• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Question- study representatives 1 & 2. They are both representations of the way in which people in the USA reacted to the Vietnam War. How far do these representations differ?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History coursework: Representation 1 evidently was produced to discourage people from joining the army. It exudes a death -like demeanour, as a skeleton is being portrayed as Uncle Sam, it mimics the iconic original poster of Uncle Sam, albeit in an antagonistic manner. The very statement "I want you" seems like an unpleasant and unjustified demand and depicts that joining the Vietnam War would lead to a futile death. It portrays the eventual inevitability of dying if you take part in the Vietnam War. It seems obvious from this poster that at the stage when the poster was created that many Americans no longer supported the war and as the above writing states were trying to "unsell the war". ...read more.

Middle

I think the makers behind the poster chose this form as it is visually striking and brings the message across more effectively than a leaflet of facts. I think the author of representation 2, John Simpkin wrote his investigation as paragraphed analysis as it was the simplest way to list information and statistics. The representations were obviously created for contrasting reasons, one to disclose information, the other to discourage further people from participating in the War. Overall I think the sources are more different than similar. Although both noticeably give off negative depictions of the US army's role in the Vietnam War, which is interpreted through the quotes such as "US armed forces were also found guilty of torturing captured prisoners and innocent civilians" and the decaying skeleton in representation 1 I think the similarities end there. ...read more.

Conclusion

Source 2 was written when the Vietnam War had ended and the whole incident and its aftermath could be analysed. However I think the sole difference of each is the intent of each source. One is a completely unbiased piece of written literature reporting reactions to the Vietnam War, the other an invitation to a seemingly unavoidable demise, illustrating the horrors of the Vietnam War. By Eva Mathew Question- study representatives 1 & 2. They are both representations of the way in which people in the USA reacted to the Vietnam War. How far do these representations differ? How to get full marks: Analyse the sources and identifies a range of similarities and differences in representations. Uses precisely selected detail from the provided representations to support the explanation and makes a judgement about extent. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Vietnam 1954-1975 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Vietnam 1954-1975 essays

  1. American reactions to the vietnam war

    However the harsh image, and powerful anti-war message portrayed in this representation, clearly represents the polarised American society, at that time during the war. Representation 2 gives a clear and vivid view of how Americans with left-wing political opinions, pacifists and liberals reacted to the Vietnam War.

  2. Why are there different views about the influence of media on the course of ...

    was a result of the media who seemingly where against it also. I need to take into consideration the 'time factor' when assessing the reliability of this source and what it is inferring. The media might not have been as anti war as Horster is suggesting it was before he left for Vietnam in 1970.

  1. How was the opposition to the Vietnam war protrayed in contemporary literature, film and ...

    It is also heartbreaking to read in a poem about a friend dieing because these soldiers did not only see their comrades dead but witnessed them dieing which, must have been awful. This adds to the fact that the soldiers were helpless and they couldn't do anything to stop their friends from dieing.

  2. Vietnam Coursework Comparing sources

    The fact that Hamer is an American journalist makes this theory more reliable than the one presented in Source D, his criticism of American tactics exposing the fact that many people on both sides were strongly against the employment of military weapons against the civilian population.

  1. Vietnam 2

    In President Johnson's speech he says that they have a promise to keep. The promise was "the independence of the South Vietnam the freedom of the people of South Vietnam to guide their country own country in their own way".

  2. The Vietnam War.

    On December 23, 1950, a Mutual Defense Assistance Agreement is signed by the United States, Vietnam, France, Cambodia, and Laos; around the end of the Truman administration the United States was bearing one-half of the cost of the French of the French war effort in Vietnam.(Leone 34)

  1. Analyse and evaluate three representations of history: Protests against the Vietnam War

    Representation 3 focuses on particular people or groups such as the government ?Uncle Sam?, military generals, parents and ?Wall Street? bankers. The artist who created this song has selected details from that era such as Wall Street making money off the war ?there?s plenty good money to be made? to suit the message the representation is trying to give.

  2. How was opposition to the Vietnam War portrayed in contemporary literature, film and popular ...

    It also showed the violent nature of conflict and the bitter, cruel side of war. This brought the harshness of war back to Americans at home and increased opposition to the war greatly. The cinema also played a major part in the opposition to the Vietnam War.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work