• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In what respects, if any, could Weimar Germany be held to be 'doomed from the start'?

Extracts from this document...


In what respects, if any, could Weimar Germany be held to be 'doomed from the start'? Germany's first attempt at democracy, the Weimar Republic, established after World War One, had, by the late 1920s, failed and was beyond repair. The many problems during its fourteen years resulted in major support for extremists and what had been deemed one of the freest states in the world crumbled, ultimately leading to the rise of Hitler and his autocratic regime. The failure of the Weimar Republic in bringing about support for the callous and brutal polices of the Nazi party has consequently been highly debated and contested by modern historians studying the creation of the Third Reich. It is now understood that circumstances in the early 1930s did not completely render the Nazi state inevitable. Rather, a series of individual miscalculations and a long-term lack of support were to cause the fall of democracy in Germany in 1933. Although, in the end, catastrophic events such as the Wall Street Crash in 1929 are largely to blame for the republic's demise, many historians claim that faults in Weimar were already apparent from the start. ...read more.


Henig observed that the Weimar government's 'necessary political compromises and party deals were sordid and a far cry from the patriotic and orderly government of Wilhelmine Germany. Many yearned for a system free from conflict and from sectional interest and hankered after the elusive "national community" which they remembered from the early months of the war.iv' Although a return to pre-war politics was by the 1920s not viable, Weimar leaders did little to gain friends or support during the early years. Hans Mommsen, when comparing the structure of other post-WWI political systems on the Continent, has commented that the democratic principle only survived in a few states, with failures also in Poland, Austria, and even tension within the France political system by 1936.v Therefore there were inherent weaknesses within Weimar Germany, which, in retrospect, have caused some historians to see its failure as inevitable. Support for the republic was certainly weak, and there were indeed political failings that made any immediate solutions to the country's increasing economic and social crises almost impossible. ...read more.


The end of Weimar Germany was nigh. Chancellor Br´┐Żning's decision to rule by decree in September 1930 to restore authority and prevent further radicalisation was, according to Hans Mommsen, 'doomed because they ignored the very conditions of modern industrial society and pursued an illusory dream of returning to anti-urban social structures.vi' With the rapidly increasing resentment, the fate Weimar Republic had been sealed. By 1932, only 'a choice between authoritarian and fascist dictatorship existed.vii' It therefore remains that, whilst there were obvious intrinsic weaknesses within the Weimar Republic, the government managed to survive until an unfortunate and catastrophic series of events in the late 1920s. To conclude that Weimar Germany was 'doomed from the start,' does not take into consideration the measures taken throughout the 1920s to solve long-term social, political, and economic problems. As Ruth Henig highlights, 'Weimar Germany was a society in transition, experiencing the pressures of modernisation and of industrialisation.viii' Any attempt at changing the deep-rooted nature of Germany's political and social structure would be difficult, but failure was not inevitable. i Ruth Henig, The Weimar Republic 1919-1933 (London, 1998) ii+iii Gordon A. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Was The Weimar Republic Doomed From The Start?

    an office he was to fill with such distinction under four governments that he was called the greatest master of German foreign policy since Bismarck. He enjoyed immediate success with the acceptance of the Dawes Plan, which restructured reparations on the basis of Germany's ability to pay.

  2. Was the Weimar Constitution doomed from its very beginnings?

    new Russian communist political system, with the fall of the Kaiser, they saw an opportunity to place Germany in a similar system. In January 1919 they revolted, and tried to take control of Berlin, with the support of the USPD they proclaimed a new revolutionary government.

  1. The Failures of the Weimar Republic, 1919-1929.

    Instead, Germans voted increasingly for parties on the extremes the Nazis and the Communists specially, so that no governing coalition was possible. The Nazis and parties on the left held a sizeable majority in the Reichstag, but they could not ever work together.

  2. What problems did the Weimar Republic face from 1919 to 1923, and why did ...

    Communist rising 4. Kapp Putsch 8. Hitler's Beer Hall Putsch These are all political problems which made it difficult for the new German government to run the country properly. Economic 5. Reparations 6. Hyperinflation and the invasion of the Ruhr These are both mainly economic problems.

  1. Weimar, 1918 - 1923

    and Colonel Hans von Seisser (chief of the state police). The three men formed the 'Bavarian Triumvirate'. At the start of October 1923, the V´┐Żlkischer Beobachter unleashed a violent series of articles aimed at Stresemann and von Seeckt. Von Seeckt ordered the Bavarian government to suppress the paper and stop its publication; the triumvirate refused.

  2. How was Nazi foreign policy for the start of WW2.

    The biggest of these was the Treaty of Versailles. Not only did the treaty both humiliate and put to shame Germany, but also it devastated them economically. One of the first things that the Nazi government did in 1933 was begin to free Germany from this treaty.

  1. How far do the early problems of the Weimar Republic suggest it was doomed ...

    that the Weimar was losing a fighting battle and that someone else should take over. The rightwing were certainly not happy with a democratic system and longed for the opportunity to overthrow the Republic. This in turn linked on to further unrest in the already unorganised Germany.

  2. Why were successive Weimar Governments able to sustain Democracy during the period 1919-1933?

    The Dawes Plan in 1924, lead by US Banker Charles G. Dawes, helped Germany after the incident in the Ruhr, to pay their reparations payments more on their terms. The terms of this committee meant that Germany would still be required to pay the reparations, but after a period of years, it would be adjusted to Germany's ability to pay.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work