• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How do these sources show why O'Connor, "unquestionably the best loved, as well as the most hated man in the Chartist movement", become its leader?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Kate McPherson (917 words) How do these sources show why O'Connor, "unquestionably the best loved, as well as the most hated man in the Chartist movement", become its leader? O'Connor is seen to be the most loved man in the Chartist movement. Harney speaks of him as having a strong physical frame, a loud voice which is seen as important reasons as to why he's the natural leader of Chartism. He's acknowledging that O'Connor is not perfect but he has all the qualities that a leader should hold. They are supported by the cartoon from the middle class magazine Punch (in source 4), which whilst ridiculing O'Connor, emphasises his heroic, muscular figure. In source 2, Gammage - who is an enemy of O'Connor - echoes what Harney believes by describing him as being "stout and athletic". Gammage is being intellectual by admitting this as he doesn't normally compliment O'Connor because of his dislike for the man. The source is very qualified and also clear why Gammage thinks he was successful and popular. ...read more.

Middle

He said this because O'Connor was editor of the Northern Star so therefore had access to change what was said about him. He says O'Connor was only popular as he did not tell the truth and that his actions in the paper were to achieve "absurd and mischievous popularity". Francis Place was against Socialist ideas and therefore persisted with his hatred for O'Connor for a long time along side with Gammage, who were both supporters of the 'peaceful' Chartist William Lovett who had believed in Moral Force. Dorothy Thompson disagrees with Francis Place, by saying that even though he was the editor, he gave all views which made it unbiased. She supports Harney in source 1 when he says "...he never interferes with what I write in the paper nor does he know what I write until he sees the paper". Gammage didn't want O'Connor to be leader, as he thought "Vincent by far was his superior" (source 2). He did not believe he was appropriate to lead the movement and felt there were others which were better suited. ...read more.

Conclusion

Gammage and the Punch cartoon show agreement. The fact that Gammage, who as a supporter of Lovett and loathed O'Connor and the middle class publication who feared and dismissed the Chartists, emphasise the importance of O'Connor's appearance and abilities. Harney is obviously biased as a friend of O'Connor but he was an experienced revolutionary so his judgement is valid. Harney knows the English don't want a violent continental revolution and acknowledges O'Connor's intelligent understanding is not offering this to the Chartists. His assessment of O'Connor's intelligence therefore indicates the importance in O'Connor's leadership. Gammage perceives O'Connor's intellectual ability, but judges O'Connor as "erratic". This is unsurprising. Gammage knows of O'Connor's later mental ill health and the failure of the Land Plan when he writes in 1856. The five sources give the evidence needed to understand why he did become the leader and even his own enemies such as Gammage and Francis Place had to admit he appeared strong even if he wasn't their first choice of leader. It also shows that another favourite candidate for the Chartist leader - Harney, a revolutionary - admitted himself that O'Connor was more appropriate as he was in favour of violence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. Stalin Man or Monster

    This will make source F just as reliable as source E without any context because they are both seen as just two different opinions. Another reason of why source E is less reliable is because it was illegal to speak badly of Stalin in Russia in those times.

  2. Stalin: Man Or Monster?

    They were both probably published in newspaper and would be about current events. Source I was published in America, a capitalist country and the USSR's nemesis at the time. This would lead you to expect the source will criticise the show trials and it does.

  1. Stalin man or monster

    in reality on great engineering projects such as dams and canals, many of the workers were prisoners who had been sentenced to hard labour for being political opponents or suspected opponents of Stalin or for being kulaks. Source B doesn't show the harsh factory life under Stalin.

  2. China 1945-90 - source based questions.

    How much of Mao's China is left today? Explain your answer. When Deng came to power he immediately began to reverse what Mao had done, he wanted to change he direction that china was headed. The type of communism that Deng practised was very different from Maoist China.

  1. Stalin: Man or Monster

    By the late 1930�s many Soviet workers had improved their conditions by gaining well-paid skilled jobs and earning bonuses for meeting targets. There was an almost non-existent unemployment rate. Stalin also encouraged woman to work by setting up childcare services; four out of five new workers recruited between 1932 and 1937 were women.

  2. Stalin - Man or Monster? - Sources Questions

    Everybody has a smile on their face and the general mood is a cheerful one. This photograph is unlikely to be a true reflection of public opinion as the army suffered heavily as a result of Stalin's purges and Stalin often staged or edited photographs.

  1. Stalin: Man Or Monster?

    When the prisoners had finished building the Belomor Canal (a process in which many of them died), Stalin did not stand by them and behave towards them as equals, but turned up, stayed well away from them, and left. In reality he was rather disappointed by the canal which was to narrow and too shallow.

  2. Stalin; Man Or Monster Sources Questions

    2) Source 'D(I)' is written by Stalin in 1945. At this time Stalin would still be in power, and regarded as somewhat of a hero to his people as winning the war. It doesn't give us a very good insight into the person Stalin was, as written by himself and obviously for propaganda purposes.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work