• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Prohibition: Which of these two sources is more reliable as evidence against prohibition?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Study Sources E & F: Which of these two sources is more reliable as evidence against prohibition? The reliability of a source is important to historians and so in order to make a valid point using sources the reliability must be tested. For this reason, I will be looking at the reliability of both sources and by analyzing both I will determine which source is more reliable. Source E is in the form of a letter written in 1932 by John D Rockerfeller Jr. who was from a very recognizable and highly respected wealthy family in America at the time. They had one of the most powerful influences on the United States and had a personal wealth exceeding a cool $1 billion and the person who had the greatest share of this was John D Rockerfeller Jr. and thus making him a very influential business man in America. Due to the high standards and the highly respected status of John D Rockerfeller, source E can be said to be very reliable. ...read more.

Middle

'The day would soon come when the evil effects of alcohol...'He also believed that alcohol was a vile thing and caused corruption like the Anti-Saloon League and the Women's Christian Temperance Union. There are some aspects of the source which make it a lot less reliable. The fact that it is one persons account makes us question its reliability. Rockerfeller may be exaggerating the failure little especially since he was a huge supporter of Prohibition. This source could in fact be the view of a very narrow group of American Philanthropists where as on the other hand the general public may have had a very different view. Also, the source shows no references to actual facts and shows no figures which weakens Rockerfellers argument because it then shows that his points are more of his opinion and he doesn't specify and go into detail. He only generalises each point. Other sources like source G & H use facts and figures and so there reliability is valued more. ...read more.

Conclusion

Secondly, this source can also be seen to be highly bias, thus making it unreliable. It was a speech, meant to be heard and so bias views would be expected in order to convince people to support it prohibition. It is designed to persuade people and make the do what you want and so the source is can be said to not be very reliable at all. In conclusion, I find that source E is more reliable then F. It was written towards the end of the prohibition era and was not designed to persuade anyone unlike source F. The writer was given the advantage of seeing what was happening during the era and so his argument to me is more reliable and valuable. Source F can only be used to explain how and why prohibition came about and what affected the public's attitude. Source F can show that prohibition was started and the law makers had innocent intentions however source F shows haw badly it failed because it discusses everything that happened during the era and not what was believed to happen. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. Prohibition 1920 Sources Question

    of the alcohol would not have penetrated into the country, and less would have fallen into the hands of the gangsters. 6. Prohibition caused huge arguments in the 1920s, and massive corruption. Yet today it seems less important than the growth in the US economy in the 1920s.

  2. Does the evidence of source C support the evidence of sources A and B ...

    took it, it may not show Jarrow's true living and working conditions. It may be used as propaganda and show people to be ''happy'', whereas they are actually suffering. Overall source C supports source A because it shows that most people in the town were unemployed.

  1. History - Prohibition

    But some sources, however, are less reliable than others due to various factors, such as the time in which and by whom they were written. Source E supports prohibition. It was written by John D. Rockefeller Jr., who was a very wealthy industrialist.

  2. Was Prohibition bound to fail? - source related study.

    The sources support each other in that they agree about certain aspects, however they do not prove each other, as they are both questionable. (f) Do all the sources support the view that the failure of Prohibition was inevitable? Looking at all ten sources separately, it is impossible to say

  1. How useful is Source A as evidence for studying the spread of prohibition in ...

    Although these individual photos could also be staged and products of government propaganda campaigns, the ideas behind them are still correct so the proposed nature such a raid would still be there. Both sources have their strengths and their weaknesses, and both could be used for investigating the proposed nature of speakeasy raids.

  2. History depth study coursework-USA 1919-1945.

    As unreliable these statistics maybe, they do show an increase in the amount of illegal stills seized, gallons of alcohol seized and the amount of drunks which does show to some extent that Prohibition was unsuccessful, but these are only a portion of reasons for why Prohibition was unsuccessful. (e)

  1. Prohibition Sources Coursework.

    Source F is also a primary source. Source F was written by John F. Kramer, the first Prohibition Commissioner. This source was a quote from a speech he made in 1920, presumably just after the law banning alcohol was passed.

  2. Prohibition. In this essay I will be looking into prohibition, peoples opinions on it ...

    Source 'C' and 'D' are both for prohibition though they both show this in very different ways. Source 'C' shows it is for prohibition by stating that the 'Poor Mans Club' is well named, as it keeps its members and their families always poor.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work