How did the Germans and British interpret events at Dunkirk so differently? How did they select and edit information to suit their point of view?

Authors Avatar

Vimalraj Arumugam 9P              History Common Task                         08/05/2007

Question: How did the Germans and British interpret events at Dunkirk so                    differently?  How did they select and edit information to suit their point of view?

        There are numerous scrutiny’s contiguous the Dunkirk evacuation.  Was it a triumph or a disaster?  How did both sides demonstrate propaganda videos to suit their observations?  Annotations were made by mutually sides to give their judgment on the Dunkirk evacuation.   The Battle of Dunkirk lasted from around May 25 to June 3, 1940.  The German forces swept north to capture Calais, holding a large body of Allied soldiers trapped against the coast on the Franco-Belgium border.  It became clear the battle was lost and the question now became how many Allied soldiers could be removed to the relative safety of England before their resistance was crushed.

         

From May 22 preparations for the evacuation began, codenamed Operation Dynamo, commanded from Dover by Vice-Admiral Bertram Ramsay. He called for as many naval vessels as possible as well as every ship capable of carrying 1,000 men within reach. It initially was intended to recover around 45,000 men of the British Expeditionary Force over two days, this was soon stretched to 120,000 men over five days. On May 27 a request was placed to civilians to provide all shallow draught vessels of 30 to 100 feet for the operation.  The Allied held area was reduced to a 30 km block by May 28. Operations over the rest of May 28 were more successful, with a further 16,000 men recovered but German air operations increased and many vessels were sunk or badly damaged including nine destroyers.  On June 1 another 65,000 were rescued and the operations continued until June 4, evacuating a total of 338,226 troops aboard around 700 different vessels.

Join now!

        Now the synopsis of the evacuation has been alleged, but was it a victory or a disaster for both sides and how did they administer to edit the evacuation to suit their side.  To start with the Germans a victory for their side because they made British troops retreat.  This was a superior source of propaganda.  Secondly the allies were weakening.  This intended the German diplomacy were functioning.  The disaster for the Germans is they allowed several thousand men to escape their boundary of defence and security.  Also this meant that the English would have had the chance to ...

This is a preview of the whole essay