• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the view that the Versailles treaty created as many problems as it solved.

Extracts from this document...


Jonathan Mitchell Discuss the view that the Versailles treaty created as many problems as it solved. On the 28th June 1919 at Versailles Palace in France the Germans signed one of the most influential peace treaties ever proposed by democracies. The Germans believed the treaty to be a farcical document littered with anti German clauses designed to cripple Germany. France however, with probably the highest economic and physical damage from the war, saw the treaty as to lenient on the Germans. Britain and the USA (France, USA, Britain being affectionate named the big three due to there status after the war) were more liberal and forgiving about the punishment Germany should receive. Britain and the USA were more concerned with the long term economic and political threats that a decimated German state could pose to the international balance of power in Europe. Historians for years have pondered over the harshness or leniency of the treaty and what by doing so it caused in later day Europe. During the First World War most of the physical warfare had been conducted on French and Belgium soil, not touching German or British land. ...read more.


Yet all three nations had in mind the threat of extremist parties taking over Germany, they had already see the acts of 1917 in Russia. A left wing socialist group led by the works of Karl Marx (socialist philosopher and seen as the creator of Communism as a Political stance) had seized power during the chaos engulfing Russia following the fall of the Tsarist regime. They did not want Germany to be vulnerable to the threat of Communism. Though other considerations obviously took priority. On the other hand any Treaty or actions that try to recreate borders and distinctions between countries and areas never work due to wide spread differentiating people's on land's, it was very naive of the Big three to presume this would work, Wilson's 14 points although more lenient to Germany still posed just as many territorial changes as the treaty although they were slightly less severe.. This recreation of false distinctions between countries was a down point of the treaty especially when the powers would not uphold what they had laid down this inevitably would cause problems in post war Germany as these kinds of actions had done before throughout the world. ...read more.


In saying that the treaty of Versailles was a complete failure and created all Europe's post war problems would be a massive overstatement, to say it was merely the best the Nations could do with the given situation and that all the problems which arose were little to do with the treaty would be an understatement. The real answer lies somewhere in between the two. The options of the Nations when creating the treaty were small but in being naive and not thinking forward to what certain clauses of the treaty might bring about they created problems. Yet no one could anticipate the rise of Hitler and the Nazi's in Germany and although the treaty aided them in their rise it was one of many factors that lead to the rise of the Nazi party in post Versailles Germany. In conclusion the treaty created a lot of problems some avoidable, some not, its resources were small yet its dealing with its resources was poor. Yet when the nations wanted such polar opposites for a post war Germany and Europe in general it is expected that some problems could and would arise. Keynes said post the signing of the treaty that "The Treaty by overstepping the limits of the possible, has in practice settled nothing". ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Treaty Of versailles

    5 star(s)

    As a result of being excluded it led to bad communication between the League of Nations and Germany. Also Germany would've had support from other countries that were in the League of Nations. So if for example, there was a conflict between another country.

  2. Explain how the Treaty of Versailles created many problems for Germany in the period ...

    This again caused more resentment towards the government who were highly under pressure by all the angry Germans. An area 50 kilometres wide on the east bank of the Rhine was to be demilitarised. This meant that Germany could not station troops or keep weapons in this area, even though

  1. How did the Treaty of Versailles contribute to Hitler’s rise to power?

    The purpose of the Putsch was to put Hitler into power and set out the min Nazi beliefs of National Socialism that everyone was loyal to Germany and that all German settlers were of Aryan Lineage. There was to be equality and that there was to be state control of the economy.

  2. Versailles Effect On GermanyThe Treaty of Versailles: Prelude to WWII The Treaty of Versailles ...

    Germans had given up hope of paying off the reparations, and were in favor of Hitler's promise to undo the whole of the Treaty of Versailles. Despite Hitler's previous failure in attempting to get into power, now that Germany was in need of change, he gained tremendous support by promising

  1. The rise of Hitlers power was based upon a number of long term problems ...

    With 1/4 of their land being lost and now completely land locked Germany was struggling, to make matter worse Germanys largest industrial area - the Ruhr had now been disarmed of German troops and all exports where to be sent to the "winners", as a form of reparation.

  2. Germany, 1918-1945 - Treaty of Versailles.

    This begun to get the German public to agree with Hitler's views and therefore voted for him. On 8th November 1923, Hitler, with the SA, broke into a meeting held by three leaders of the Bavarian government. He forced the leaders to tell their audience that they would give the

  1. Why did most German's hate the treaty of Versailles?

    The Germans felt that this was totally excessive and unnecessary, and that people would lose their homes. Probably the most destructive part of the treaty was the Reparations that Germany was made to pay as damages. A fixed sum of �6600 million would be taken from Germany, and as the

  2. Political Problems - Treaty of Versailles

    The strengths of Hitler and the Nazis 1. Hitler was a great speaker. 4. The SA and SS attacked other political groups. 6. Goebbels organised effective propaganda. 8. Hitler and the Nazis targeted specific groups of society to get their support. 10. The industrialist, Alfred Hugenberg, helped Hitler to attack the Young Plan.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work