'It was the work that women did during the war that earned them the vote'

Authors Avatar

Hannah Brinkley

‘It was the work that women did during the war that earned them the vote’

I agree with this statement because, although I believe that women would have eventually gained the vote, the war was a catalyst and got women the vote, as well as respect, quickly.

However, source H, from a history book written in 1980,  thinks that seeing the war as the reason women gained the vote is ‘a very simplified view’, and that in fact it did very little for women. This is because during the war women who worked in farms, hospitals and factories were resented rather and rewarded for their work. Also, it says that politician’s views were already changing and many believed women had the right to vote for bringing up children, so the war was only a small part of it.

Source I, also from a history book written in 1977 also says that the war, although one reason why women gained the vote, is a ‘rough generalisation’. It says that social and political changes that occurred due to the war created a mood that was ‘favourable to change’.

Source J, an extract from a speech by Herbert Asquith, the Liberal Prime Minister in 1917, contradicts these sources slightly. He said that he believes women should have the vote, firstly because the Suffragettes stopped their violent campaigning, and secondly because they contributed greatly towards the war effort. Asquith had formerly been against votes for women, when he was Prime Minister from 1908-1916.

There are many other reasons why women gained the vote after the war. Firstly, the suffragettes had been patiently campaigning for about three decades-the first NUWSS was formed in 1887. By 1990 it had gained the support of many backbench Liberals, as well as some Conservatives and the new Labour Party. Although the Suffragettes were not able to get the law changed, but they did bring more attention to the issue and put the idea into politician’s minds. Despite their campaigning, fifteen bills had been turned down by parliament for votes for women by 1900, and a Women’s Suffrage Bill was heavily defeated in Parliament in 1900. One bill looked like it had succeeded however; in 1911 a ‘Conciliation Bill’ passed its Second Reading by 110 votes. The bill allowed women who had control of a house or room to vote, or one who owned a shop worth over £10 a year in rent. Unfortunately the bill did not reach the House of Commons and so no actual law change took place.

Join now!

The Suffragettes were also a factor in the reason women gained the vote after the war. They were very different from the Suffragists because they were prepared to, and did, use violence and broke the law to try and gain the vote. Consequently, women’s suffrage was often front page news and got the cause a lot of publicity, though not always the good kind. They became very militant and forceful from 1912. The so-called ‘Cat and Mouse Act’ was a strategy by the government to control the disruptive activists. They were arrested but released if they went on hunger ...

This is a preview of the whole essay