• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig - War hero or butcher of the Somme?

Extracts from this document...


Amy Gilmour 10SC Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig: War hero or butcher of the Somme? Many historians see the Somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of the war. The devastating casualties and deaths of the war left thousands without their loved ones, a whole generation was lost at the Somme. After the devastation of the war, many soldiers blamed Haig. It was thought that Haig's leadership was to blame for the tremendous amount of casualties and deaths of the Somme. The soldiers were thought to have followed their orders courageously, precisely and so that everything went exactly as planned, but they were let down by their leaders. However, many historians now believe that General Haig was not entirely to blame for the failure at the Somme, and that it was not a military disaster, but why? There are many arguments for General Haig being the butcher of the Somme, but also many for him being a hero. Firstly General Haig was in charge of the attack from the British on the first day of the Somme. ...read more.


He rarely used them on dry ground, where they were much more effective. General Haig tried to use new ideas such as the "creeping barrage" which failed killing many of the British troops because the guns were not accurate enough. The "creeping barrage" was when guns were fired just in front of the troops causing a big cloud of mist and flying shrapnel which the troops would run through, then more guns would be fired just ahead of the troops again. This would continue right up to the enemy lines; it would confuse the enemies so that they couldn't see who they were trying to hold off. If the guns had been more accurate, this form of attack could have been very effective. Haig was also considered a bad general due to him having had an advantage for years in numbers over the Germans. For the few months that the Germans had a numerical advantage over the British troops they almost won the war. This also leads many to believe that we would have lost the war if it were not for America joining in. ...read more.


Haig's problems with destroying the German trenches were not entirely his fault either. Artillery experts had in actual fact, guaranteed Haig that the enemy trenches would be destroyed at the Battle of the Somme. This left a lot of the blame to the experts that told him this, not many would have disagreed with experts in the field. With General Haig's plans of attack getting better all the time, he must have been doing something right. After all, the Battle of the Somme caused more casualties on the Germans than the British so his main aims of the battle, to kill and injure some of Germany's best troops, had been achieved. The reason for planning this attack at all was also achieved; Verdun was saved. In my opinion, General Haig was neither a butcher nor a hero; he tried to do his best by thorough planning. I personally think that others reasons were to blame for his plan failing. Artillery experts and the lack of technology meant that his well thought out plan did not go as expected. Though a whole generation was lost, this section was not planned and therefore not entirely his fault. Haig was not a hero, definitely not a butcher; he was just a good general. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Douglas Haig - Butcher Or Hero?

    In 1916 Haig was in Charge of the Battle of the Somme, which didn't go very well and there were lots of casualties. There, Haig was given his nickname "Butcher of the Somme" In 1918 Haig organised the final offensive, which eventually led to Allied Victory.

  2. General Haig - Butcher or Hero?

    Sources 2 and 3 have been written after the war, and had witnessed Haig's tactics and the results of the Somme, Ypres and Passchendaele. These battles had by far been Haig's worst, and the Somme offensive saw 58,000 British troops killed on the first day of battle.

  1. Haig, Butcher of the Somme

    trenches, barbed wire, machine guns and artillery with the weak instrument of human flesh'. Another historian, John Terraine, described in his book how the 'generals rose to challenge after challenge' adapting 'to constant change with astonishing success' (source 8). There is no doubt that the trench warfare was unlike anything that the generals had come across before.

  2. Haig butcher of the Somme?

    To some extent it's fair to suggest this for surely you would have to get closer then '50 kilometres' to understand the intensity of the situation.

  1. Was Field Marshal General Sir Douglas Haig a hero, or the butcher of the ...

    In his second year, he was in charge of one of the bloodiest battles in British warfare: the Somme, which was probably Haig's worst battle. - Already it sounds like he was a poor strategist and even ignorant-. In the battle of the Somme Haig's plan was to launch a

  2. Was Field Marshall Haig the Butcher of the Somme

    However he didn't direct it to the soldiers, but the commanders. [Source G.] Historians, however, aren't as judgmental as others as they look at the situation from what it would have been like at the time it happened rather than a modern day perspective.

  1. General Douglas Haig

    This was unfortunately, not a good thing as it undermined confidence towards Haig as a leader. Haig is said to be 'unable to recognise defeat' which is true although he wanted the attack to go the same way as it did at Neuve-Chapelle, where initial progress was rapid, quickly breaking

  2. How far to do agree that Sir Douglas Haig is to blame for the ...

    Being a General should involve you listening to others to try and make the best decisions, however this is not what General Haig did. Haig would not listen to any other ideas about how to plan the attack.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work