• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How successful was the New Deal and why has it been the subject of so much controversy?

Extracts from this document...


According to C. Vann Woodard, "Franklin D. Roosevelt and his new deal have been both credited with recovery from the depression and blamed for the failure of recovery'. How successful was the New Deal and why has it been the subject of so much controversy? Franklin D Roosevelt introduced the New Deal with the aim to help improve the conditions within America and to bring the country out of the great depression. To do this Roosevelt needed to consider what would not only stop the depression but also to prevent a re-occurrence. After the event of the Wall Street Crash people were left living in unsuitable conditions and most were unemployed, to overcome this Roosevelt had to introduce acts, which would help the condition of the population and regain trust. Within the first one hundred days of the New Deal Roosevelt had closed the banks for four days and passed the Federal Emergency Relief Act, this gave the treasury power to investigate all banks threatened with collapse, although this did not help any of those already affected by the wall street crash, it prevented any more banks from suffering and helped gain trust back into the banking system. ...read more.


The TVA was used to build 20 dams to control floods to encourage schemes such as tree building to stop soil erosion, to encourage farmers to use more efficient means of cultivation and to produce hydroelectric power to nearby areas. On the surface it seems that the New Deal contributed a lot to the recovery of the Great depression however the was areas where's Roosevelt's decisions were criticised by not providing enough action when it was needed. This has led to much controversy; supporters of the New Deal believe the government should have intervened and argue that FD Roosevelt took the most effective action he could have done whilst sticking by his own belief, however critics of the New Deal have argued Roosevelt took too much action and should have remained to a Liase- Faire society. This was not the opposition Roosevelt received. Even the United States Supreme Court found that several of FDR's agencies created during the hundred days were unconstitutional. This action turned the Supreme Court into an immense obstacle that Roosevelt would have to cope with during his presidency. ...read more.


In 1934, he voiced the opinion that FDR was not going far enough. Coughlin was specific in calling for silver inflation, but was vague on other issues, offering no real solutions. His broadcasts attacked international bankers, Communists, labour unions, and Roosevelt's administration, as unemployment remained high. And, thirdly, Huey Long took part in the Share Our Wealth Movement by demanding that the government allow every family to get an annual income of $2,000 and a homestead or $6000 to build a home. To pay for this, the government would have to nationalise all banks. While the New Deal did much to lessen the worst affects of the Great Depression, its measures were not enough to restore the nation to full employment. Conservatives argue, for example, that it went too far, and brought too much government intervention in the economy, while those on the left argue that it did not go far enough, and that in order to be truly effective, the Roosevelt Administration should have engaged in a far more comprehensive program of direct federal aid to the poor and unemployed. But the New Deal's greatest achievements transcend sheer economic statistics, the New Deal offered hope and restored the faith of the American people. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. History coursework: Was the New Deal successful?

    welfare when they should be getting jobs, and the more welfare they acquire the more idle they become. ("Welfare kills a man's initiative...You're free to eat if you can pay for your food, and you're free to starve if you don't pay" Quote from source J)

  2. How successful was the new deal? Explain why Roosevelt Introduced the New Deal?

    At the first this policy was greeted warmly be employers and workers however it soon hit problems. Employers signed the codes and then broke them and some employers wouldn't even sign at all. Businessmen and politicians accused FDR of socialism and too much interference in private enterprise.

  1. How successful was the New Deal - FDR

    This act could indicate that there was more that Roosevelt could have done to make America a better place considering social and financial matters but failed to do so. However, Black Americans benefited from the New Deal slum clearance and housing projects.

  2. Franklin Delano Roosevelt and the New Deal - How successful was Roosevelt's New ...

    The Supreme Court declared that the NRA had no right to meddle in the New York poultry trade and that it was not their affair to deal with such matters and that it was for the state government to investigate. The brothers were acquitted and the code was declared illegal.

  1. Depression and The New Deal

    WPA workers built/improved 5900 schools, 1000 airfields, over 2500 hospitals, 69 000 km's of road and almost 13 000 playing fields. In addition, there were schemes where artists, writers and actors were employed. The National Labour Relations Act (1935) - also known as the "Wagner Act": This Act protected the right of workers to join unions.

  2. How Successful was the New Deal 1933-1941 in Pulling America Out of the Economic ...

    the Depression: "Not only did the policies of public officials help bring an economic collapse, but few public leaders acknowledged the crisis. They thought that the economy would cure itself. These ideas set limits to government action" I agree with Tindall when he says that the American government thought that the economy would cure itself.

  1. T.Roosevelt and the New Deal.

    'Whereas the main aim of the measures passed in the Hundred Days had been to provide relief and recovery, the acts of the 1935 legislation was to provide long-lasting change. The reforms of 1935 expanded the New Deal into new areas of government activity.

  2. Prohibition movement in America1920-1932.

    A sign over the top reads, "Weeks wages". Behind the bar is a very happy barman who looks pleased to be taking this man's money. The man handing over the money looks a bit drunk. There is a second picture circled within the main picture, a woman with her head and arms stretched across the table looking very distressed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work