• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

History Sourcework - 'Kristallnact was a spontaneous event by the German People' How far do these sources support this claim.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History Sourcework: Study all the Sources. 'Kristallnact was a spontaneous event by the German People' How far do these sources support this claim. When looking at this question, it becomes obvious that there are three different possibilities of how Kristallnact came about: 1.It was a spontaneous event by the German people in anger to the death of von Roth 2. It was ordered by Hitler, in order to eliminate the Jews. 3. It was planned by Goebbels in order to help him with his power struggle within the Nazi Party. The first option of kristallnacht being a spontaneous event by the German people is supported by sources B and D. Source D describes how the signs reading 'Jews not wanted' appeared put up by the German people, o ward off Jews from their tow. This mild hatred could have led them to riot during Kristallnact, but I believe that this account may have been slightly over exaggerated as the tone is very negative and highlights the negative factors while remaining too vague. ...read more.

Middle

He took interviews and gathered information until he concluded that the Nazi party had ordered the rioting and caused it to happen and furthermore that most German people had not participated in the rioting themselves. Source F is a cartoon drawn by a Russian artist for the Russian newspaper. The Russians bitterly hated the Germans and so if there was a rumour that the Nazis had committed the crimes on kristallnacht then hey would take it and demonstrate to there people how evil capitalism was as the government ordered its own people in Germany to be purged. Source G is another cartoon drawn some weeks after kristallnacht when appeasement had ended, The magazine began to think about the way in which the Nazis were treating its people and so drew this cartoon. This cartoon can be applied both to kristallnacht and other events that had happened. This cartoon is about the evils of Nazism not just Kristallnact. As 'outsiders' so to speak they will not fully comprehend how the Nazi party conflicts inside between senior officials. ...read more.

Conclusion

They would have suspected and heard who started kristallnacht and what happened really. This adds extra credit o these sources. Source I stands alone as it matches into none of the other three categories. It only shows Hitler's regret at what happened. It doesn't discuss what actually happened on kristallnacht or who started it. It therefore has no relevance to any other source. In conclusion I believe that those sources group into option 3 have he most relevance and support on a single theory. The theory of spontaneous action has two sources to support it, one of which is biased, the other which is vague and inaccurate in its relevance to kristallnacht. Non-Germans who do not fully understand the political climate of the time write all the sources that group into option 2. They believe that it was not a spontaneous event but believe that Hitler ordered it. People who lived in Germany write option 3, people who understood what were happening and what the Nazi party was up to. Options 2&3 have greater numbers than option 1 which means that the sources overall disagree with the theory of spontaneous attack. J.Harratt ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Source Investigation: Why did Kristallnacht take place?

    Source D endorses this by mentioning that in the weeks preceding Kristallnacht, there had already been 'signs of unrest amongst the masses'; here, the use of language suggests that the ordinary Germans were the 'masses' who would eventually become out of hand, and spontaneously start the great riots against the Jews.

  2. The Final Solution - Sources Questions

    However it should be noted that this does not prove the Germans were 'unwilling executioners.' Source 9 is very interesting in the debate of whether the German nation were 'willing executioners.' The writer's mother "was convinced that everything the Nazis did was right and essential."

  1. Kristallnacht was a spontaneous even by the German people. How far do these ...

    friend of Hitler and she may have been trying to protect him on the other hand, as the account was taken a long time after the actually event happened, Frau Troost would have grown elderly and might have forgotten some of the details and mixed up the truth from lies.

  2. What was the main cause of Kristallnacht?

    The description was written by a German Jew, who were all likely to exaggerate the severity of the events to provoke sympathy for their race. For instance, yes, there might have been some anti-Semitic unrest, but not so much to cause Kristallnacht.

  1. Modern World History Coursework - Reichstag Sourcework

    Van Der Lubbe spoke about the events just after they happened, therefore in this case, source B does not support source A. Another point to make about the sources is why they were created. Source A was from Rudolf Diels' personal account, whereas source B was given to a jury during trial.

  2. GCSE History Coursework: Reichstag Fire 1) ...

    Source F is a quote from Goering's trial at Nuremburg in 1946 for war crimes. It says that 'What General Halder says is not true'. He goes on to say 'Even if I had started the fire, I would certainly not have boasted about it'.

  1. Why did Kristallnacht take place? Source based work.

    I think this because it was written 16 years after the event and therefore ones memory may be blurred. Fritz Hesse was a journalist and he could of made some of these things up to make his work more interesting to the public; he could of heard rumours and broadcasted it.

  2. 'Kristallnacht was a spontaneous event by the German people' - How far do these ...

    Source B is a secret report prepared by the Nazi Supreme court which gives it strong credibility. It states how Hitler was told by Goebbels to neither promote these demonstrations nor discourage them if they started spontaneously. Source D is by a German-Jew describing the weeks before Kristallnacht.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work