• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

History Qu.1 Full Answer

Extracts from this document...


Is there sufficient evidence in Sources D to J to explain why the Troubles broke out in Northern Ireland in 1969? 'The Troubles' refers to a period of violence that broke out in Northern Ireland, from 1968 to 1998. Sources D, E and G to an extent highlight how the discriminations against each religion have built up over time. Source D gives us a Catholic perspective, whilst sources E and G are in favour of Protestants. The other sources, F, H, I and J give us more of an insight into the short-term reasons for the Troubles. All of the sources provide an insight into the long-term problems that 'The Troubles' caused, and how they affected the attitudes of people generations down the line. Take source D, for example - B. Devlin describing her school days. This gives us some insight into prejudice teachings among the Catholics, but it does not illustrate the Protestant point of view. The source indicates that The Troubles are an ongoing problem, and stems from past events, for example, her school Vice Principal describes when "All her family had suffered at the hands of the British forces." Devlin also explains how the Vice Principal's beliefs were that Protestants weren't hated, just viewed not to be Irish. This suggests that the Vice Principal (Mother Benignus) ...read more.


Emotive language is used in the picture's caption, which is a device that will provoke sympathy for the Protestants, for example 'stripped naked' and 'perished'. The term 'wild Irish' is used against the Catholics by the Protestants, because they view them as traitors to the country, something that Mother Benignus in source D also believes. The reason for the event in source G is long term. It was caused by an uprising of Catholics who had had their land taken away by English Protestants, and led a rebellion against them. Source H is a much more shocking image in comparison to the other sources, partly because it is a photograph and partly because it appears to display police brutality. The photo was taken at a time of great political change in the world. For example, Martin Luther King was leading civil rights marches for black people in America, and others were protesting against the war in Vietnam. Because police brutality was depicted in this photograph, it gave the British Government bad publicity which led to international condemnation. Ireland was inspired by the civil rights movements taking place internationally, and protests began against gerrymandering. This can be compared with source D, written by Devlin who leads many civil rights marches. ...read more.


Terence O'Neill had tried to stop this, but his proposals were met with violence. This can be linked to source F, where civil rights marches took place to stop gerrymandering. The police forces were almost entirely Protestant, and The Special Powers Act in 1922 was originally set up to deal with the IRA, but it gave the police in Northern Ireland more power than any other police force in the UK. They could suspend the civil liberties of a suspect. This was used more often on Catholics as the IRA became less of a threat during the 1960s. All of this built up the Catholic's resentment towards Protestants, just like in sources H and I where it led to civil rights marches and loyalist attacks. The conclusion I have reached is that although there is evidence in sources D to J, to explain why the Troubles broke out, many of the sources are biased in some shape or form. This leads me to believe that there just isn't enough sufficient evidence to give me a solid answer to the question. However, all the sources offer me different perspectives of different communities, which is a useful insight into some of the reasons for why the Troubles broke out. ?? ?? ?? ?? Meghan Mooney ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Was Cromwell a Hero or a Villain?

    1668 A final bad comment came from Christopher Hill. He was impartial and supported both sides of the argument. His bad comment read: "Cromwell was a clever man seeking power." 1970 However, his good comment read: "Cromwell was a good man seeking religious government." 1970 Despite the other bad comments, there were also a few good ones.

  2. How far was the monarchy responsible for its own downfall in September 1792? Explain ...

    Marie Antoinette sent details of French military plans to Austria, proving that the Queen did not stand united with France. Furthermore, people questioned where the Kings allegiances lay, on the 20th June 1792 people poured into the Tuileries demanding the King wear the tricolour in support for the republic.

  1. Was Oliver Cromwell a villain?

    This might have also prevented more bloodshed due to the prevention of an invasion as the other countries feared our army. The shooting of Leveller ringleaders was justified as they were no more than mutineers that had betrayed their country.

  2. Life of Oliver Cromwell

    However, on 3rd September 1650, Cromwell fought an unexpected battle, between him and the Covenanter Army in the battle of Dunbar. Killing 4,000 Scottish soldiers and capturing 10,000. This gave the New Model Momentum, and eventually took Edinburgh within a few weeks!

  1. Since the Good Friday Agreement in 1998 there has been a relative period of ...

    The Orange Order marches consist of people marching in orange, wearing sashes, carrying banners and they often are accompanied by drums. On the other hand Catholics have the same but they wear green instead of orange. They also have clubs and societies like an Ancient order to match that of the Protestants.

  2. Olympics More Than Just A Sport

    signs of any country on planning to, although, one part of the journey to Beijing 2008 Olympics was the Torch Relay. The Torch relay, began on March 24th, it was intended that the Torch relay theme was "Journey of Harmony" with the slogan "Light the Passion, Share the Dream".

  1. Was Oliver Cromwell a hero or a villain?

    The main reason why they disliked him so much was that people blamed Cromwell for all the bad things that happened as historians made up stories that could never of happened; a story tells of four-year Cromwell punching two-year Prince Charles in the face but these two people never met when they were young.

  2. The History of Bradford. How Undercliffe Cemetery display the values of the Victorians.

    Paternalism was a value within the Victorian times that every man governed over, the cemetery corroborates that paternalism was in fact a facet that helps one understand where men were within society. In a more general format the cemetery?s main feature shows that paternalism was the most dominant element of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work