• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Haig - Source related work.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How far does source A prove that Haig did not care about the live of his men? [7 marks] Source A is an extract from a diary entry written by Sir Earl Douglas Haig (Commander of the Battle of the Somme) in July 1916. As a result of this source A is a primary source as it was written at the time. The source is all about the death toll that Britain would be expecting. The source shows different ways to see Haig's intentions. One views him as a cold hearted man trying to kill innocent men by putting them into war and another shows him trying to win the war for Britain. The latter is evident in source A when it is said, "The Nation must be taught to bear losses" thus showing that Haig was expecting a lot of casualties. Source A cannot be totally useful in proving whether Sir Earl Douglas Haig cared about the lives of his men, since the source is only a small extract from a much larger diary entry. ...read more.

Middle

This can be seen as a fatalistic attitude as it could reduce Haig to not really making an effort to secure the position of his men and thus endangering the lives of his men. So unknowingly he could be seen as not caring for his men, but rather trying to appease the nation. One must understand that both sources have their limitations. From wider reading one knows that in source B where Haig mentions, "The men are in splendid spirits" is the only extract written by Haig, which mentions the morale of the soldiers, this leads us to the intriguing question of what is so different about the extract. Source B differs from other extracts that are typical of the time. All other Haig's Diary entries (Britain and the great war- John Murray 1994) do not mention the morale of his men and in retrospect we know that source B contradicts other reliable sources about what is written about the outcome of the first battle. We now know that 60,000 men died or were injured in the first few hours. ...read more.

Conclusion

Firstly, if it was addressed to the public whereby his men would be aware of his thoughts and concerns, it could be depicted that he did not care about his men. We can deduce this because if his men knew that their Commander's attitude and belief towards them was so low it would significantly affect their morale. Secondly if it was just for the attention of the Commander himself and a few other elite members (other Generals) it would not come to be known by the army officers themselves. In this instance it can be simply seen as Haig being realistic and keeping all his options open. Undoubtly there will be casualties in war and it is the job of the governing bodies to appease the people of the nation, since in war you need the people of the nation to be on your side, hence resulting in what Haig says in source B. So in conclusion the answer is that source A can only be used as evidence against him but not to prove that he did not care about the lives of his men. Helalur Rahman Khan 3894 10548 Stepney Green School ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. "Evacuation was a great success" Do you agree? Source based work.

    Do you agree or disagree with this interpretation? Use sources and your own knowledge to explain your answer. Evacuation was introduced because Britain was at war with Germany and they expected the Germans to bomb Britain. There were three main evacuation periods. The first started on September 1st 1939 and was called 'The Phoney War'; this first wave of evacuation took place because Britain expected air raids.

  2. The Somme - source related study.

    Later, Lieutenant Colonel Sands saw that the Germans had the high ground on all three sides of the valley that he would attack down. He would have to march down this valley for 750 yards. He believed his men would march into disaster.

  1. Haig and 'The Battle of the Somme' - source related study.

    I think that this source is a bit extreme, but is reliable and should be considered by historians when studying Haig and the Battle of the Somme. (d) Study sources F, G and H. Do sources G and H prove that source F is wrong?

  2. Votes for women - source related questions.

    They had, for example, policy targets to meet concerning the welfare state, like reforms of healthcare and those to prevent poverty. Then there was also the empire to think of, many countries were starting to want independence and some such as South Africa and British India had already been given

  1. South Africa - source related study

    Both of the sources are valuable as it backs up what Tyler was saying and it also gives us some sort of a picture for us to think about when we use the other information given to us in Source E.

  2. Votes For Women - Source related study.

    In 1910 and 1911, therefore, Conciliation Bills (so-called because they only asked for the vote for one million women, so as not to annoy the opposition) were passed with large majorities. Even though only women with complete control over a house, part of a house or a shop could vote

  1. Haig and the Somme - source related study

    Furthermore the source is from 1920s, so the historian would have been able to research on the events thoroughly. Finally it also gives a fair description of the German losses 'losses had been so high'. Both source D (ii) and source E comment reliably on the weather conditions.

  2. Britain in the age of total War - source related study

    Source C is useful in some ways and not at all in others. It is useful because it shows the good and bad effects of the Blitz. It shows how the bombs had a physical effect on the British people.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work