• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

I believe that General Haig's, statement on his interpretation of the importance of the battle of the Somme is not a valid one because

Extracts from this document...


Task 2 23rd March 06 How Valid Is This Interpretation of The Battle of The Somme I believe that General Haig's, statement on his interpretation of the importance of the battle of the Somme is not a valid one because of the fact that Haig had the motive to lie and some of the statements he made where untrue. I will back this belief up in the following essay. The first major point that General Haig makes in his interpretation of the battle of the Somme was "German soldiers are now practically beaten men, ready to surrender". This basically is saying that the Germans soldiers were ready to admit defeat, which inevitability sent German moral spiralling down. This could be a valid statement because the German soldiers had sustained huge casualties (164,055) and moral was low because of this; however I don't believe that this statement is valid because there is no evidence that proves that the German soldiers were ready to surrender. There was no sign of mutiny in the German camp, which is usually a sign of surrender. Also Haig seems to ignore the fact that British morale is also low at this time. ...read more.


On the other hand there is evidence that this statement was not valid, as if the Germans had been forced of a defensive position as Haig states then why did the war continue for two years after the battle of the Somme? I think Haig is trying to make out he is doing his job properly by forcing Germans to change there tactics but there is no evidence to prove this. The final major point that Haig made about the Somme was " The German casualties have been greater than ours" this statement could be valid because the British casualties have been estimated at 415,000 and the German casualties have been estimated at 450,000 to 600,000 and it is known to be closer to 600,000 than to 450,000. If Haig meant "ours" as in allies then our total loss will have been greater or close to the German casualties list as the French lost 195,000 and this added onto the British total gave a much larger figure of 610,000 lost allied casualties. But this again does not support Haigs understanding to the battle. ...read more.


and his poor tactical decisions (was it a big push or a war of attrition) and this gave him the motive to lie and the reasons to suggest that the Somme was a greater success that it actually was as his job was on the line. In conclusion I believe that General Haig's interpretation of the battle of the Somme is not a valid one because the amount of truth written in his statement is widely questionable " the German soldiers being ready to surrender" for example. Also he gives us no reason to believe that any information is valid as he does not back up statements with statistics or facts " the German casualties have been greater than ours" in this statement there should be figures of German casualties vs. British to make it a more believable comment. Haig was exaggerating to make his position look better " we have proved our ability to force the enemy out of a strong defensive position" which again is over exaggerated and there is no evidence to prove that it is true. So therefore I personally believe that Haigs interpretation of the battle of the Somme in a non-valid one. Written by Lauren Hazard ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. Explain the importance of the battle of Britain as a turning point of the ...

    During the operation the British Merchant Navy- crewed mainly by amateur sailors - evacuated over 330,000 British troops and 10,000 French troops from the Dunkirk pocket, This amazing feat was accomplished due to Hitler's Generals halting their ground troops and only allowing the Luftwaffe to advance, This allowed us the

  2. The Defensive Features of Rochester Castle in 1215

    The next feature which the attackers would come across would be the ditch, which would be extremely steep in medieval times and if the weather was wet it would be very slippery and could even cause people to break bones.

  1. How important was Haig's role in the successes and failures of the British Army ...

    Haig was also heavily criticized by the Prime Minister David Lloyd George who described Haig as being 'brilliant to the top of his army boots'. Haig was heavily criticized for not being able to have the creativity to build new weapons but one think he did was encourage the use of tanks which latter paid off.

  2. How important were Haig's tactics in bringing an end to WW1?

    The casualties at the end of the Somme were horrific, six hundred and twenty thousand allied troops died. However, four hundred and fifty thousand German troops died which was a slight plus to all the allied casualties, and some of those were some of Germanys best and most experienced soldiers.

  1. Was General Haig a donkey or a great commander?

    The fact that "the Flaunders front...had weakened the German strength to a point where the damage could not be made good" also seems to feature heavily in the defence of Haig, a point which is probably true. Therefore the Battle of 3rd Ypres meant that the "German sword had become blunted."

  2. The great war: The battle of the Somme.

    Both sides wanted peace on their own terms and the morale of each army stayed high enough for the war to be continued. In the end, the 'Big Push' was regarded as the way through stalemate, but even this fell through and stalemate continued on the Western Front for most of the First World War.

  1. The Battle of the Somme

    They carried on, even when they saw men dying around them. At the Somme, they were led to believe the bombardment had been a success and fought on. It was soon obvious this was not the case but the men courageously carried on throughout the German machine-gunning.

  2. The Battle of the Somme

    However, Lord Kitchener's campaign to recruit volunteer troops was slowly increasing the population of British forces. By July, Britain had gathered enough forces to fight a battle that would force a significant number of German troops to be moved from Verdun.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work