'Only the great depression put the wind into Hitler's sails'. How far do you agree?

Authors Avatar

Lucy Sawyerr 10s

‘Only the Great Depression put the wind into Hitler’s sails’ (AJP Taylor)

How Far do you agree?

AJP Taylor implies that only the effects of the Great Depression led to Hitler’s rise in power. However, for Hitler a poorly educated, ex corporal to become the leader of one of the strongest countries in Europe, there must have been many factors involved leading to this staggering achievement. The Treaty of Versailles, the Munich Putsch, Hitler’s personality, the Weimar Constitution, the invitation to become chancellor and the enabling law all played an integral role to Hitler’s rise to power. These factors were all closely interlinked and ultimately led to Germany’s demise.

The Treaty of Versailles had inspired resentment in Germany; Hitler used this as a tool and promised to overturn the treaty. The Armistice of 1918 led many people to believe that the German army had been ‘stabbed in the back’ by the government. They felt that they had not lost the war and shouldn’t have had to suffer the consequences. The terms of the Treaty stated that Germany’s armed forces were 100,000 men, six battleships, no submarines and no air force. All of Germany’s colonies were taken away and became mandates of the League of Nations, and perhaps the most hated by the Germans, they were held responsible for the cause of the war and thus were subject to pay the astronomical reparations. Hitler blamed the ‘November Criminals’, Hitler professed that in order for Germany to be the strong nation that it once was, they would have to regain their lost land, especially in Poland,  to rearm and, perhaps most importantly put an end to reparations.

The Great Depression affected Germany greatly; the German people were starving, homeless and desperate for any solution offered to them. Hitler promised prosperity, security, national renewal and to restore a sense of dignity. The reparations, enforced by the Treaty of Versailles, could not be paid without aid from a country with economic stability - The USA. However, the Wall Street Crash of 1929 meant that the USA had to call in the loans. Without the money coming from America, Germany struggled to pay their reparations to Britain and France, who were also affected by the depression. With no loans and the lack of interest in Germany goods, the five main banks in Germany closed and businesses went bankrupt. After the collapse of industry many were left unemployed. The Weimar government could not deal with the unemployment and cut spending.  This meant that the unemployment benefits were cut and many former workers became homeless. Germany was in a state of desperation. Many Germans hand lost confidence in the republic and democracy; they were willing to turn to anybody that promised a solution. The German people turned to extremist parties such as Communist and Nazi. Hitler said what people wanted to hear, he promised job opportunities to the unemployed and better benefits to the homeless, his strong leadership was reassuring to a dilapidated Germany. In the 1930 elections the Nazi party gained 107 seats but by 1932 as the depression deepened, they had 200 seats.    

Join now!

The Munich Putsch was a turning point for Hitler, he realised that the only way he could control Germany was by taking power legally. His original plan ended disastrously, but it bought a new direction for the Nazi party. In November 1923 Hitler thought his time had come and attempted to take over the government of Bavaria. Germany was suffering from hyperinflation because of the struggle to repay the money owed to the allies as a result of the treaty of Versailles. Hitler hoped to take advantage of the misery and seize power in Munich. He hoped he would ...

This is a preview of the whole essay