• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Roman medicine was the same as Greek medicine; do you agree?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

´╗┐Sofia Chand Miss Smith and Miss Wheeler, History (RM31) Roman medicine was the same as Greek medicine; do you agree? Journeying from the Greek period of medicine to that of the Romans, how much changed and what stayed the same regarding medical practises, anatomical knowledge and accuracy of theories and ideas? Furthermore, which outweighs the other? Firstly, continuity between the two empires was that they both believed in the theory of the four humours. Originally, the Greeks established the theory, however, the Romans helped to develop this theory into something much more useful. Galen is the scientist who is most well-known at the time for working at the theory of the four humours. Like Hippocrates, he believed in the four humours but Galen thought that there was a more rational solution to balancing the humours. For instance, if the symptom was too much phlegm then the patient?s problem was caused by a cold and should therefore need to take something hot, such as pepper. Hippocrates laid the foundations for which the Romans then progressed, even though some of their theories were not entirely correct. ...read more.

Middle

Another key idea that both, Romans and Greeks, believed strongly in, was that gods and goddesses could cure and cause illnesses. This shows that religion played a really big part in their lives and outlines the theme of superstition in both empires. The Greeks had built Ascelepions as refuge to the sick; it was a peaceful temple where the ill could go in order to get cured. The Ascelepions were devoted to the Greek god Asclepius, the god of healing, and they firmly believed that at night, their god and his daughters would visit them and leave them cured. The Romans however appealed to their chiefly goddess of health, Salus. Gods were part of their everyday life and were expected to be powerful. When medical treatment was expensive, risky and painful, there was good reason to use every means available to help prevent illness. Asking for the help of gods would often be a first option instead of a last resort. A huge difference between Greek and Roman medicine was public health which means what the government or whoever was in power at that time did in order to prevent or cure epidemics. ...read more.

Conclusion

Overall, I would disagree that Greek and Roman medicine were the same and instead I would argue that in fact, they are very different. Greek medicine was very much based on loose theories and ideas as they did not have a plentiful amount of evidence to back them up, as well as this, the Greeks did not dissect or perform surgical operations that allowed them to explore the human body or animals that we?re similar too. This suggests that they weren?t as familiar with anatomy and disease like the Romans were. The Romans made sure they were educated in the human body and made some important links from dissecting animals that then formed stronger ideas that were quite credible in that day and age. The Romans were much more practical people and they also showed they had more ability than the Greeks. They were able to supply their empire with an extensive public health system that was very helpful and did actually prevent epidemics and look after their people well. Greek medicine was very different to Roman medicine. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Who made the more important contribution to the development of medicine, the Greeks or ...

    Hippocrates encouraged people to look for natural treatment rather that going to the Gods for help. He came up with the Hippocratic Oath and the aim of it was to give confidence in doctors. Abatons were built which were places where patients slept at night and were visited by Asclepius and his daughters.

  2. What Impact did the fall of The Roman Empire Have On Medicine And Public ...

    The Roman houses also had heated floors. This meant during the winter the Romans wee kept warm. The Romans also had a balanced diet. Galen believed the theory of the four humours but he had different ideas to Hippocrates. Galen believed in opposites, that if you were a weak person then you should do exercise.

  1. How Were The Roman Army Superior In Weaponry, Armour And Tactics To The Celts?

    This pattern is used on modern trainers today many centuries after the Romans did. (see picture) In comparison most of the Celts fought naked except for some 'trousers' below the waist. 'Some of them so far despise death that they descend to do battle, unclothed except for a girdle (Diodorus Siculus, History)'

  2. The Roman army

    soldiers received, which is illustrated in the extract below: "We owe our success against all other people to our skilful selection of recruits; to our teaching, as I mentioned earlier, of the use of weapons; to our hardening the soldiers with daily exercise; to our acquainting them in field manoeuvres

  1. Organization, Training and Discipline: How Did these Factors Contribute to the Success of the ...

    its excellent weapons and weapons training, I have not finished this bit! On the battlefield the Romans were even more organized, their tactics were possibly some of the most innovative and inspired in the history of the world. In battle, the Roman soldiers would stand with the shields in front

  2. Behavioural Theories.

    Comfort Barber Shop, established in 1906, seems to be the center of High Street popularity. The owner, Gael Montana, is the third owner of the barber shop in almost one hundred years of operation. She, along with friend and co-worker Jim Moore, give people hair cuts, gossip, shaves, friendly advice,

  1. Improvements in Public Health

    He managed to identify a water pump as the source of the disease. When he removed the handle the causes of cholera immediately declined. It took another six years before this theory was more widely accepted. John Snow also made development in anaesthetics and made them safer and more effective for use on humans.

  2. History of Medicine Revision Notes.

    into the cup if you had too much blood in spring 1. Clinical Observation[g]: Doctors had to follow FOUR STEPS when examining the patient: 1. Diagnosis: studying the patients symptoms 2. Prognosis: Predicting what course the illness will take 3.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work