• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Nazi Policies towards Jews were Brutal but Erratic'. Asses the validity of this judgement about the consequences of Nazi Anti-Semitism in the years 1933-39 In the years after the Machtergreifung in 1933

Extracts from this document...


'Nazi Policies towards Jews were Brutal but Erratic'. Asses the validity of this judgement about the consequences of Nazi Anti-Semitism in the years 1933-39 In the years after the Machtergreifung in 1933, German Jews were subject to fluctuation levels of violence and intimidation at the hands of the Nazi Party and its supporters. The variations in intensity were the result of a number of factors including the occasion of the Berlin Olympics, and internal rivalries in the Nazi party about the best way to proceed with Anti-Semitic policy. 'Brutal' is defined in the Oxford dictionary as Cruel, harsh or savage,' and in consideration of this, Nazi treatment of Jews between 1933 and 1939 was certainly brutal. The earliest example of this brutality comes during the Nazi seizure of power in 1933, when Nazi SA troops assaulted and murdered an estimated 45 German-Jewish citizens. This type of random violence exemplified by the SA was carried out daily in 1933, with victims being hauled into 'Wild Camps,' places of torture and murder set up in abandoned factories and army barracks. Michael Wildt, an author described random acts of such as 'SA men kidnapped theatre director Paul Barnay and beat him with rubber clubs and dog whips so severely he was later hospitalised.' ...read more.


This law carried with it the premise that Jews were racially inferior to Aryans, and were thus unclean, and this would have been intensely insulting to Germany's Jews. The laws passed after Reichkristallnacht such as the yellow star law requiring all Jews to wear a yellow star on their clothes to identify themselves was another example of psychological brutality, and this particular law also incited a huge rise in random Anti-Semitic attacks as Jews became an visibly identifiable group. The treatment of Jews in Nazi Germany, for all its brutality, was hugely inconsistent for many reasons. Many of its policies seem to have been devised in a rushed manner, with, for example, the Nuremberg laws having to be altered after their original release to add a definition of the would 'Jew'. As well as this, a number of competing policies comprised Nazi treatment of Jews, a number of which contradicted each other in such a way that a workable policy was indiscernible. The way in which Nazi Anti-Semitism seemed to react to outside factors, rather than enforcing its policies on the outside factors made policies hugely changeable. An example of this is the way that the shops boycott was organised in an attempt to quell the acts of random ...read more.


Himmler, who was head of the SS division of the police, was primarily concerned with the expansion of the SS and its power Himmler therefore favoured a policy of forced emigration, in which Jews were forced to leave Germany through specialised emigration centres which would be set up. This policy had been worked successfully by Eichmann in Austria, who had forced over half of Austrian-Jews to leave the country for other areas of Europe. The chances of either of these plans being successful in solving 'the Jewish question,' was severely jeopardised by Goebbels' organisation of Reichkristallnacht (completely unbeknown to Himmler and Goering), as the rampant vandalising of Jewish businesses made it very difficult for a policy of Aryanisation to be remotely successful. It also contradicted Himmler's beliefs in violence 'behind closed doors,' as Reichkristallnacht was blatant Anti-Semitic violence and intimidation which attracted much negative foreign attention. In conclusion, Nazi Anti Semitic policy, whilst physically brutal, was more significantly brutal in a psychological sense through the acts committed against Jews and the discriminatory laws passed against them. The policy was erratic on a number of levels, including both its reactive approach to outside circumstance, and its internal dispute and lack of direction. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. How successful were the domestic policies of the Nazi Party 1933 - 1939?

    The car was also useful for propaganda, especially when the saving scheme was set up allowing workers to set aside money for their car. Nobody of course complained when they did not receive the vehicle. The economic policies were all part of Helmut Schacht's four-year plan.

  2. The Nazi Police State

    out all the stops in their attack on the Jews, but a week later things became horrendously worse still, as 20,000 Jews were sent to labour camps. However awful an experience life in labour camp was, the labour camps were not 'concentration' camps, and Hitler's 'Final Solution' was not put to action until 1942.

  1. How did the Nazi Policy towards Jews Change Between 1933 & 1945?

    The Night of the Broken Glass The Night of the Broken Glass or Kristallnacht was quite significant as it highlighted the complete downfall in the Jewish society in Germany. Jews in many areas tied to resist the Nazis. All too often this led to worse treatment than before.

  2. Between 1933 and 1945 Hitler and the Nazi Part were successful in their creation ...

    3Hitler started building the children's mind from the cradle, having steps of his youth groups, from the tender age of 4 years old, boys had to join the German pimpfen, while girls had to join the BDM. Steps of the youth organisation continued until the boys join the Hitler Jugend, at the age of 14.

  1. Describe how Jews were discriminated against in Germany from 1933 to 1939

    Even as the Nazis weakened in the last years of the war, precious military resources such as fuel, transport, munitions, soldiers and industrial resources were still being heavily diverted away from the war and towards the death camps.

  2. Why was Nazi opposition limited between the years 1933-39?

    that allowed Hitler to have dictatorial powers, for example his cabinet granted him 4 years in power as a dictator. The enabling act allowed Hitler to alter the constitution as he saw fit. Hitler then proceeded to dissolve all the other political parties and gained control of everything.

  1. How important was Goebbels both in the Nazi Party and in Nazi Germany?

    Speaking in the aftermath of the Stalingrad catastrophe, Goebbels stressed the grim truth that catastrophic defeat was a real possibility, and concluded with a rousing call for national mobilization. Goebbels' frankness and even courage won him a measure of popular admiration.

  2. Assess Impact of NAZI policies on the position and role of women in Germany ...

    The overall effect was marginal, as women were simply changing professions rather than getting out of employment. The overall impact was that a workforce was freed up for the emergency agricultural work of 1939-45. The % of women aged 15-60 in regular employment in 1939, was 52% in Germany compared with 45% and 36% in the USA and Britain.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work