• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do sources D (i) and D (ii) provide any useful information for the historian studying Haig’s decision to attack Ypres in 1917? Explain your answer.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Do sources D (i) and D (ii) provide any useful information for the historian studying Haig's decision to attack Ypres in 1917? Explain your answer. The main problem so to speak is that both of the sources have only looked at the situation within the trenches and have not looked at the main picture, which is that if they don't go on attacking the Germans the French army will collapse and the Germans will win the battle. Source D (i) is a very bitter account written by Trevor Wilson about a man who has told him his views and opinions about the situation in hand. ...read more.

Middle

And because of this he has seen the Germans situation and is criticising his own side for everything that the Germans have as an advantage e.g. Dry trenches, ferro-concrete boxes and machine guns. He is also looking from the point of view as a man who knows he is probably going to be killed during one of these supposed useful attacks that Haig wants. But he cannot see the big picture so this means that his views on the situation are limited and are going to be very different to the one's of General Haigs because Haig can see the whole plan from his point of view. Source D (ii). ...read more.

Conclusion

the front line and this is why I feel that he ha had to base his account on the evidence that he has got from soldiers that have been to the front line that he has spoken to in the reserve trenches. And after looking at this evidence I can see that the information from both sources D (i) and D (ii) is not actually relevant to the decision that Haig hade to make during the war, and that all this source can do is help you get a better idea of the atmosphere, conditions and generally give you a better picture of the trenches through the use of text. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. Styal Mill - Study sources A, B, C and D. Which of these sources ...

    The source is useful in telling us about the conditions in styal mill, but it tells us no information on the conditions of the other mills, which is what we want to find out. A limitation of the source is that we know that Thomas couldn't read nor write, and

  2. Do these sources agree or disagree in their verdicts on the result of Haig's ...

    'French plight' from source J is referring to the French mutinies that were happening, this is similar to source I because it further shows that morale was very low as further highlighted by 'the British Army lost its spirit of optimism, and there was a sense of deadly depression among many officers and men.'

  1. How useful are sources A, B, and C to a historian studying the attitudes ...

    The people he talked to probably did not participate in any large scale battle and so he only has the views of those who did not suffer greatly in the war, and he should perhaps talk to a member of the Newfoundland division if he wanted the opinions of those who suffered at the orders of his father.

  2. How useful are Sources A, B and C to an historian studying the attitudes ...

    Moreover this source is almost totally unreliable as it is fictional and written merely for the purpose of entertaining; yet it does tap into some truth regarding the soldier's attitudes towards their commander's leadership qualities. As I have read in the article 'Lions led by Donkeys' a former soldier reviews

  1. How useful are sources A, B and C to an historian studying the attitudes ...

    This cartoon to a certain extent shows the truth. Source B is a TV show which was broadcasted during the 90's. The source is secondary. This source is very similar to source A in that it uses the same ideas but uses humour to show it to the audience.

  2. How far to sources G and H agree about the chances of success for ...

    These two sources had many similarities. Both of the sources agree that the weather conditions affected the battle a considerable amount during this time. They both talk about the men attempting to advance and not being able to walk or run because they have fallen in to shell holes filled with water and sunk up to their waists.

  1. How useful are Sources A, B and C to an historian studying the attitudes ...

    Obviously because they felt the risk of death was too high, or was it that they were just cowards? But then again, this source was taken from a magazine, and magazines are very rarely neutral- they have to have a state of bias, so as to keep the reader interested.

  2. The Third Battle of Ypres

    The low ridge from Keppel to Passchendaele was shaped rather like a sickle with the handle at Messines and the blade sweeping round Ypres with Passchendaele at the tip and this ridge dominated the battle area. The Steenbeeck was one of a number of insignificant little streams that were to

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work