• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Dunkirk was a great deliverance and a great disaster'. (AJP Taylor). Is there sufficient evidence in sources D to J to support this interpretation?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Dunkirk was a great deliverance and a great disaster'. (AJP Taylor). Is there sufficient evidence in sources D to J to support this interpretation? The evacuation of Dunkirk could be perceived as either a great deliverance or great disaster, because there were over a third of a million troops saved yet the B.E.F lost nearly all its artillery and aircraft and ships were also destroyed. I slightly agree with A.J.P Taylor yet I would probably lean towards it being more of a success. Source D shows a painting of the men at Dunkirk being evacuated by the smaller boats and bigger boats. This source gives across the view that it supports the idea that Dunkirk was a great deliverance because the men are queuing up in an orderly fashion, the boats are leaving successfully and there are no bodies wounded or dead on the beaches. ...read more.

Middle

I would say that source supports Dunkirk as not being a great disaster more than being a great deliverance. Source F shows British troops on the beaches at Dunkirk firing at German aircraft. This source is not as easy to tell if it supports a side on A.J.P Taylor's statement or if it agrees with it completely. The few British soldiers shooting could represent courage yet also could show the weakness in numbers we had in fighting troops and aircraft. I think similarly to source E that this source does not show Dunkirk as great deliverance more than being a great disaster. I say this because there is no possible way that the picture could be interpreted as the soldiers being delivered from that situation where there is no sign of rescue ships or encouragement. Source G seems to agree with A.J.P quite well because it states that, 'our men have gained in experience of warfare', yet also 'we have had great losses in equipment'. ...read more.

Conclusion

Source I is A.J.P Taylor's view of Dunkirk himself which obviously reflects his own statement. His points are that even though nearly the whole army was saved there were great losses in weapons, aircraft and sea vessels. His facts are all given in numbers which shows that he understands all the losses. I myself disagree with A.J.P Taylor and his view that Dunkirk was a great deliverance and a great disaster. I believe that Dunkirk was a great deliverance because even though military wise the B.E.F lost lots of equipment, basically the whole army was rescued and more importantly, as shown in source G, it raised the morale of the people back home greatly. Knowing that our army was back safe was a lot more important than some ships to most civilians and it also gave the newspapers the story of the heroic fisherman who saved the army which also raise morale. Yes, there were losses yet the British spirits were more important. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Mildred Taylor section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Mildred Taylor essays

  1. Dunkirk - Defeat, Deliverance or Victory?

    I feel this source is reliable because due to my background knowledge I know that there were thousands of men on the beach lined up orderly. I also know that men had to wade into the water to board boats because the beach was too shallow and there was no appropriate docking area.

  2. Defeat, Deliverance or Victory? Which of these best describes Dunkirk?

    We know that nearly all of the B.E.F were evacuated and many saw the evacuation as well improvised, well ordered and calm. Many regard Dunkirk as a psychological victory, for numerous soldiers and civilians Dunkirk boosted morale leading to a sense of bravery and unity known as 'Dunkirk Spirit'.

  1. The Evacuation of Dunkirk.

    Also it could have been another reason to give a popular version to celebrate the anniversary of Dunkirk 40 years after the war. M8 The German View at the time The Germans believed that Dunkirk was a defeat for the British this also had to be portrayed to the people of Germany.

  2. Was Dunkirk a defeat?

    of men on the beach lined up orderly and this source also links with sources 6 and 7, as both of these sources talks about men queuing in water. An eyewitness account of Sir Harold Franklin a Divisional Commander at Dunkirk, he says that reports of merciless bombing and the

  1. Was Dunkirk a Miracle or a Disaster?

    There were many books and interviews published about the tragedies of Dunkirk many years after the event. Brian Horrocks, an evacuee from Dunkirk wrote an autobiography about his memoirs of the event - published in 1960. He's an eyewitness that makes it a primary piece of evidence written on behalf

  2. Defeat, Deliverance or Victory? Which of these best describes Dunkirk?

    The officers did this to calm the troops. Having the author and the date mentioned shows that this source's reliability can be researched. As well as this the source is an eyewitness, so it is first hand therefore it is primary data. The author gives a good insight of what is around him e.g.

  1. Defeat, Deliverance or Victory? Which of these best describes Dunkirk?

    This source shows panic between troops and the Government. This was quite unusual as this message was given on the most successful day of the evacuation, when 47,081 troops were brought to safety. This source is quite reliable as the message is written at the time of the evacuation.

  2. The Evacuation from Dunkirk in World War 2 was a great Disaster for Britain. ...

    This is clearly an exaggeration of the reality of what the BEF soldiers were actually facing. This source does not tell us the number of casualties/fatalities or anything negative. The BBC was glorifying the victory of the British soldiers. However, this has limitations as because it was the BBC; a

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work