• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

history coursework - arab israeli conflict

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

GCSE COURSEWORK ASSIGNMENT MODERN WORLD STUDY: THE ARAB-ISRAELI CONFLICT Question 1 In 1948 the village of Deir Yassin was invaded by Jewish Irgun fighters. By noon on the same day they had killed everyone in the entire village - women and children included. There is no real proof about who is to blame for the Palestinian refugee problem. The reasons of the fight over Deir Yassin go back since the partition of Palestine. The partition meant that majority of the population, the Arabs, would get less land that the Jews. On the other hand, the Jews did not get Jerusalem, their homeland, included in their area. Both sides were unhappy about the land they were given, so they started to fight each other to get the land back. In December 1947 violence broke out between them and they grew more and more aggressive until massacre itself in April the next year. The Jews thought that if they committed the mass murder, they could gain back the land. Deir Yassin would have been an extremely important strategic point for whoever had control of it. This made the village more valuable to both the Arabs and Jews, which meant it was the centre for violence. The two sources are written about the same event but express the opinions of different people. ...read more.

Middle

To conclude, the 2 sources are totally different. They differ in almost every way, and each source is extremely biased, the sources are not reliable at all, we can only use them to see individual opinions. Neither of the sources either have proof to support the opinions, for example source B tells us that the massacre was undertaken by people who had nothing to do with the government, but the Israelis have no evidence for this, so we have no reason to believe this. The sources give so diverse facts and opinions, it is impossible to draw conclusions about who is to blame for the refugee problem, we can only have our own opinion. GCSE COURSEWORK ASSIGNMENT MODERN WORLD STUDY: THE ARAB-ISRAELI CONFLICT Question 2 Although sources A-F include a lot of information, it is hard to analyze the sources to make the conclusion of who is to blame for the Palestinian refugee problems. Many of the sources are biased and don't give both sides to the story. The 6 sources give us lots of information concerning the opinions of the different sides, but when it comes to concluding and giving a fair opinion, it's almost impossible. We need to analyze each source for their efficiency, and asses them to find out their purpose and reliability. Source A gives us the Palestinian view of the Arab exodus from Palestine. ...read more.

Conclusion

The source states that if Palestinians settled elsewhere, the whole problem would stop. It is basically a confirmation to source D. This source pretty much proves that the Arabs are causing the refugee problem. The last source, F, is 2 photos. They say that the Arab was born in Jerusalem, but can't go back to live there. The Jew was not born in Palestine, but she can return there any time she wants. The Arab and the Jew can still say exactly the same thing20 years later, as their situations are exactly the same, nothing has changed. The source is defiantly not biased as it has the perspective of a Jew and an Arab. It doesn't explain the cause of the problem, but it tells us that the problem has not been solved yet. To conclude, these sources do not let you come to a conclusion. Source A contradicts source B, and source C contradicts source B. Sources D and E tell us that the Arabs didn't want compensation and acted awkwardly to annoy the UN, which contradicts source A again. With all the sources saying that others are wrong, and the lack of evidence for sources A, B and E, we cannot believe any of them, or come to any sort of agreement about who really is to blame for the refugee problem. We need more evidence and facts to come to a firm conclusion. William Fisher ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. WW1 Coursework

    To try and leave the war, many people tried to fake an illness, but doctors treated them until they gave in. Doctors would do this as they wanted as many soldiers as they could have on the battle front. If someone were potentially ill they sometimes just torture him or

  2. Arab-Israeli Conflict

    2. Why did Israel withdraw from the Gaza strip? In December 2003 Prime Minister Ariel Sharon announced that 'quitting the Gaza Strip was the only way forward.' This was a heavily political move as most Israeli's agreed with him, but he was faced with the unusual problem of having little support within his own party.

  1. Black Country Museum

    We were not allowed upstairs in both the rich and the poor houses; this was because there was a lack of fire escapes.

  2. Black Country Museum Local History Coursework

    Torches were also used instead of candles due to health and safety reasons. Fire extinguishers were certainly not used during the 19th century. However, the Health & Safety Work Act 1974 ensures all public building have fire alarms and extinguishers.

  1. Does sources A to F suggest that Israels desire to establish a homeland in ...

    In 1951 Egypt tore up the Anglo-Egyptian treaty which meant British troops had to leave the Suez military base, but Britain refused to. The result of this was increasingly violent hostility towards Britain and the British troops in Egypt. Since the establishment of the Israel, cargo shipment to and from

  2. GCSE History Coursework: How were the various groups of people affected by events during ...

    anxious to return home to their families and loved ones as many of them were conscripts. Source 11 shows the islanders were so grateful to the British soldiers, they lets some of them become Godfathers to the Argentine soldiers. There were now conflicting views over the governments of the two

  1. History Coursework - Modern World Study - The Long March

    In conclusion, I believe that Source D would be most useful to a historian studying the Long March. Although, it must be accounted for that the source would be unlikely to say anything derogatory about the CCP. Also, Source E is useful evidence that Chairman Mao used propaganda not only

  2. Using sources, who or what was most responsible for the ending of Apartheid?

    Rather, the intentions that the two sources infer, are too marginalise and intimidate black persons, which in hindsight, is exactly the principle of the Apartheid. In my opinion, source A6 is more useful, for two main reasons. Firstly, it is published in a textbook, therefore entrenching the racist ideology in

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work