• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Quarry Bank Mill

Extracts from this document...


History Coursework Question 1 Quarry Bank Mill QUESTION 1 --- STUDY SOURCES E AND F, AND THE SITE AT QUARRY BANK MILL. HOW USEFUL ARE THESE SOURCES IN ARRIVING AT AN ACCURATE EXPLANATION OF HOW APPRENTICES WERE TREATED AT THE MILL IN THE EARLY 1840'S? The Apprentice house at Quarry Bank Mill was originally built in 1790 but later more was added on. In 1800 there were 90 children ranging from 10-12 year living there. It was 40% boys and 60% because boys were thought to be more trouble than the girls. But the two sources I will be assessing do not show to follow this trend. In my essay I will be assessing sources E and F. Each from a different a person with their reasons to be one sided for or against the mill. The sources talk about an apprentice from Quarry Bank Mill, named Ester Price. Source E was take from the account of her punishment written by Robert Hyde Greg. This will automatically give the reader the idea that his account might favour the mill, because his father, Samuel Greg was the founder of the mill. ...read more.


During our visit to Quarry Bank Mill we visited the apprentice house. While we were there we saw many things like the fact the apprentices had beds with sheets. However the sheets the bed sheets were changed once a month and the beds were changed only once a year. This isn't very healthy as the apprentices didn't have washes very often. These beds would have two to a bed, while in work houses children would sleep on dirty floors, similarly towns like Manchester were suffering from overcrowding and often four to five families would share one small house. With a good nights sleep the apprentices could work harder. Maybe Robert Hyde Greg did this for his advantage, so he could get more out of the apprentices or was it because he believed the apprentices deserved these luxuries. The windows didn't open in the bedroom so during summer the rooms were very hot while in winter the rooms would be incredibly cold. The bedrooms would have bedpans under the bed, this meant that they didn't have to go outside but they would have had to fill up the pan until they could empty it. ...read more.


Both are one sided. Favouring with the author feelings. Neither gave an account from a neutral party. Robert Hyde Greg puts up a good fight, he explains the fact he had been involved in an incident involving the same Ester Price a year prior to her running away. Mr Greg' new way to deter running way was to chop off all the hair of the offender, (the Greg's did not believe in physical punishments). This was seen as a very harsh punishment. But still the punishment did not commence as Mrs Shawcross and Mr Greg's sister (Sally) thought it was far to ruthless. Therefore it shows The mill wasn't so tight on punishments. Because both accounts contradict each other at points it is hard to come to a verdict. Mr Greg in his account writes it in first person, this gives the impression that he was present for the mass majority of the events. While John Doherty seems to have a lack of information at points. Comparing the sources to our site visit many things can be connected. We visited the room in which Ester Price was locked in, and the room in which Mrs Timperly's body had been placed in. Both were adjoining therefore John Doherty's account correctly pointed this out. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Why did Samuel Greg establish a cotton mill at Styal in 1784? ...

    In the 1820's a shop was opened in the village and stocked food, household goods, clothing and millinery and a tailor was sent to the shop to fit customers. Workers could also raise their own livestock and then sell it to the shop if they chose to do so.

  2. Is Quarry Bank Mill a typical example of manufacture and production in a British ...

    These included; the Mill Manager, and the Overlookers who were in charge of each room. Operated machinery could be found within each room which prepared the raw cotton. There was the 'Carders', of whom the men worked the machines to straighten the cotton fibres.

  1. Why Was the Site for Quarry Bank Mill Chosen By Samuel Greg?

    Power was therefore essential in the cotton industry and a driving factor in Greg's choice of site Greg also needed to make sure he had a supply of labour.

  2. Quarry Bank Mill - source related study.

    working conditions and good care standards, as the children are described as not looking as well when they first come as when they have been at the mill for a while. However, it deals only with three aspects of work in mills and only shows a small part of the interview.

  1. Do these sources, and the site at Quarry Bank Mill, fully explain what working ...

    This quote suggests some of the positive remarks he made, " He leads you through a superb building... he gives you an excellent lunch." Engles is unable to criticise the appearance of the apprentices. In this source Frederick Engles complains he can not get to the real truth as Greg

  2. Why could the site of Quarry Bank Mill be successfully developed by Samuel Greg?

    Initially, he received capital from his uncle, Robert Hyde. Partnered with Nathaniel Hyde, they were wealthy Manchester manufacturers who made a fortune from owning a company which found a better way of organising cloth production other than traditional methods. In his will, Hyde left the �26,000 business to Greg.

  1. Why was the site for Quarry Bank Mill chosen by Samuel Greg?

    In total Samuel Greg had �36,000. This amount meant that Greg was in a fortune financial position. Samuel Greg knew that 90% of businessmen who went into cotton spinning at this time went bankrupt but Samuel Greg was fortunate to have a reserve of cash to keep him going in an industry that had a history depression and which might fail.

  2. Do you think Lumsdale was a successful choice for the site of these mills?

    From the aforementioned point, we can deduce that one of the few, maybe the only advantages Lumsdale had over Cromford was a bleaching industry was active in Lumsdale, so the cotton produced in Cromford could be bleached and dyed in Lumsdale, which would mean extra money for Cromford's mill owners.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work