• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine the degree to which the flaws of the Weimar Constitution explain the continuing instability in the years 1919 to 1923.

Extracts from this document...


Examine the degree to which the flaws of the Weimar Constitution explain the continuing instability in the years 1919 to 1923. In 1918, a revolution broke out in Germany, largely as a consequence of world war one. Initially revolution was instigated by the conservative ruling classes, although this revolution was soon to be followed by the revolution from below, which established German democracy. The end of revolution opened the gates to a new constitution, the Weimar Republic. However this was no ordinary time for Germany. War had been lost and German economy ruined. Although the Weimar republic was the first democratic constitution to rise from the ashes of authoritarianism, instigating universal suffrage, giving Liberal freedoms to the people and concessions to the workers etc, it faced huge unpopularity from the German population. After facing attacks from the left and the right, many questioned whether the Weimar Republic was just a democratic experiment, weakened by being born at such a tumultuous time. The instability suffered by the Weimar Republic could have been partially the fault of the constitution itself. However, when examining the degree to which this was the ultimate factor for instability, it is essential to asses other factors which I feel are more significantly responsible for its unstable nature. ...read more.


However the Stab in the Back Theory was created by General Ludendorff and served to shift the blame for military defeat to the Weimar Republic, accusing it of stabbing the army in the back. The motivation for such a theory being proposed undermined the validity of the theory itself. However the associations, it provoked, weakened the prospects of stability for the Weimar Republic as it was widely believed and reinforced, despite it's falsity. Such problems which would lead to instability only seemed to be amplified by the signing of the Treaty Of Versailles. It was a very harsh settlement; Germans lost territory, armed forces, industry and population, being forced to pay �6.6 million in reparations as well as accepting the guilt clause for starting the war. The people bitterly resented the Weimar Republic for signing which affected the stability of a new constitution which was unpopular with the people. The fact that the Weimar Republic was born out of such turmoil is very significant in relation to its stability and does not have close links with the nature of the constitution itself. This goes to show that the problems in the constitution may well be a relatively insignificant in relation to other factors. ...read more.


I therefore believe that this factor is significantly more important than the constitution itself when explaining the instability. However left and right wing extremism is also a factor more significant than that of the constitution but can curiously be linked to it as the left believed it had not gone far enough and the right felt it had gone too far. Maybe if the constitution had met a more happy medium it wouldn't have been attacked so vigorously and may have been more stable. In conclusion I believe a full explanation for the Weimar Republic's continuing instability can not be found in the constitution as it was only one of a number of factors but together with the more significant circumstantial factors, like the defeat in WW1, it helps to explain the back bone to some the instability it faced in the years 1919 to 1923. The links the other factors do have to the constitution come back to how the Weimar Republic dealt with them, questioning whether a constitution, embodying measures to stabilize in the event of crisis would have survived to be more stable than the Weimar Republic. However despite its instability, the Weimar Republic had managed to survive by 1923, questioning how dangerously unstable it actually was. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Why was the Weimar Republic so unpopular with many Germans between 1919 and 1923?

    4 star(s)

    The Ruhr area of Germany was invaded by French and Belgian troops in 1923. This was a political problem because the government was in charge of ensuring that the reparations were paid. Some people disliked democracy. They preferred a strong leader who would decide what was best and tell them what to do.

  2. Weimar, 1918 - 1923

    Sir John Wheeler-Bennett "The conspiracy had been nine months coming to birth." The aim was to overthrow the Weimar government and constitution and institute a military dictatorship, with Kapp at its head. On March 11th, Noske, the Minister of Defence, issued orders for the arrest of L�ttwitz and other leaders of this possible Putsch.

  1. What problems did the Weimar Republic face between 1919 and 1923?

    This raised the unemployment levels in Germany because a great deal of the soldiers returning from the war found themselves unemployed.

  2. Why did the Weimar Republic survive the crisis of 1918 – 1923?

    The army, and the �lite's in the government never intended to overthrow the Government, as they were dreadfully afraid of a civil war. Although the judges were biased, they still removed the extreme left wing protesters and halted their attempts to seize power by sentencing the majority of them to death.

  1. Why did the Right Wing fail in its threat to the Weimar Republic in ...

    Seeckt, after gaining power, could have sent out his army to stop the Putsch but did not want to because he did not want his troops to fight ex-German soldiers. The Putsch began because the Right Wing wanted to see the Republic overthrown but instead of using political means the

  2. Why was the Weimar Republic able to survive 1919 - 1929?

    On November 16th 1923, 4, 200, 000, 000, 000 Marks was equal to 1 U.S. Dollar. George Grosz said, "Lingering at the [shop] window was a luxury because shopping had to be done immediately. Even an additional minute meant an increase in price".

  1. Munich Putsch 1923 - Sources Questions

    This shows that Hitler's methods did change since being arrested and put into Prison. In order to use this new method, Hitler and the Nazi Party needed to attract votes from the German people. Hitler did 5 main things to increase his chance in achieving his dream of being Leader of Germany.

  2. How far was the Kapp Putsch the major reason for instability between 1919 and ...

    Consequently, the government fled Berlin, though not before the trade union leader, Karl Legien[4], called for a general strike, hoping it would stunt the progress of Kapp and Luttwitz, which, in fact, it did. Although Kapp and Luttwitz managed to hold Berlin for some time, after four days of strike,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work