• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is source F more reliable than source E as evidence about the lives of women in China after the first revolution?

Extracts from this document...


Is source F more reliable than source E as evidence about the lives of women in China after the first revolution? Life was hard for most women in China before the first revolution. In this essay I will be observing both sources; E and F, stating which I think was more reliable after having compared them. Source E was written by Jonathon Spence, a British author, in 1981. It is based on 'The Gate of Heavenly Peace.' The purpose of this source was to educate people as it was taken from a textbook. The fact that the source was taken from a textbook meant that the author would have to be neutral in his interpretations; giving a fair account for both sides. Therefore, this would mean that the source is reliable, in one aspect, as it has a balanced story line. In addition, taking into consideration that source E was in fact written by a British author, who uses the word 'abuse' for the events of the Chinese culture, shows that source E has a one sided, western, perspective. ...read more.


80% of women were poor peasants and the lifestyle still remained extremely hard, even after the revolution in 1911, which is another aspect of unreliability. The author also says that most people were ending the practices of foot binding and infanticide, which I know is true because these two things were outlawed in 1912. Therefore this implies that the source is reliable. Source F was unreliable in the way that it was highlighting the positive aspects of communism; to persuade people to join their party. This is merely because it was written by a communist, Hu Yepin. Source F was written in 1930 about life in the communist province of Jiangxi. Hu Yepin only talks about one area of China, therefore, it is not particularly reliable as it does not show and explain the overall lives of women. The fact that source F was written for a story is also another aspect in which we can question its reliability. ...read more.


I would say that I disagree with it. Source E and F are both unreliable in the sense that source F is written too close to the event and source E is written far away from the event. This is both a good and bad thing as source E has the benefit of hindsight, but at the same time information could have been lost and altered. In addition, source F is unreliable as it is written too close to the event so enough information could have not been collected; however, it would also be coming from a person who experienced the revolution. I say that I think source E is more reliable as there is more evidence and facts, whilst source F is vague. Source F is also polemically written and manipulates the women. I think that source E was also more reliable as the author, Jonathon Spence, was neutral in his interpretations and was writing for the purpose of education. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. China 1945-90 - source based questions.

    As source D portrays Mao's Cultural Revolution propaganda of the Red Guards smashing Mao's opponent. Throughout the country, revolutionary committees sprang up, taking power from the local government and party authorities. The scale and effects of the Cultural Revolution were frightening.

  2. Russia 1905-1945 Stalin - man or monster - source based questions

    Party to get rid of all the people who might oppose hom, particularly Bolsheviks who had been important in the past, such as Zinoviev and Kemenev. Stalin planned it so well that they were accused of organising the murder of Kirov and planning to assassinate Stalin. They were all executed.

  1. What happened to the Romanov family? - Study Sources A and B. Sources A ...

    This is manifest as Source A states, "the Tsar . . . were shot there" which is backed up by Source B which assumes, "the Tsar is supposed to have been shot" verified by the more descriptive and informing Source C which mentions that the "entire Romanov family had been massacred in the Ipatiev house."

  2. Chinese Revolution Sources Question

    Explain your answer. In this picture there are many people cheering for chairman Mao as they walk they hold a huge picture of Mao. The artist had drew the picture with everyone smiling in it as if there lives have never been better, so the artist is portrayed chairman Mao

  1. Stalin - Source based work

    Stalin never actually went on trips around the countryside. He stayed in Moscow speaking only to his dedicated followers and supporters. The painting is an example of Stalinist art where censorship was imposed on all art forms, which were obliged to serve the state and now had no true freedom of expression.

  2. Romanov Family Question F

    It is possible for both sources to be true, but yet highly unlikely because many people would not kill people separately, at different times and locations. Then bury some of the bodies in one place and bury some of the others in a different place.

  1. What Happened to the Romanov Family? - source related study

    This and other references between the two sources back each other up, meaning that the two sources are more likely to be reliable, as each can evidence each other. On the other hand it could be that both are unreliable.

  2. China: Great Leap Forward, source based work.

    The author says that they have 'no full picture' and that 'people only have stories to tell about starvation'. The source is very negative and seems to make all attempts not show figures of grain production and death. In source D it says that Khrushchev (The leader of the USSR)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work