• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In what ways did the Irish Question change between 1800 and 1922?

Extracts from this document...


In what ways did the Irish Question change between 1800 and 1922? The Irish Question changed dramatically between the years 1800 and 1922. It had generated ever since the English and Irish connections had been made in the seventeenth century, when the Anglican Ascendancy was formed, which meant that Ireland was governed indirectly from England and so Irish became discontent. The 1798 Rebellion was the major reason for Britain becoming involved with Ireland. The Rebellion revealed to the British Government the weaknesses of the existing, divided system in Ireland; therefore the Irish Question needed to be addressed. At this point the Irish Question had arisen because the British were concerned about the 1798 Rebellion; they feared Revolution and didn't like the fact that Ireland was being used as a base for France. The Act of Union represented the first phase of the Irish Movement. It aimed to unite Ireland and England, to dissolve the Irish Parliament into the English Parliament, to allow free trade to England, 2/17 of Irish wealth was to go to England and 15/17 of English wealth was to be spent on Ireland. The Act of Union as a whole did not do much for Anglo Irish relations, because it caused more separation and disassociation. Even though Britain had to now take responsibility for Ireland, it was still treated as a separate country and Duke of Wellington later described Ireland as "the enemy's country". Before the Act of Union the divides between the English and Irish and the Protestants and Catholics had been fairly strong mainly because the Anglican Ascendancy. The Irish Catholics were annoyed because they had limited rights as a result of this and were unhappy as they had to pay tithes. The Irish Protestants gained more rights from the Ascendancy so will have been pleased, but the Presbyterians will have been unhappy because they too had to pay taxes. ...read more.


Gladstone was not unaware of the political advantages of Irish Reform and so in 1868 the Irish Question was placed at the forefront of politics and the Government agenda. The first of Gladstone's Irish Reforms was the Irish Church Act in 1869. This disestablished and disowned the Anglican Church in Ireland and destroyed its privileged status and taking over its property; therefore the ascendancy was solved. The second Irish Reform was the First Irish Land Act in 1870, which limited landlord's rights over their tenants and prevented evictions. This however did little to solve the problems of the Irish Rural economy and it was ten years too late, because the Irish Question had started to move away from this issue. It did inspire Irish Nationalism and paved the way for Parnell and Home Rule, because The Irish Universities Bill 1973 was the last of the Reforms, but this failed and led to the Liberals downfall in the 1874 election. This indicated that the Irish Reforms were having an impact of the make up of the British Government. The key point about Gladstone's impact on the Irish Question is that even though his reforms were unsuccessful as he could not keep up with the continuous changing of the Irish Question, he did avert violent rebellion and at least the British Government were seen as doing something. The Irish question after this point was about the Land question and Home Rule, because Parnell like O'Connell and Gladstone highlighted the role of the individual in shaping the Irish Question. The Irish Land League was created and Gladstone decided that Home rule was the only solution as the Reforms had failed and support for the Home Rule party had increased. The Land Question was important with the Irish Farmers as they found themselves facing agricultural depression due to the poor harvests and the cheap grain that had been imported causing food prices to decrease. ...read more.


The British Government would also be allowed naval facilities in Ireland. The Irish Parliament rejected this, especially the Oath of Allegiance, but they did say they would have some connection to the UK. Therefore areas of the Status needed discussing, so the Oath of Allegiance was watered down, Northern Ireland was allowed to opt out of the Treaty, but a Boundary Commission would be set up so that it would rejoin the rest of Ireland eventually due to immense criticism and the British would have three naval bases in Ireland. Finally on the 5th December at 2.30am the Treaty was signed, because Lloyd George had used the threat if you don't sign the Treaty we will go to War, which meant that they had no other choice because a war will have been unpopular with the British Government. The Treaty was very popular in Britain; therefore passed through parliament easily, whereas with Ireland it brought great discord and argument. It had been was a temporary measure to appease the split between North and South and to solve the Irish Question one and for all. In conclusion it can be seen that the Irish Question had a changing nature over time, because of the impact of certain individuals, such as Gladstone and Parnell and outside events in shaping the Irish Question. The attempts to answer the question were unsuccessful because they came too late which meant that issues were been addressed that were no longer important. An example of this is Land Act, which was passed too late. There were common links and themes that occurred, such as, when Britain gave harsh responses to events, which they did not plan and there were poor consequences of this. Many of the proposed solutions created more problems and it is clear that the Irish Question still had not been answered as the troubles still continued after 1922 and even to this day they still exist. ?? ?? ?? ?? Rebecca Johnson Ms. Savage 8108 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

  1. Development of Irish Nationalism 1798-1921

    He supported the C've party, and instructed Irish voters in England to vote C've The C'ves swept to power, and were guaranteed the support of the Irish in parliament. 1885 Gladstone announced as in favour of Home Rule. CSP switched sides.

  2. Northern Ireland - The Good Friday Agreement was created in April 1998, and then ...

    As the Irish Parliament was controlled by Protestants, they created laws to greatly restrict Catholics. These laws were called the 'Penal Laws' and were created in 1697 and were abolished in 1727. These are the main restrictions: - * No Catholics will be allowed to join the army or navy.

  1. Parnell and the Irish Question Why did Gladstone fail to pacify Ireland?

    although this did not mean that the Irish were any better off; the tithes still had to be paid but were now paid to the state rather than the Irish Church. Despite the fact that the Act 'solved once and for all the major religious grievance of the Irish Roman

  2. How successful was Sir Robert Peel's Irish policy (1841-45)?

    The situation under de Grey was regarded by Peel as "unjust... dangerous... and utterly impracticable." Heytesbury's arrival was supposed to assure the recruitment of Catholics into the magistracy and civil service, thus leading them away from what was previously their only option: Irish nationalism.

  1. "The Failure of the British to Solve the Irish Question Arises From Ignorance and ...

    Protestants, especially in the Northeast, were strongly pro British and saw Home Rule as the first stage towards independence from the UK. This was strongly resented for many reasons, such as the economic link favored by many industrialists. Randolph Churchill, a prominent member of Home Rule opposition, once said to

  2. The Irish Question

    Many Catholics however saw the Sunningdale Agreement as a way for the British government to try and reduce the blame for recent events such as Bloody Sunday. Many of the Protestant community of Ulster disagreed with the Sunningdale Agreement and displayed their feelings through a power workers strike, described by Eamonn Mccann in Source E.

  1. Why Did ‘Bloody Sunday’ Take Place? (Russian History Sources Question)

    Source E doesn't agree with the view that Bloody Sunday was caused by poor living in working conditions. This source just describes the trauma that a worker went through whilst being shot by a Cossack. It describes in detail the murderer's face and the victims eyes, but it doesn't give any reason why Bloody Sunday happened.

  2. Why was Ireland partioned in 1922?

    Catholics were 95% of the population in Northern Ireland, but only had 5% of the land. If Ireland had a problem, they had no way of communicating with London. This long-term cause of Direct Rule led in turn to a number of the medium-term causes of the portioning of Ireland.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work