• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How significant was James Simpsons role in solving the problem of surgery during the 19th century?

Extracts from this document...


02 March 2010 How significant was James Simpson's role in solving the problem of surgery during the 19th century? During the 19th century, there were many attempts to perform surgery without there being any risk towards the patient. This usually meant that the surgeons had to overcome problems of pain, infection and blood loss which were the three main ways in which patients died during surgery. Many individuals discovered methods to make surgery safer. One of these men was a Scottish doctor, by the name of James Simpson, who discovered the anesthetic properties of chloroform and successfully introduced it for general medical use. Of course, there were other individuals who had used different varieties of anaesthetics before James Simpson. In 1799 Sir Humphrey Davy discovered laughing gas which reduced pain felt by patients. It was mostly used by dentists during teeth extractions, which caused excruciating pain. In 1846, J.R Lister used 'ether' as an anaesthetic so the patient would be unconscious during operation. However this was soon dismissed as it irritated the lungs and caused the patient to cough during the operation as well as the fact that ether is highly flammable. ...read more.


This scared the many surgeons into not using it. There were also other who opposed chloroform because they believed that easing the pain of childbirth, it would make it unnatural and was an act against God. In addition to this, whilst the patient is unconscious surgeons became more confident and attempt more complex operations allowing infections deeper into the body and causing more blood loss. This also contributed to the rise in number of deaths since the introduction of chloroform. Yet, James Simpson soon got many people to realise that his theory was accurate and it was soon accepted. When Queen Victoria used chloroform when delivering her eighth child in 1857, the public along with many other surgeons began using it as an anaesthetic and this soon became a part of surgical practise. However although James Simpson had already tried the anaesthetic on himself, it almost immediately became clear that there were very serious side effects associated with its use and it was known to cause death in a number of instances. From 1864, numerous studies were conducted in an attempt to determine whether chloroform affected the respiratory system or the circulatory system. ...read more.


He personally administered chloroform to Queen Victoria when she gave birth to the last two of her nine children, leading to wider public acceptance of obstetric anaesthesia. The fact that there were many other individuals who were able to discover other vital things prevents James Simpson from solely being responsible for solving the problems of surgery. John Snow also proves that James Simpson was not the first to come up with the idea of 'anaesthetics', and therefore cannot really be responsible for the discovery although he played a major role in coming across chloroform. In conclusion, I believe that James Simpson's role was not very significant in the attempts to solve the problems of surgery. This is because he was able to use other people's ideas, such as John Snow, to actually discover the anaesthetic. In addition to this, there were many other individuals and factors such as War and Technology that would have impacted surgery on a bigger scale than that of James Simpson's discovery of chloroform as an anaesthetic. Although we can see his dedication in proving that chloroform was a suitable anaesthetic we can also see that there was a lot of scope for other individuals to find an anaesthetic that may have proved to be less fatal. ?? ?? ?? ?? Thamanya Kugathasan ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Jack The Ripper - Law and Order in the late 19th century

    is for this reason that the police had difficulty solving the Jack the Ripper murder. 2) Why did the Whitechapel murderers attract so much attention in 1888? There are many reasons why the Whitechapel murders caught much attention. The murders themselves were 5 killings of prostitutes by an unknown serial killer.

  2. Why did medical care need to be improved during the early 19th century

    The source is of limited use because the writer (John Rudd Leeson) was saying how bad things used to be in hospitals, but it doesn't explain what things are like at the time the book was written when improvements had been made, but we can only assume this because we

  1. The interior of the Apprentice House today bears very little resemblance to what it ...

    Also, hanging from the ceiling are various Herbs. These were typical of the period. The Herbs were used to improve the smell and help kill Lice. We are also told from Sefton's account that 'our rooms were very clean the floors frequently washed...The rooms were aired every day'.

  2. History of Medicine Revision Notes.

    Arun Thind [ag]This was his swan neck flask experiment. He used a swan-neck flask to trap germs in the neck. He heated the liquid and he noticed the liquid in the flask stayed pure because the germs had been trapped ? Realised germs were the cause of disease Arun Thind

  1. Revision notes - US History. Major events and personalities of the early ...

    Led to many homeless squatters Point of Interest: Wildcat banks don?t pay Bank of US back even though they took away the people?s land Connection: Much of land being taken away was from Louisiana Purchase American System: Who: Henry


    William Farr, another civil servant, also helped to persuade the government with his work outlining where and at what age death rates was highest, as well as what they died of. His work highlighted facts and figures which the government could not ignore nor dispute.

  1. History of plastic surgery; how plastic surgery became a usual thing in Korea

    To make a stronger point, there has been a report form the Daily magazine in Korea in 2006 that many plastic surgeons are gaining annual increases of 26% or more in the number of the number of clients. (Including both the number of foreign clients and local clients.

  2. Were the 1980 Hunger Strikes the most significant IRA event of that decade?

    When the IRA saw the publicity the Hunger Strikes were collecting, they then soon took credit for it. Also, when arguing the significance of the Hunger Strikes, an extract from ?Ten Men Dead: The Story of the 1981 Irish Hunger Strike? says ?four months before, 10,000 had taken part in

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work