• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How useful are these two sources as evidence for the contribution of women to the war effort in the years 1914-1918?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

4) Study sources F and G How useful are these two sources as evidence for the contribution of women to the war effort in the years 1914-1918? On there own sources F and G are useful to a diminutive extent. However it is when they are put together in context that they become very useful. Source F is an over the top propaganda poster produced by the government in 1916 for a governmental campaign. Women are portrayed as heroines for their "war effort." It aims to persuade women to enrol as munitions workers by showing a woman putting on her uniform and getting ready to work in an ammunition factory. This image is extremely persuasive as it indicates that those women who did enrol would be like the one in the poster, a woman who represents the peak of prevailing, liberation and fidelity for her country. The utility of this source is lowered due to the fact that the poster is a propaganda piece which is usually created to influence upon opinion hence in this case encourage women into industry. Another way in which the poster is persuasive is through an image in the background, which consists of a soldier preparing some weapons. ...read more.

Middle

And as I said earlier they are even more utile when seen as supporting each other. Source F could be the answer for reason why so many women were entering the industrial workforce as conveyed in the bunch of statistic in source G. 5) Study sources H, I and J and use your own knowledge. 'It was the work that women did during the war that earned them the vote'. Use the sources and your own knowledge to explain whether you agree with this interpretation. This is an opinion believed by many historians. There are many other reasons for why women gained the vote. Some of these are represented via sources H-J. Source H is an extract from a history book entitled 'Women's Suffrage in Britain, 1867 - 1928', which was written in 1980. Considering the fact that this source is from a history book, we know that it is a secondary source and that it has been based on research and therefore can be trusted. At the very beginning of the source, the author of the book openly states his or her opinion of the interpretation being nothing but basic and indistinguishable: 'A very simplified view would see the vote as a reward for loyal wartime service'. ...read more.

Conclusion

Evidently, Asquith's view is similar to that of the interpretation in the question. However, more importantly, Asquith changed his opinion and gained respect for the Suffragette campaign and thus women's suffrage despite him himself being personally victimized by the Suffragettes. Supporting the interpretation, another reason for why women gained the vote could be the Suffragettes' determination to stop their violent campaign and instead help in the war effort. Emmeline and Christabel Pankhurst, two of the leading Suffragettes, saw the war as an opportunity to prove their capability. For example, they appeared at recruitment rallies to encourage men to join the army. However, opposing the interpretation in hand is the statistic that 50% of women in the suffrage movement were in fact against the war and so didn't contribute to the war effort. Even Sylvia Pankhurst broke away from her mother's organisation, the WSPU, due to her beliefs in pacifism. In conclusion, there were a number of reasons for why women gained the vote, not only their contribution to the war effort but ultimately it was bound to come as women had been challenging their collective roles since the late 1800's. Heeten Pindoria 11P ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. What was the contribution of tanks towards winning the war for Britain?

    to find weak spots with the tank and therefore used them to their ability > Mines - Minefields and landmines have been known for cutting through the tank's bottom armour > Aircraft - The opposition could have used missiles to pierce the top armour, a weak spot Although tanks were

  2. womens crsk history

    Because of this, only older, more responsible women had been given the right. In my opinion, I think that it is not because the women were older, but because they would mainly listen to what their husband has to say, therefore, vote for the same person as her husband.

  1. Explain why the attitudes of civilians towards the war changed from 1914 to 1918

    This source also wouldn't be able to take into account the actual feelings of the soldiers etc as he wasn't there. The fact that it was written for a children's text book also has a huge influence as many gruesome details would have to be left out or toned down to accommodate for age.

  2. Assignment Two: Objectives two and three

    Source C and D were both taken, or published, at the beginning of the blitz, and they both havr captions. Source C was published on the 15th September 1940 with its original caption. Source D however doesn't say whether its caption is original, this suggests that the caption may have

  1. Votes For Women - Source related study.

    This was mentioned by Emmeline Pankhurst in 1912, according to Source D, but she felt that they had at least been noticed which was a start, "Now the newspapers are full of us." Source F is a primary source; it is a poster made during the war.

  2. Votes For Women, 1908-12 Sources Question

    Source D although very useful for finding out a Suffragette propaganda, does not tell us why women wanted the vote. Source C tells us that women want the vote because they want their point of view to be put forward, they think that their opinion is more valid than men's

  1. To What extent was Britain a Democracy by 1914

    ���Öw��jA�[���V+;.m�'UK�R�e�(tm)Y�`�`3}-�K�%�...�...~k�Ý��-5)�P��_�縳�Y�.]<��q]�(8#TԪ�'n�w�K{�i�*1/2Ò"��(c)d�d���o�[��=���u�OǺ���G� �3/4�&��;��5...�ɴ��_�h�Im.�:O�'�V37��f�Ú�� � |/�G�W�<K�)c��nG��]J[K��-Y�"Qkj� uIe�#�%���������(tm)�~jv� ���?G(c)i �x��t�u3/4��-�m�� �ã¶5��;3*�f9j����Gã|u�H��V����-$xsO�"��ͥ�"��n[ie[�:f1/4�jP��L��� -'E�S(r)�}��=/�^���Ý�BP�r���w"�3/4Z-�'G�w����?| �)"-�H�\"�.oT��"'%�2�Kc������_> �d�1/2�O���U��+�WB1/4�\I"�����...��1/2���'���xb-LQ1/4��"T�V��_�W]l�I�������t���i�vmjQEf0��(��(��(��A�h�-���1/4y�/h-=���1/4/d���� - : Ķ�� �Uï¿uÍ���k,(c)n%`��'�"��P��> ���i?�������~�i�xDB��lÆ£ua4-1=�"(r)�(��|'�,���M~�3/4 ��<�K�n��^j:���p�M���������h�.-�f����8��Z��FL�F0g���+ ?xW[�4f��T��-��i-Z����S�}�[HC"1/2��kMF[`�K���'m"T��D�(tm)��<��D��|�K�"s�����u~(r)�)�IK��M�#��"�-'�(tm)�h:1/4Rxv��z5�xy,5�(tm)��y(r)8�Z8'B�o:('��\b|q�� �a�;�r�"��<K�^\��A����2�}...oR�u�[A�]"i��_��"`hÚ���~���[���53/4�#x+M ����q��LRg�Y "�ݸ�;`��sÄ��G����-(c)��Q�-�/<9��n"��V(1/4�+#,b�It�-q/��(r)"KM4�1/2���i�--�����9�Vn��"Ó'�{Uy�1/2����K��Ý��ŷ�u O�j��+i��3Ǩ�a��N1/21/2-�i�N�7D�"f2���-i���Vk�j:ֹ��N��Y<q �w"�[ ~oì·73N�QO�-�k�A�C�-�R��=�n�ï H�٭b]'��u�"��Ū:�!"�&��7�NL�b...�I�����?�O����? � �|F�|)y�̺��t�'��e"�������4����m�/��<�I^|k1/2��oK.�sݥ�-��(r)��G-R���-�8r"��"3/4�w� �&/�*�*��'�l1/4U�������x�A�U�� ��/���Wơ���K-"...�m���R�#� �h�3/4 �-� ��e�_ _^��-hg�R���"�D-�*v0�Lf��t���_�eO�_���? �_x�B�.(r)�->�u:[";���1/2�b"R�6*(tm)�H�v���>-���� ��"jw �j�F�i�Gg'���`�nmo"�[r.Q^(�sF3n��墴��~�Iz�k����)��JJ�{[u}����C3/4���GIТ�(r)���_m.t� 7-���K-���?"�w� �k 3/4��T�r��2<�:�"�OÍ\��ã¿ï¿½ï¿½ï¿½i�k [�B�S�1/27�gkg�T'�i���\)-1/2�|��)��'���Kñ°·ï¿½n� �-H��?]A�,6-'E<'}"βf-Cn�a"�"_ 3/4=�� ���-��s�1/4--�7�X(Ԣ��.�n�$� �P1fb�$�#b�u(r)*e.J"'y[�No�>m��w�,�Ê���K��u_�'m��-�����o �{�����F�!�m��%��'�"�K��+�fGl6�\� �@R[�/_��I1/4K�/j_ /�9Z� u��k����H�z&ѭ�{i �B(r)%7�E3���F����[� ?���

  2. Both sources F and G are useful as evidence for the contribution of women ...

    These women were given the nick-name "canaries" - though it was not a term of abuse, more a nick-name of endearment as people recognised the massive importance of their job. Working with explosive chemicals meant that one explosion in a factory could trigger off many other ones.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work