• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"In the years 1865-1868 the Fenians did not pose a serious threat to British Rule in Ireland" To what extent do the extracts support this view?

Extracts from this document...


"In the years 1865-1868 the Fenians did not pose a serious threat to British Rule in Ireland" To what extent do the extracts support this view? (16 marks) It is agreeable that to a certain extent "in the years 1865-1868 the Fenians did not pose a threat to British Rule in Ireland". This is because the Fenian movement did not achieve its aims, which were to overthrow British power and gain independence in Ireland by creating a mass uprising. However it was still significant in the long term, because it gained a lot of publicity, which as a result caused the British Government to discuss Irish issues and served as inspiration for future organisations. The Fenian movement was a secret revolutionary organisation established in Ireland and the United States in 1858. They gained a fair amount of support in the 1860's and even had their own newspaper 'The Irish People' run by the Irish founder and leader James Stephens. The society had been introduced as a result of the 1865 Potato Famine, which had caused a poor economic situation in Ireland. Throughout these desperate times the British government had not given any help to the Irish and so the Irish felt extremely resentful towards them. ...read more.


'inducing its dupes to engage in breaches of the law, to disturb the minds of other and to bring public vengeance on themselves'. The extract states that the movement 'had great influence in bringing about mischief', meaning that the Fenian's created trouble and did not produce any significant changes in Ireland. However it does imply that they did threaten British Rule to a certain extent, in view of the fact that the Catholic Church was actively trying to prevent the Fenian Uprising from occurring. This was due to the fact that they did not agree with the violent methods used by the Fenian's and so they influenced people to oppose it by making it seem unfavourable and appointed informants to notify the government of all of the Fenian's plans. This is confirmed when the Archbishop pronounces that the job of the bishops is 'to prevent the spread of secret societies and to check everything revolutionary'. The middle class did not support the Fenian's because there was a strong belief of Laissez-faire or 'Leave it alone', which meant that they did not want to be involved as they did not have any interest in the matter and did not want to finance the organisation and buy weapons. ...read more.


An example of one of these groups was the Irish Republican Army, which became responsible for the violent bombings of the city of Manchester and the Grand Hotel in Brighton. The main impact the movement had was that it still managed to get William Gladstone and the British Government to recognise the problems within Ireland. Whereas before it was a natural and acceptable state of affairs to ignore problems in Ireland, after the Fenian movement they had no choice to give the Irish justice in order to be at peace with each other. To conclude it can be seen that the Fenian movement did not pose a major threat to British Rule between the years 1865-1868. This is because it failed considerably in achieving the aims, mainly due to the lack of support from the middle classes and the Catholic Church. Extracts A, B, C and D provide evidence to support this view, but the extracts would have to be compared with other sources of evidence in order to ensure that the views given are not biased. Extract E says that despite their failure they did become legendary, as they managed to get William Gladstone and the British Government to recognize the problems within Ireland and inspired other groups, such as, the I.R.A to campaign further. ?? ?? ?? ?? Rebecca Johnson Mrs. Savage 8108 History coursework ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

  1. How successful were the British Government in brining peace to Ireland?

    The St Andrews agreement was published. This was a statement that said power sharing should be reinforced in Northern Ireland. To encourage all the political parties to get involved and agree the British government promised to provide NI with money. The political parties were also under pressure from the people of NI to agree.

  2. The Brighton bomber

    He hoped by killing the Prime Minister the government would allow the special status. He chose the Grand Hotel because he knew that the Prime Minister and other key government ministers were going to be there. It could be argued that any murderer should not be released early especially one that killed 5 people and injured 34.

  1. Ireland coursework-Part AIreland has had a lot of trouble over the years for many ...

    He said that he would not negotiate with Sinn Fein until there was complete IRA disbandment, "And that's not going to happen," he said. This article suggests that the 1998 peace agreement is in trouble because it is so hard to trust each other after the lack of trust that has built up.

  2. How far do the sources support the view that Irish Nationalism was an 'increasingly ...

    He talks of 'Christian' and 'charitable' ways of dealing with those who bid for a farm from which another tenant was evicted. However, later he implies violence by telling the crowd that he would like to see where they would get the men to make those who didn't pay rent, pay.

  1. 1. Why did the IRB and the ICA continue with the uprising despite the ...

    To conclude this question I believe that the Rebels carried on with the rebellion because they were desperate to make Ireland a free republic. They had waited for seven hundred years; the rebels were willing to do everything within their power to bring the rule of the British government to an end.

  2. The History of Conflict in Ireland.

    The Bogside is in the city of Derry, or Londonderry, the second city of Northern Ireland. It is a city in which there always had been a Catholic majority, but in which Catholics had been systematically discriminated against in terms of political power.

  1. "The Failure of the British to Solve the Irish Question Arises From Ignorance and ...

    Protestants, especially in the Northeast, were strongly pro British and saw Home Rule as the first stage towards independence from the UK. This was strongly resented for many reasons, such as the economic link favored by many industrialists. Randolph Churchill, a prominent member of Home Rule opposition, once said to

  2. How serious was the crisis in Ireland between 1909 and 1914?

    The passing of the Parliament Act was of tremendous benefit for the Liberals, since the Conservative dominated Lords were put in a position of little significance and no real influence. However, though the act had temporarily handicapped the Conservative most efficient means of manipulation, it had created a perfect opportunity for the Irish peers to prioritise the Home Rule issue.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work