• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Prior to the Good Friday Agreement in 1998, all attempts to bring peace to Northern Ireland had failed. If the Good Friday Agreement is to succeed, what problems will have to be overcome?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Coursework Assignment 3 - Prior to the Good Friday Agreement in 1998, all attempts to bring peace to Northern Ireland had failed. If the Good Friday Agreement is to succeed, what problems will have to be overcome? In Northern Ireland, there has been a large conflict in opinion over should be in control of the country for many years. Some people believe that Ireland should be united as one and should have no control or influence from Britain. These, Catholics in the majority, are known as 'Republicans' or 'Nationalists'. Others, Protestants, known as 'loyalists' or 'unionists' believe that Northern Ireland should be separate, at least politically, from the Republic and be part of Britain, possibly ruled from London like it is now in the wake of the suspension of the Good Friday Agreement, or that Northern Ireland should be part of Britain but have its own Government. Religion, Patriotism and political belief have caused a great amount of conflict between the groups. In each group, many parties, sub-parties and splinter groups have been formed, each one having slightly different views based around the same idea and using different methods than others. An example of conflicting groups on the same 'side' would be the range of Nationalist groups that exist. The SDLP (Social Democratic Labour Party), arguably the most peaceful Nationalist organisation, believes in using non-violent, negotiating methods to achieve it aims. The IRA, or Irish Republican Army, on the other hand, is a Catholic paramilitary well known for using violent, intolerant methods to achieve its targets. Obviously, the SDLP does not tolerate the IRA's methods in any way, even though they share very similar views and want to achieve almost the same thing. The same comparison could be made between Protestant organisations like the Ulster Unionists and the Ulster Defence Force. The two main groups in Northern Ireland have not been able to agree or compromise over many things in the past. ...read more.

Middle

The two groups do not trust each other, and believe that their opposites spy on them, as has been seen in the recent suspension of the Northern Ireland Assembly. The Catholics' trust and attitude towards Britain and the Protestants has far decreased in previous years. Excluding the British troops' behaviour in the Easter Uprising, some other events have made the Catholics mistrust Britain. In January 1972, 27 Irish civilians were shot in Nationalist Londonderry after a moderately peaceful rights march. At 4.07 PM on the 30th January a paratrooper asked permission to arrest some rioters who had stayed behind to confront the soldiers who had blockaded their route. Just three minutes later, the soldiers opened fire on the crowd, killing 14 innocent men, six of the just seventeen years old. While the soldiers maintain even now that the victims were armed and first fired upon them, there is no published proof to this day that the victims were carrying weapons. The Catholics of Ireland claim that 14 were 'executed'. A secret memo was discovered, dated three weeks before the incident, from a senior British Commander, telling the soldiers "CS Gas and rubber bullets do not deter rioters". He recommended instead that "the minimum force needed to restore law and order is to shoot selected ringleaders". This made many very doubtful of whether it was an accident that the Catholic protesters were shot dead. Many Catholic Paramilitary prisoners, in 1980, decided to fight for special privileges. They thought because they were not prisoners who had actually committed crimes, and were 'prisoners of war', that they were being unfairly treated, as a real criminal. They believed that they should get to wear their own clothes instead of the prison uniforms, and that they should receive a greater number of visits from loved ones and friends. To achieve their aims, they decided to hunger strike. 10 people died from starvation, including Bobby Sands, who ended up with 100 000 mourners at his funeral. ...read more.

Conclusion

So even if the agreement did come to a halt, the ideas should definitely not be scrapped because it has been seen that some of them, when put into action, do actually work. The government will also have learnt that other aspects of the agreement do not work. Even if the agreement is not scrapped and does continue, I believe the government should do their best to please every group involved as has been done in the Good Friday Agreement. The Government should try to persuade the Unionists to be more trusting of the Nationalists and the Nationalists to be more trusting towards the Unionists. The Unionists should be encouraged not to resign from the assembly every time a result cannot be reached, and the IRA and loyalist extremists should be promised better rights as prisoners the less violence is deployed, however, the cause of terrorist violence in Northern Ireland is of not easily detectable as the paramilitaries often use Guerrilla warfare and do not often own up to the violence. The decommissioning of weapons should be subject to a review and a compromise. Weapons should be monitored and given up step-by-step. The IRA should be scrutinised if discovered to fake disbandments, while the Unionists should be encouraged to communicate, even if they do not agree with an opponent's view, and should be more trusting of the IRA, as it is possible that one reason the IRA is bitter is because it feels it is discriminated against and is not trusted. Ideas like review of policing should be followed up whether the agreement is or not, because an end to discrimination could be a huge step towards peace in Northern Ireland. The ideas used in The Good Friday Agreement have not ceased, and should be followed up in the re-launch of the agreement or carried on to a new agreement, however, if a new agreement is formed, the ideas should be amended instead of being directly translated and repeated, as it would just result in a suspension like the one at present. 12/11/2002 Sean Starbuck | History | Coursework assignment 3 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

  1. Conflict in Ireland

    However this was not everyone's opinion and some Catholics were prepared to give Power Sharing a chance, as at least it was a step forward. Only a few months after the introduction of Power Sharing failure stuck and on the 28th May 1974 Power sharing came to an end.

  2. How successful has the peace process in Northern Ireland been?

    Talks were to be set up to try to decide on a new type of government for Northern Ireland. The only organisations to be involved in this declaration were ones which were not violent, for example the SDLP and the Alliance Party as well as the UUP (Ulster Unionist Party)

  1. How successful has the Good Friday Agreement (in Northern Ireland) been?

    Strand Two is a North/South ministerial council, and Strand Three is a Council of the Isles, which is made up of representatives from N.I, the Rep. of Ireland, Wales, Scotland and England. Other areas include the accelerated release of paramilitary prisoners, reform of the Police force (the Royal Ulster Constabulary),

  2. Why has it taken so long for the different groups in the peace process ...

    By this time it was too late. The Provisional IRA had already responded with a bombing campaign. This could well be seen as retaliation to protect Catholics, so we can see why no Catholic would want to see the IRA hand in their weapons.

  1. What are the main differences between Republicans / Nationalists and Unionists / Loyalists?

    However, the army soon began to get tough. They policed Catholic areas as if it were a huge military operation, raiding houses whilst searching for artillery belonging to the IRA. The alienated Catholic community began to see the British army as another weapon the unionist government could use against them.

  2. Has the Good Friday agreement meant that Northern Irelands problems are over?

    In 1999 the assembly collapsed and Sinn Fein was accused of spying. In 2000 Sinn Fein withdrew from all talks on decommissioning and the election of ministers failed when UUP members withdrew due to lack of decommissioning. Although terrorist activity has been on the decline, in 1998 the Real IRA

  1. The History of Conflict in Ireland.

    from Dublin, or Kerry, or whatever, who are the people that take control. And because they are the brunt of the campaign, they are the people who lead the Republican movement in a much more militant manner. They move out of Marxist vaporizing, which had nothing to do with pieistic

  2. The underlying cause of the conflict between Northern Ireland (Ulster) and The Republic of ...

    in Ireland, to try and convince them to stop the union with Northern Ireland. This war, known as The Irish War of Independence lasted 2 years, in which several 750 civilians were killed, which is often the case in any form of violent conflict.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work