective as it suffered such a major drawback with innocent villages such as My Lai being mistaken for NLF strongholds and innocent villagers and civilians being massacred. ...read more.

Conclusion

This inhibited the effectiveness of the defoliation tactic, as the damage caused by the US was essentially a free propaganda and recruitment source in aid of the NLF. In conclusion, though the US were able to carry out successful search and destroy missions, the body count is questionable and in some instances the Vietcong where able to regroup and returned after the US had left captured areas abating the change produced by the tactic. The tactic also had severe drawbacks in that civilians were accidently and sometimes purposefully killed, leading the Vietnamese people to resent the allied forces and support the NLF and was therefore not greatly effective. On the other hand, defoliation was more effective as it hindered the NLF food and coverage in forested areas and brought around a greater level of change than the search and destroy tactic. However, it too suffered drawbacks in the effect it had on the civilians and the country of Vietnam, so the tactic was not as effective because of the damage it caused destroying the very people the tactic was supposed to be protecting. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Vietnam 1954-1975 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Vietnam 1954-1975 essays

  1. What was the impact of the My Lai massacre?

    The Tet Offensive was also a turning point in the Vietnam war as after this event it became clear that the American's were still no closer to victory as although in military terms this was a success (37,000 VC killed compared to 2500 Americans)

  2. Did the power of television force the US to leave Vietnam?

    If you look closely at the cartoon, there is one particular man that stands out on the train. The man holding the axe is supposed be President Lyndon Johnson and the fact that he is the main character in this cartoon and also he is the one that is holding

  1. Evaluate the effectiveness of Diem's regime politically, economically and socially

    Diem, preoccupied with power and struggles of opposition did not bother so much with the reconstruction and industrialisation of the South, economic advancement generally only came to those who were catholic and corruption was widely spread causing the south to become increasingly dependant on international aid.

  2. How Effective Were The Tactics Of Search And Destroy And Defoliation During The Vietnam ...

    to the un-popularity of the US troops and South Vietnamese Army (SVA). In addition to this, American troops also had very little training and experience in the terrain of Vietnam. This gave the opposition a huge advantage as the US troops would follow the stream or river allowing the VC to counter them from all angles and side.

  1. Throughout the Vietnam War, the Americans used various tactics to try and defeat their ...

    Finally, due to just high exposure to the acid, as it was sprayed over such vast areas, defoliation in Vietnam is responsible for over 4million deaths and disabilities, not including the generations of birth defects which are still being experienced.

  2. How effective were the US tactics of 'Search and Destroy' and 'Defoliation' in the ...

    back in and re-build the village with the support of South Vietnamese civilians. Also, the South Vietnamese support didn't decrease, if anything, it increased due to the hatred of Americans (Source 1). Another way it was ineffective was that the information given was usually false (as shown by the My Lai massacre)

  1. I think that the four most significant themes in the Vietnam War were protest ...

    most people that they would kill so many people in violent ways for no real gain. The Pentagon papers had a big impact on how significant the news reports were. The papers were first released in New York Times on June 13th 1971 and they contained figures from Vietnam that

  2. How effective were the US tactics of search and destroy and defoliation in the ...

    Women were raped, children and elderly shot even thought they were all innocent. The final body count came to 300. As this was the first war the media and newspapers got involved in the public in the USA eventually became aware of this tragedy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work