• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How useful and reliable are these sources in explaining how womans lives were affected by World War I?

Extracts from this document...


How useful and reliable are these sources in explaining how woman?s lives were affected by World War I? In the First World War millions of people died as the Allies, consisting mainly of Great Britain, France and Russia fought the Central Powers, who included Germany and Austria-Hungary. Women?s lives in Britain, on the Home Front, were changed significantly by the First World War. Some of these changes shaped woman?s standing for the following decades while other changes were not permanent or worsened their position in British society. The following five sources all contain individual information about how woman?s lives were affected during the years of 1914-1918 and the years afterwards. Women replaced male soldiers after the start of World War 1. Women were very far away from equal status to men also the activities of the Suffragettes, who despite having the simple aim of giving better rights, often who often angered politicians with their demonstrations; this is supported by Source A1. Source A1 also informs us of the gaps created in employment due to the war. We are made aware of the fact that after the war women had proved themselves to be equally capable as men. The Suffragettes, primarily led by Emmeline Pankhurst often organized many forms of protests in order to gain the vote but called off the proceeding due to the outbreak of the Great War. ...read more.


If not for other evidence we could not have confirmed that women had worked excessively everywhere in the country during the war by this photograph meaning it is not particularly useful unless it is with other sources. Often women looked at the positive aspects of female employment, such as the woman in Source A7 who starts by saying ?Earning high wages??. This proves that she considers women in work to be positive despite many flaws and in-equality in the process. She continues with this theme and goes on to say about the extra income funding ?clothes? and ?bracelets and jewellery?. Coming towards the end she explains her verdict is too spend her money in case she is ?blown to the sky? . The author was probably an upper-class woman though which introduces an element of controversy as she was likely not to have known much about the reality for women, such as women in Source A8, especially women with families and lower-class not educated women. In reality many women earned only about 150p a week, a long way from the 5 pound stated in the poem. Many women also had families to care for therefore leaving little or no money for personal use and were often denied jobs because of their gender especially in the first year of the war and before the coalition in parliament. ...read more.


Source A1 tells of women being given political representation and women proving they were just as important to the war effort as men. Source A10 undermines this by revealing the truth, which was the fact that even though the women had been just as important, come the end of the war they were nearly back to the start as they were kicked out of their jobs and many were soon on benefits or working in domestic service. Source A10 is written by an author of history school textbooks meaning it is likely to be well researched therefore unbiased and reliable, as it is for GCSE students to use, this implies it is completely trustworthy. This source is particularly useful as it contributes to the vast information about the Great War and helps people?s understanding of life in the country at the time. 1910?s and 1920?s society was riddled with in-justice highlighted by the fact that the very same women that were praised were now criticized and by the 1920?s domestic service employment rose by 200,000, a sign of the lost hope. At this point, despite being granted the vote, it was really 3 steps forward, 2 steps back for the women of Britain. As the heroics of the FANY?s and people like Flora Sandes became a distant memory women all over Britain were soon ?handing in their notice?. These 5 sources are all helpful in different ways with varying reliability and they all provide information about the woman?s lives in World War 1 and how they changed. (1471) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. How were the lives of women on the home front affected by the First ...

    So, it was less paid and hard work for her. Although she knew that these jobs were dangerous, she still had to do it as she needed money. Almost 300 women were killed by explosions and some died from poisoning.

  2. How were the lives of women on the home front affected by the First ...

    by Mrs H.A Felstead to the Imperial War museum in January 1976. It shows that the pay for domestic service was very poor. As they worked long hours and only for �2 a month. Which helps to show why so many women went to work in factories and do the

  1. Why were British Civilians affected by World War 2?

    This was due to the fact that Britain was alone without any strong allies therefore the government needed all the support they could get to stop the almost inevitable German invasion, so they turned to women. In December 1941 the National Service Act making the conscription of women legal was passed.

  2. In what ways were people's lives affected by evacuation during the second world war?

    There would have been differences between the host families and the evacuees. Many came from slums so they had bad manners and no knowledge of hygiene. Some had never worn night clothes or slept in a proper bed and some had never even bathed before.

  1. Source Work- Women in World War 1

    Source 2 is a certificate from the Woman's Land Army for all members. It writes that they are serving their country just as much as men. This is quite significant, as this means that women did help to win the war, although it was more indirectly than the men were.

  2. World war 1

    The first source shows that Haig does not care about his men; he says that, 'The nation must be taught to bear losses', which basically means that the war can't be won without losses and the nation need to get used to this.

  1. Did The First World War Liberate British Women?

    their own meaning and history, which would inspire anyone to learn more about the different things. This source however does not have much written content and for a historian a lot of research would be needed for this source to be of any value, and it is not attributed.

  2. The First World War, and the womans actions during it, was the key reason ...

    Although the magazine illustrates women assisting the men in a positive way, it is likely that the writer is producing this for a particular audience: women workers. Hence, the source may be more subjective, as it is attempting to encourage women to help with the war effort.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work