• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Question 3 History Source D and E

Free essay example:

Study Source D and E. How useful are Source D and E in helping you to understand why the policy of British Government towards Independence for India changed after the Second World War.

Source D is a memoir written in 1945 by Stafford Cripps, a member of Labour Cabinet that won the election on reconstruction policies in Britain. Source D narrates to the historian that Britain was in a position where they could not cope with the concerns in India; therefore, they could not continue solving other issues that had a negative impact on Britain unless India participated. The Source clearly states that the British government was not prepared to stay for long in India. Stafford Cripps realizes that Britain needed to strengthen the control on their own home ground instead of ruling India. His motivation where: to give India independence and furthermore to use the resources to build up the defence of the British society. Cripps loyalty and effectiveness towards this occasion was reasonable, considering that he knew India inside out and wanted to improve the face of Britain. One obvious factor that was stated by Cripps was that it was hopeless to continue the responsibility with India. The memoir was written after the event, which suggests that he could be defending his own role by not telling the truth and not being neutral. This suggests that he could be exaggerating the belief of the historian of the true incident in some extents.

Source E is an eyewitness account in Calcutta in 16th of August 1946 during the Direct Action. The eyewitness is stating his view during the unpleasant issue in Calcutta. Calcutta was a city with all the religions, which could cause anger directed towards each other. Hindus and Muslims where fighting against each other because of their belief that the opposite religion wanted to rule India. The Source show that the situation in India was deteriorating rapidly. The Source is expressing that the policy in Britain changed because they could not manage to pay for the needed resources in India. The weakness of the source is that it is lacking details.

In conclusion, the sources imply to the historian that It was impossible to bring India together because of Direct Action, a time when The Muslim League where planning protests which followed by riots and this lead to religion antagonism. The conditions in which Britain was facing provoked them from ruling India. Therefore they had to persuade India to cooperate. Both sources combined are providing the historian with enough information to have an idea of the event. However, used on their own will give a different picture. Source D is useful because a member of the government published it but on the other hand, it was written after the incident. This demonstrates that the Source could be an exaggeration of what really happened. Source E is not useful because it does not answer the question directly but it may be useful for something else. I believe that there are other Sources, which would give a fuller view of the event.    

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

(?)
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related GCSE History Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. History: India Independence Coursework

    however, the source does have a weakness. It isn't specific on who the reporter is. 4) Study Source F and G Use Sources F and G, and your knowledge, to help you explain why India was partitioned in 1947. (12)

  2. The Rebecca Riots

    It's a letter he had written whilst touring through South Wales in 1804. He talks about how backwards agriculture farming was at this time, and there would be little point in investing because the quality of the land was poor.

  1. Question 3 History

    Some men hated the women altogether. "Males were vulnerable to conscription" suggests that the women worked so hard, and in some cases better than the men, that men would be pushed out of the job when war was over. Where they really putting the males out of the job?

  2. Northern Ireland Question 3

    The Anglo-Irish Agreement was an agreement between the United Kingdom and Ireland, which aimed to bring an end to the Troubles in Northern Ireland. The treaty gave the Irish Government an advisory role in Northern Ireland's government while confirming that there would be no change in the constitutional position of

  1. History Question Answer

    However, throughout the article emotive language is used in particular places, for example, one of the former soldiers attacked the new 'evidence' as 'rubbish'.

  2. Study Sources D and E and use your own knowledge.

    MPs from all parties joined the 'Conciliation Committee', which produced the Conciliation Bill. This was an agreement to give some women the vote. There were two main clauses in the bill which were to give all women who owned a house, part of a house or just a room, and owners of shops would also be able to vote.

  1. Cranleigh Railwat Reconstruction

    The main reason that the Cranleigh line was built was to link Guildford and Horsham on a direct route so that no changes on the journey were needed, but also because of the following reasons, so that the trains could carry people and goods from Guildford to Horsham and vice

  2. Suffragettes Question 3

    The government also had other problems of their own to deal with e.g. Ireland, which led to the women's request for the vote being pushed right to the back of the political agenda. It was reasons like this that led to the fall-out of women between themselves.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work