• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does field Marshall Haig deserve his title as the Butcher of the Somme?

Extracts from this document...


Discursive Essay: Does field Marshall Haig deserve his title as the Butcher of the Somme? I believe that Fild marshall haig deserves the tile of "the butcher of the somme" In December 1915 there was stalemate on the western front both side were dug into trenches and were scared to move forward. On December 10th 1915 Field Marshall Haig was appointed commander of the British forces. He was 54 and had a long and successful career in the cavalry. He had also fought in the Boer war 15 years earlier. In February 1916 the French forts around Verdun were under heavy attack. The French army pleaded for the help of the British. The British army led by Field Marshall decided to launch a major attack along the river Somme to take away the pressure on the French. The British intelligence reports told Haig that the Germans were out numbered and had very low morale. The bombardment started on June the 23rd 1916, it lasted for a week and used heavy artillery fire. ...read more.


Haig said after the first day that 'everything had run like clockwork' But how can this be possibly be the case if sixty thousands British troops lost their lives. In the same report he said "Our troops are in wonderful spirits and full of confidence. Again, how is it possible for Field Marshal Haig to know this if he has never visited the Front Line? When you first look the evidence you must realise that Haig's views on modern warfare were inline with what most people thought at the time. Haig believed that the country had to expect 'heavy losses'. This shows that he expected many men to loose their lives for Britain to win the war. Modern historians have said that Haig should have called a halt to the advance after heavy casualties but he may have been told something different. It has been reported that he was told that the bombardment had destroyed the barbed wire, which it hadn't. These two pieces of evidence show that Field Marshall Haig had been receiving inaccurate intelligence reports. ...read more.


But when people began to examine the evidence surrounding the Battle of the Somme they began to blame Haig. That is why modern historians now think that Field Marshall Haig was to blame. If I were a soldier at the time I do no think I would have doubted Field Marshall Haig's methods because the Battle of the Somme was just another battle of heavy casualties. Nowadays generals are in a position of care. They need to look after their troops instead of squandering them. One of the main reasons for this is that there is an expectation that no loss will be tolerated. If Haig was a General of today he wouldn't have squandered so many men because today it is just not right. Also the 1st world war was a new kind of war it was a war where many more men could take part, the tecnogly also allowed killing at a much greater speed, therefore the blood shed was much greater. It is easy to blame someone using hindsight. But I belive that field Amrshall Haig does deserve his title as the "Butcher of the Somme" Discursive essay Does Field Marshall Haig Deserve his Title as the Butcher of the Somme? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Does General Haig deserve the title Butcher of the Somme?

    5 star(s)

    Haig was in a lose lose position, as, in the circumstances the only way in which he could win was through mass casualties as that was what a war of attrition was reduced to and he would be held responsible for the deaths.

  2. General Haig - Butcher or Hero?

    In these mediums, the writers may 'twist' the events in some ways, using poet's justice. However minor this is, the account may give a different impression than it should be. Therefore, the chances are that sources 9 and 10 are not reliable; just as source 8 could be, if the writer played with the facts to make it more interesting.

  1. Does General Haig Deserve the Title The Butcher of the Somme?

    Military historians believe that Haig did do a good job as he did the best he could with the resources he had, he was well qualified and did well with the tasks in hand and he shouldn't be compared to the generals of today as they are in completely different time and have different resources.

  2. Does Haig Deserve To Be Called The Butcher Of The Somme?

    Perhaps because he was trained not to show any strong emotions, Haig had an almost autistic approach to other people, he apparently didn't realize or notice that soldiers had feelings or fears. His diary in many places says that his men were in 'splendid spirits', when they weren't.

  1. Haig, Butcher of the Somme

    trenches, barbed wire, machine guns and artillery with the weak instrument of human flesh'. Another historian, John Terraine, described in his book how the 'generals rose to challenge after challenge' adapting 'to constant change with astonishing success' (source 8). There is no doubt that the trench warfare was unlike anything that the generals had come across before.

  2. Does General Haig deserve to be remembered as the Butcher of the Somme?

    He came up with his own interpretation because he is a socialist and also has observed which enabled him to come up with an interpretation about Haig.This source is quite reliable as it is a primary source however is shows it is all opinion based.

  1. How important were Haig's tactics in bringing an end to WW1?

    A second British fleet, consisting of older ships, was used to guard the English Channel. The German fleet, the High Seas Fleet, consisting of 13 dreadnoughts, was based on the North Sea ports of Germany. Although there was very little fighting at sea, the sea campaigns were incredibly important because

  2. Haig butcher of the Somme?

    He goes onto explain Haig's ignorance: of not having to suffer from living in cramped smelly conditions; getting feasted on at night like the soldiers, because he never 'knew what a trench was like'. This source was written for people to read and believe that Haig is not worthy to be 'an Earl' or have '�100,000' reward given to him.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work