• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do you agree with the view that the main cause of the collapse of Tsarist Rule was that the Tsar's supporters lost faith in th

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Do you agree with the view that the main cause of the collapse of Tsarist Rule was that the Tsar's supporters lost faith in the regime? (24 marks) The tercentenary of the Romanov dynasty was celebrated in 1913, the Royal family travelled throughout Russia in order to gain support. Figes believes this anniversary was manipulated in order to increase support for an ever increasingly unpopular dynasty. The discontent for the Tsarist system was widespread and is undoubtable that the pillars that had once held up the autocratic system were weakening. Historians however have different believes over the influence that these unstable pillars had on the Muscovite Tsar, with many viewing the peasantry and proletariat more influential in bringing about the downfall of the regime rather than the army and aristocracy. The report from the Okhrana, which describes the situation in and around Petrograd, describes the "bitterness of feeling among wide sections of the population" in former St. Petersburg. The source, similarly to source five acknowledges the "unbelievable burdens of war." The Russian Army was huge, with over a million in conscripts in 1826, the 25 year service was a great dread for most Russians with fierce discipline imposed on soldiers. ...read more.

Middle

Which there western European counterparts were already enjoying and had been for centuries. Source five states that: "The immediate factor that led to the collapse of the regime was...a failure of the Tsar's own supporters to carry on propping up a regime in which they had increasingly lost faith." This statement summarises the views and actions of the groups in Russia who withdrew their support for the regime. However it can be argued that the withdrawal of support by former pillars of the regime was not the only or the most influential reason for the collapse of the Romanov dynasty. The Orthodox Christian faith, dominated the lives of Russian people since the age of the Tsar's. The faith was extremely important in holding the autocratic system together, it advocated the Tsar was not just a King who ruled with divine right as in western Europe, instead that the monarch was in fact "God on Earth. The faith had great political importance as it allowed the Tsar to punish those who opposed him with God's law. However in the late 19th Century divisions emerged within the church between liberal and conservatives, meaning the churches influence, unity and most importantly power within Russia was weakened and ...read more.

Conclusion

The fourth Duma, which became increasingly out spoken is also an important factor in the collapse of the dynasty. The assembly voiced great concerns about the running of the country, which is implied in source 4: "complaints are openly voiced about the corrupt government." Alexander Kerensky who called for the Tsar's abdication, which doubted for the first time in Russia doubted the idea that the Tsar was "God on Earth", made the most famous of these grievances. A call for the dissolution of the Duma was made however around ten of the members of the body defied the constitution and refused to step down showing the open opposition that was beginning to emerge towards the ever crumbling regime. In conclusion although the Tsar's supporters did desert the regime in its hour of need it can be argued that the actions of the aristocracy, army and the middle class were a reaction to the immense power that the proletariat were voicing. It can be argued that although the groups who supported the Tsar had grievances they were only prepared to act upon them due to the openly rebellious attitude of the proletariat whom along with the Duma first openly threatened the regime set the ball of the revolution in motion. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. How convincing is the argument that WW1 was the main factor in the collapse ...

    Liberal optimist historians claim that without the obstruction of the war the Tsar may have made more reforms and efficiently improved agriculture as well as the peasant's quality of life. The Liberal optimists believe the revolution could have been prevented without the imposition of WW1, though it seems likely that

  2. Why did the Tsarist regime fall in 1917?

    In source C, it says "[The situation] would probably have destroyed any man who sat on the throne". So source C is trying to show that it was not Tsar Nicholas II fault that bad things were happening, and that the situation was so bad that no-one would have been able to deal with it.

  1. "To what extent was World War One the main reason for the downfall of ...

    as the Russian Social Democratic party in 1898 (which later split into the Bolsheviks and Mensheviks). These revolutionary parties had a broad propaganda role which helped undermine loyalty to the regime, especially amongst the workers and soldiers. This was coupled with the wide range of nationalities in Russia who on the most part wanted to overthrow the Tsar.

  2. Explain Rasputin's contribution to the collapse of Tsarism.

    She was easily persuaded, and German, so the Russian population disliked her. Rasputin was probably only trying to help the Tsarina, because running Russia was a huge responsibility, and it was a mistake for the Tsar to leave it in her hands.

  1. China 1945-90 - source based questions.

    reform programmes continued up until his death on 20th February, 1997, just four months away from the handover of Hong Kong back to Chinese sovereignty. There was no power struggle after Deng's death like that that had occurred after the death of Mao.

  2. The blance sheet for russia.

    At the outset, few people would have given much for the survival of the new regime. Against all the odds, the Red Army beat back the enemy on all fronts. Trotsky's remarkable achievement was recognised even by the enemies of the revolution, as the following quotations from German officers and

  1. Stalin Sources Questions

    The inquisition we have to project to ourselves is one of why if Stalin was such a monster then why did he remain in power for such a long time. To help us gain an answer we have to examine Sources A to M.

  2. Why was the Tsarist regime able to survive the revolution of 1905?

    He realised that he could solely undertake this task and so he appointed Sergei Witte as his new chief minister to help him sort all his problems with the state. First of all he realised that the army were well and truly defeated and he had to end the war

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work