• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Evacuation was a great success' Do you agree?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Evacuation was a great success' Do you agree? Evacuation of children in the Second World War was a massive project and many people have different views on how successful it actually was. I am going to study several sources (A to F) and compile my own opinion on the matter. After studying the sources there are elements of success and failure and I will now discuss them. Firstly and one of the biggest examples of evacuation being a success was that it got kids and some mothers (800,000 mothers and 550,000 babies in all) out of the way of the firing line to places were they were in less danger of death or serious injury. Evidence of this is present in a number of Sources namely A, D and E I will look at them all, but firstly A which is a picture of children being evacuated in an orderly queue with there parents behind them, the picture was took in London and the children seem to be fairly happy and unmoved by what was going on. The picture seems to show evacuation as a success. However this Sources reliability is questioned by the insufficient amount of evidence given, the picture only shows a small part of the evacuation process, only one incident out of the ...read more.

Middle

and the biggest reason for its unreliability is that it's from a novel created for kids, this means that only information which children will find interesting will be included. Another success of evacuation was for the city children who were evacuated to the countryside, making the trip improved the diet of many children because they ate a variety of foods including increased vegetables, this made the children healthier and sometimes happier. Sources D and F explain this, Source D's propaganda filled text tells of the children be healthier and happier, but this source as I have previously said is unreliable. Source F is a short video with numerous different accounts and sources, some reliable and some not, but in the video a person tells of the food being like having Sunday lunch everyday, however this source could again be unreliable because there is little evidence and its an opinion, but I believe that the source is reliable because its a first hand account from a child who experienced life as an evacuee. Other examples of evacuation being a success are the local halls which were turned into reception areas to sort out difficulties and host child selections, another success for evacuation was the parties that were held for the children to encourage the mixing of residents and ...read more.

Conclusion

As I have previously said many mothers and children were unhappy about being separated, but they also sometimes found it difficult moving to and then living in a strange area were they new no one, small villages although sometimes friendly couldn't provide mothers and children with what they were use to and in a way expected. City folk were use to a number of shops, pubs, cinemas, busy traffic, but were often left with nothing like what they expected. In my opinion evacuation being a success or failure really depended on what family fostered you and if you encountered social divisions and racism. However overall I believe that the evacuation of children was more of a success than a failure, but just a success not a great one. I believe it to be a success because of the children it saved who would have almost certainly have been killed, evacuation was always going to have it's problems as does any operation on such a grand scale but the work it did in ensuring the next generations life and other good effects it had on the war effort, e.g. moral boost. It must surely be regarded as a success and not a failure. So I do agree with the statement of 'Evacuation was a great success'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. "Evacuation was a great success" Do you agree? Source based work.

    can be seen only in hindsight as an unnecessary decision by the government to keep the destinations to which the evacuees were being taken a secret. There was no attempt to keep families, friends and school children together, or to match children and foster parents with the same interests, even though in theory they should have been kept together.

  2. Was Evacuation A Success

    This gives an insight into how many evacuees were perceived, Nina states that the foster parent was almost patronising them and making them feel low as they had an idea of most city children being poor. What makes this source reliable is that the author Nina Bowden was a former

  1. Evacuation was a Great Success

    Source I is representation of what one father thinks about evacuation in 1940 explaining his worry and disagreement with evacuation, including about whether his son could eat properly where he was going to be sent. This seems very contradictory as it seemed city areas were worst conditions, if this is

  2. Evacuation was a great success

    It was written by a historian in 1988, sometime after the Second World War. By being written in 1988, it is a secondary Source and is therefore not as reliable. It could also contain author's opinion which would also affect its reliability.

  1. Was Evacuation a success?

    It is very probable that the government took the picture and did it to raise the support and publicity for evacuation making this propaganda. If this were the case the government would aim to make evacuation look good meaning they wouldn't show an accurate depiction of evacuation.

  2. "Evacuation was a great success" Discuss

    There were many photos which one has only been displayed. I would say that to be successful they had to keep morale high, but this failed because of the blitz. The blitz had scared the British a lot and it affected morale a lot.

  1. "Evacuation Was A Great Success" Do You Agree Or Disagree With This Interpretation?

    The fact that some children go left behind shows that it was not as well organised as it could have been. Pre-set places should have been set up to avoid the handpicking of children which shows favouritism towards some children.

  2. The Blitz - questions and answers

    People were also shown carrying on with daily business in bombed areas and singing songs of victory. The government tried to hide the effect of the Blitz from the people by allowing only positive information such as stories, photographs and reports which showed the British people coping commendably with the Blitz.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work