• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Did Tsar Nicholas 2nd Survive The 1905 Revolution

Extracts from this document...


How Did Tsar Nicholas 2nd Survive The 1905 Revolution? There are several factors that help our understanding of how the tsar and his regime endured the turmoil of the 1905 revolution. However, one thing is for sure, after the uprising and swift, brutal suppression of the revolutionaries on the 22nd of January 1905 outside the gates of the Winter Palace, the Nicholas 2nd and his administration received a drastic wake up call. Even though the monarchy received a hard slap on this day, the tsar himself was in no immediate danger; the ignorance of the instigator, Father Gapon, ensured that he didn't even know that the tsar was not occupying the Palace at this time. There is much debate as to whether or not the events of 1905 constituted a revolution at all. Leon Trotsky, a famous and influential revolutionary writer stated that it was merely a 'dress rehearsal' for 1917, and he is not without support. The impact that it had was minimal compared to any other of history's great political upheavals. Many Marxist historians believe that 1905 only worsened matters, making full a scale revolt inevitable and simply acting as a stepping-stone to Lenin's seizure of power. ...read more.


he made sure that he retained control of the naval and military forces. It is not true that every soldier and naval recruit stayed devoted to their god chosen tsar; in June of 1905 the crew of the Battle Ship Prince Potemkin mutinied and slit the throats of all the officers on board, and as a further sign of protest sailed the ship out of Russian waters. This was one of the only recorded cases of mutiny in the ranks, but as Witte said while commenting on the troops return from the Far East, 'if they join the revolution, then everything will collapse'. It would have been understandable if the army had decided to turn on its commander in chief, as the failure of the upper ranks to devise suitable tactics was pitiful. The decision to travel into Asian waters with the entire Baltic fleet cost 12,600 Russian lives alone, with a further 85,000 perishing in the Battle Of Mukden when Commander Stoessel sacrificed impregnable defensive ground. It was not only the support of the armed forces that the last tsar relied upon; it was also the patronage of the police forces and his secret political police, the Okhranka. ...read more.


The Manifesto itself included concessions on; Freedom of speech, freedom of assembly (the volatility of the situation meant anti-liberal views were already relaxed within government), freedom of the press and a promise to incorporate a bicameral legislative parliament in 1906. Struve and Miliukov (the respective heads of the liberal parties) accepted this constitution of behalf of the workers, deciding to with hold any criticism for the time it was released in case it did not live up to the standards promised. For the liberals this was a huge step towards a more democratic nation, and in theory it held all the answers to their many problems, but in reality it was an intelligent ploy on Witte's behalf to split the opposition, rendering it useless. The more militant wings were now isolated leaving a substantial number of opponents in want of peace. It is something I have already mentioned, but there is always strength in numbers, and separating the antagonists was vital for autocratic survival. A third Duma was also established, incorporating the classes that previously were exempt from voting. They also had supposed power over law passing; just as our house of lords did at this time, the Duma had the power to veto laws that would otherwise be passed. Every law had to be run through them before they were approved. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. How and why was Nicholas able to survive the 1905 revolution?

    the gang of robbers that is now in power, and put in its place a constituent assembly". This powerful statement was particularly threatening because it united all of the groups who were unhappy with the Tsar. This included the working class who were tired by unemployment and harsh living conditions

  2. Why was Nicholas II able to survive the 1905 revolution but was forced to ...

    In 1905, the Army and the Cossacks in Petrograd supported Nicholas. In 1917, they did not. The desire to achieve a goal is often cited as the most important factor in any successful endeavour. However, without the practical and physical forces required, these hopes and desires can often fail to be realised.


    Their goal was to overthrow the capitalist system. The socialists wanted the workers themselves to control the factories and share equally in the profits. The socialists believed that capitalism was an advance in Russia. They believed that industry provided an opportunity for all people to share the benefits of modern production.

  2. Was the October Revolution inevitable

    Unfortunately this meant that some serfs who had land for their own personal use had to sell their land, this in turn left 7.3% of the population without any land. The poorest peasants who did own land (often only a narrow strip)

  1. How Did The Tsar Survive The 1905 Revolution?

    The army was the biggest priority for the Tsar to sort out I feel because the army were his ruling force. In an autocracy such as Russia's at the time, the army is what the tsar used to enforce his laws around the empire and without his army he would have a very difficult time staying in power.

  2. How did the tsar survive the 1905 revolution?

    Factories had no access to raw materials, so they had to lay off workers or shut down. At the beginning of the war people were willing to support the war effort, but when news of defeat arrived they became disgruntled and demanded higher wages, the formation of trade unions and

  1. Why did the Tsar survive the revolution of 1905, but not that of 1917?

    Unfortunately, they did not succeed as they found themselves facing a Russian army, whom opened direct fire at them causing grave fatalities killing up to 500 people. This episode of civil unrest and massacre was called "Bloody Sunday". This anticipated a slip to the Tsar's grasp of his reign.

  2. How successful was Tsar Alexander 2nd in Solving the problems facing Russia During his ...

    It was not only the social aspects of Russia which were suffering, the agricultural Industry was at an all time low, with only 50% of all the farm production sold as surface goods. This low output of goods crippled the Russian economy, and as a result many Nobles were facing Bankruptcy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work