• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

French and American Revolutions Compared

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

WHICH REVOLUTION IS BETTER ? In order to answer this question, we need to look at the backgrounds, the aim and the result of each revolution. Then, we?ll have to see what they have in common and what are different. After that, we might be able to answer the question. A revolution?s objective is to be able to get a better life afterwards. The best revolution would be one that achieves its goal with the minimal violence as possible. The American Revolution (1775-1783) started in 1775. However, it is important to know that Britain and America were not on good terms for a long time. For example, the Stamp Act passed in 1765 by the British parliament, that Americans didn?t pay.? NO TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION? was the reason why they didn?t pay. They wanted someone to defend their rights in the British Parliament. At this point, the king of England was furious because of the Americans? behaviour. After that, in 1767, Townshend imposed duties on goods entering American ports. To guarantee to safety of the people collecting these taxes, some extra troops had been sent to America. However, a group of extremists decided to make life as difficult as possible for these soldiers. ...read more.

Middle

Some Northern states banned slavery outright, and some provided for the gradual end of slavery. Before any meaningful reform could happen, people needed to recognize that the economic benefit was overshadowed by the immorality, and inhumanity of slavery. Women's role in society was also altered by the American Revolution. Women who ran households in the absence of men became more respected. Abigail adams, became an early advocate of women's rights when she prompted her husband to "REMEMBER THE LADIES" when drawing up a new government. Some ministers, particularly in Puritan Massachusetts, stressed the superiority of men. Enlightened thinkers rejected this idea and knew that a republic could only be successful if its citizens were virtuous and educated. Who were the primary caretakers of American children? American women. If the republic were to succeed, women must be educated so they could teach their children. The first American female academies were founded in the 1790s. This idea of an educated woman became known as "REPUBLICAN MOTHERHOOD." As in the case of the abolition of slavery, changes for women would not come overnight. But the American Revolution ignited these changes. Education and respect would lead to the emergence of a powerful middle class of women. ...read more.

Conclusion

The French government didn?t have anymore money (spent more than what they earnt and because of the military support provided to the Americans during the American Revolution) and the tax systems were not very effective. At his point, the french (except the nobles) are very unhappy and the government is having a lot of trouble getting money. The majority of french people wanteda constitutionnal monarchy and the privileges abolition. They never wanted all the violence that happened afterwards for example the Hundreds of people killed at la Bastille or during the TERROR period when 18000 people get killed. I think the American revolution was the best one because it provided the americans a enjoyable future once everything was over. More people are killed, but the victory brought soo many social and political improvements like the separated powers, the blak people?s situations? Some improvements may be felt later like the women status in the society. As a conclusion, even if the American Revolution resulted in more casualties, (which seems normal to me because after all, there were several big armies that were fighting)it had provided Americans a lot of positive changes whereas in France, after the revolution, the life of most of the Citizen didn?t change and moreover, there were terrifying and unstable periods such as the REIGN OF TERROR. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Factors leading to the French Revolution.

    Other people said the tax system was corrupt and they also said that some tax collects didn't give all the money to the goverment. In the same year King louis XVI asked the first and second estate people to help him reform the country, which ment louis wanted them to pay some tax but not suprising they said No.

  2. 'Law and Order in the American West'

    � One of the most famed and prominent outlaw gangs in the history of the American West were the James-Younger Gang, who were involved in a number of train, bank and stagecoach robberies during the late 19th century. It was outlaws like these and the absence of government control that

  1. Was Oystermouth Castle typical of the castles built in Wales during the middle Ages?

    But later when attacked again, was built out of stone. So it was finally in the 13th century did Oystermouth manage to develop its military features and catch up with the rest of Wales. During 13th century curtain walls replaced wooden palisades and gatehouses were added.

  2. To what extent was slavery the key cause of the American Civil War?

    Neither North nor South wanted to be outnumbered in Pro vs Anti slavery population and not least in the senate so as America began to expand westwards a series of compromises to balance slavery were set up. The Missouri compromise of 1820 highlighted the predicament perfectly.

  1. An analysis of American History 1865-1920

    and industrialists (wanting to capitalize on the rich mineral wealth of the South coal, iron, oil and of course to maximize its labor supply), and support also from the national institutions (army, church, Freedman's Bureau, state militias, Union League). With this force behind it the black's status was gradually improving.

  2. The French Rev DBQ

    "Not only is it the great instigator which terrifies the aristocrats, it is also the great instigator which redresses all abuses and comes to the aid of all citizens" (Source C). For these reasons Source C is very useful to a historian studying the importance of the Jacobins since it summarizes the Jacobins in a paragraph.

  1. The Emergence of Universal Medicare

    The growth of universal Medicare is combined with two acts to help provide free access to hospital and physician services which were covered by the legislation. The beginning of Medicare started in the province of Saskatchewan in 19626. Tommy Douglas, the father of socialized medicine made the first provincial health care of legislation from the years of 1944 to 1961.

  2. Causes of the French Revolution

    changing the world, the government and all that, we must change the way we think and psychologically and mentally function. Beliefs are like the sparks that set fire to the fuel that is the dissatisfaction with the government or with whatever you may call it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work