• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How valuable are sources 1,5,6,7,8,9 in explaining the events of bloody Sunday?

Extracts from this document...


Bloody Sunday Coursework Question 1: How valuable are sources 1,5,6,7,8,9 in explaining the events of bloody Sunday? On Sunday, 30th January 1972, 13 Nationalist were shot dead by British Paratroopers during a march against internment in Londonderry. A 14th person died later in hospital. The exact events of "Bloody Sunday" are unclear, the enmity between the Nationalists and Unionists is so deep rooted in history that all accounts of the day are, to some extent, biased to either party. Source 1, a print created in 1587 as catholic propaganda, shows the alleged treatment of catholic bishops by English troops. The bishops are shown solemnly praying, still dressed in ceremonial robes and mitre, while being hanged and tortured. Although it is undeniable catholic priest were subjected to such torture during the British colonisation of Ireland, it is unlikely the specific events depicted in the source ever actually happened. It is far more probable that the print is a generalisation of events in Ireland, a composite of various separate events to alert catholic in England and Ireland of the plight of the Catholic bishops. ...read more.


He claims that, apart from one shot from Rossville Street, there was no gunfire or bombs from the IRA. The report had heard many nail bombs before; therefore his testimony of hearing no bombs is more likely to be true. To have heard nail bombs before suggests he had been in violent areas in the past. His limited view on these events may have allowed him to build up prejudices towards the British, especially if he had been in a Nationalist area. The content of his statement is so close to that of Source 5 is an indication that both statements are truthful. However the apparently minor discrepancy between the Sources in Source 7, where the reporter states one shot was fired from Rossville Street, reinforces the point that both witnesses only had a limited line of sight and therefore, all eyewitness reports of the day have limited value in giving the whole picture of events on Bloody Sunday. ...read more.


Source 9 is an extract from 'Provos' by Peter Taylor, A journilist with a lifetimes experience in Ireland. He suggests there was no government cover up (suggest in source 8) and Bloody Sunday was simply the inevitable result of centuries of conflict between the two groups. This sentiment is strongly backed up by such long-term causes as Source 1. The conclusion '[Bloody Sunday] was a tragedy waiting to happen' is a very fair one based on the evidence gathered, although, it still was the Paras one pulled the trigger and killed 13 people. Taylor's lifetime experience in Northern Ireland may have given Taylor a clearer view of events in the country, conversely, it may have given him time to build up prejudice against one of the groups. While writing 'Provos' Taylor spent much of his time living in derry, and around the bogside, this suggests Taylor may have been lenient towards the IRA and Nationalists. However, with the fair, reasoned conclusion Taylor reaches, this seems insignificant, even if he was biased, the source is reasoned enough to make itself very valuable. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Ireland and World War 1

    3 star(s)

    Even though Connolly was a big figure in Ireland during the war, his ideology wasn't and Socialism made little impact in Ireland during this period. d. Industrialists- Industrialists in Ireland were usually wealthy, Protestant and Unionist. They were for the war for a couple of reasons.

  2. Northern Ireland - Bloody Sunday.

    Many people in Derry were angry that a British judge had been appointed to investigate the actions of the British Army. Some advised that the Inquiry should be boycotted but the majority of people decided to attend. As a result the people of Derry co-operated with the Inquiry but they were amazed at the results of the investigation.

  1. The long term causes of Bloody Sunday

    longer rule themselves but in the north of Ireland there is less violence and less discrimination to Catholics as there was direct rule from the English government. Some of the reforms from the civil rights movement were made. The long term causes of Easter Rising are that when England colonized

  2. Why Did ‘Bloody Sunday’ Take Place? (Russian History Sources Question)

    This source shows the increase in the amount of workers between 1890 and 1900, and these workers are all likely to feel angry and annoyed about the disgusting working conditions that they are having to work through. Even though these sources aren't directly related to the event of Bloody Sunday,

  1. Which of these two sources would a historian studying 'Bloody Sunday' find the more ...

    We also do not know why the writer wrote the account. It is unlikely that it was not intended for public view as he uses descriptive language, not usually used in diaries and personal letters. I think that it was perhaps for a newspaper or propaganda material to try and convince others to the point or view of the Bolsheviks.

  2. The build up to Bloody Sunday, and why it happened.

    On the 4th of November The British army moved into the Bogside area and Creggan and made their way into homes taking 17 men away from internment. The following day Derry came to a holt, many people went on strike.

  1. What happened on Bloody Sunday?

    scene of the killing.] The average age of the victims is 25. Consequences of Bloody Sunday After all the chaos that occurred, the people of the Bogside, Derry and Northern Ireland mourned the deaths of the thirteen defenceless victims. The British Government was under increasing pressure as many people believed the army had summarily executed 13 unarmed civilians.

  2. “Why has it proved so difficult to reach agreement about what happened on Bloody ...

    These sources, in some parts, contradict each other. The first shot will always be one of the main issues to consider, given that the soldiers could be partially justified in their action if they were being fired upon. The biased nature of the sources makes it hard to come to a conclusion.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work