• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do these sources support the view that the failure of Prohibition was inevitable?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

f) Study ALL the Sources. Do these sources support the view that the failure of Prohibition was inevitable? Sources A to E all suggest different things. There is evidence to suggest that prohibition looked like it would succeed particularly at the beginning and in rural areas. Leading up to the introduction of prohibition there was allot of support for it and many thought it would be the end to poverty problems. Rural areas were not big drinkers and prior to prohibition over half the states had already turned 'dry'. Prohibition looked promising and there was plenty of evidence to suggest the success of it. However the real truth and fundamentals of the cause was society's unwillingness to except prohibition; alcohol had been part of the culture especially urban culture for years. Changing social values were also happening at this time as industrial urbanization made people feel more liberated and more and more immigrants were flocking to America. If people didn't want to abide by the law now was the time that they were more likely to rebel as they felt like they had more freedom and confidence than ever before. Due to this, prohibition became more and more likely to fail towards the end of the decade as industrialization grew, so did people's knowledge and general management and as immigrants flocked so came their need and knowledge of alcohol. When people found a way around the law prohibition came very unlikely to succeed particularly in the urban areas where most immigrants lived and industrialization had more influence. ...read more.

Middle

Source E also agrees that "a vast army of lawbreakers have appeared", and then goes on further to say "respect for the law has been greatly lessened" emphasising on people's unwillingness to except this new law. Although this does appear to be very true this evidence is not entirely reliable as Rockefeller was trying to justify his reasons for his change in opinion of prohibition. He also was based in a large city where drinking was more available and on a greater demand than rural parts of America. A final determination for the inevitable failure of prohibition was that the law was going against the daily habits and customs of Americans. Due to a large scale flock of immigrants to America in the last 50 years, to many people like the Jews and the Negro population, drinking was not a sign of moral weakness but part of their culture and way of living. The influx of immigrants meant a growth in cities and in 1920 a census revealed that the USA was predominantly urban for the first time. This resulted in the tension between the rural and the urban states. The saloon was at it's greatest in cities with support from the Catholics and immigrants meant it had a great influence even if widening the divided between catholic and protestant, immigrant and native and the urban and rural states. Source B supports this in the sense that drinking was taking place mainly in cities; "by 1928 there was more than 30,000 'speakeasies' in New York", the source also mentions that made illegal drinking possible simply "supply a public demand". ...read more.

Conclusion

It would be hard to say whether prohibitions failure was inevitable as both arguments have their strengths. Prohibition looked promising prior to its introduction and certainly in the rural areas of America as over 50% of the states had gone 'dry' before anyway. However it was not taken into account of how the growing urban areas would take the new law. Social values were changing with the kick off of the roaring twenties as the liberation of women, new immigration and industrial urbanisation channelled Americans into the confidence of their newly found buoyancy. Perhaps prohibition would have succeeded if these traditional values had not been obscured, because all of the discussed issues are symptomatic of the fundamental cause being the change in Americans attitude and unwillingness to accept this law. However, because of this prohibitions failure only became obvious after the initial stage of prohibition, therefore not making it inevitable from the beginning. The 18th amendment did become inevitable to failure within the first few years of prohibition and certainly after 1925, as the law just was not being enforced and other crimes and an attitude of lawlessness has spun off it. Many US cities became more drunken, violent and corrupt than ever before, worsening the problems prohibition was supposed to solve. Prohibition may not have been inevitable to fail right from its launch, but after the first few years it was clear that it certainly would fail in the urbanised states of America. ?? ?? ?? ?? Chloe Graham ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. Prohibition bound to fail?

    Source C shows a man spending all his money on alcohol while his wife and child are at home with no food. The caption above the wife and child reads 'the saloon is well named the poor man's club as it keeps its members and their family always poor'.

  2. Why was prohibition introduced

    Despite getting 300,000 convictions for drinking between 1920 and 1930 drinking continued also the enforcement agents that were employed to enforce the Prohibition laws were poorly paid. This meant that some officers were persuaded to take bribes from gangsters running "speakeasies" and turned a blind eye to the "rackets" taking

  1. The Roaring Twenties

    This encouraged Western Europeans because many people were either able to speak English or pay to learn it. By 1921, an immigration law was passed which limited the flow of immigrants to USA which stated the number of immigrants coming should not exceed 3% of the number of existing immigrants in 1910 (Emergency Quota Act).

  2. The effects of Industrialization and globalisation.

    But in the process we seem to have created new and more serious problems, and people were still not happy. In the West today hundreds of thousands of people are stressed, unmotivated when it comes to their jobs, and locked into a never ending spiral of wanting more, more, more.

  1. The Roaring Twenties

    In the 9120's the average US farmer was each year growing enough to feed his family ,but, prices dropped as desperate farmers tried to sell their produce. In 1921, prices fell by 50%, hundreds of rural banks collapsed in the 1920's and there were five times as many bankruptcies.

  2. Does the evidence of source C support the evidence of sources A and B ...

    Everyone in the photograph is wandering around aimlessly in normal clothes so this shows that they were unemployed. If they were unemployed they must have been poor. This is what source A is saying about Jarrow. It is saying that Jarrow was poor and that people suffered because of it.

  1. History - Prohibition

    At the bottom of the poster are the words 'Slaves of the Saloon'. The word slave incorporates the idea of addictiveness, that is to say the man cannot get out of the habit of drinking and so has not got any freedom and he is weak.

  2. Was the failure of prohibition inevitable?

    There are even accounts of the police jest being handed envelopes with money inside to stop enforcing the area they were in. Police who did try to enforce the law were sent off to law enforce in the middle of nowhere.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work